Springboks v England: Five takeaways as 24-point margin ‘flattered’ visitors while ‘flawless’ Damian Willemse sweetened special night
Springboks full-back Damian Willemse and an inset of England's Ellis Genge.
Following South Africa’s 45-21 demolition of England at Ellis Park, here are our five takeaways from the Nations Championship clash in Johannesburg.
No side in the world lives with this South Africa
There’s no dressing this down. The world champions were magnificent, and the 24-point margin flattered England if anything.
Thomas du Toit ran through Ellis Genge, George Martin and Ollie Chessum for the opening try inside two minutes. Ox Nché thundered 25 metres through Chessum and Tom Curry with his first carry. Cheslin Kolbe stepped Cadan Murley as if he wasn’t there before finishing the second try himself, and England were 17-0 down after 12 minutes of classical rugby at a ferocious tempo, power carries killing the defensive fold, the recycle arriving before England could reset, pedigree greyhounds out of a trap.
And here’s the thing: it wasn’t even designed as a fast start. It was designed as an accurate one, and the speed was simply what accuracy looks like when every pass hits hands, every ruck is won in under three seconds and every decision is made before the defence has finished making its own.
Manie Libbok, freed of the tee and sharper than ever after his off-season work with Quade Cooper, ran the show with real authority. Kolbe kicked six from seven and settled that experiment for good. Once England‘s resistance had passed, the bench restated the gap. Malcolm Marx arrived to score off a technically perfect maul, make 19 tackles and monster the breakdown for half an hour. Ben-Jason Dixon went over off a scrum shove.
Rassie Erasmus even sent André Esterhuizen into the back-row for the last quarter, running a live experiment in a Test he’d already won. That’s now nine consecutive Tests in which the Springboks have scored four tries or more, from the team that ran in 81 tries last year, the second-highest total in their history. The other 11 teams in the Nations Championship were warned.
England’s discipline has gone, and South Africa are built to make you pay for it
England conceded twice as many penalties as South Africa, six at the breakdown alone, and finished with thirteen men as Marx and Dixon fed on the wreckage. Understand the mechanism, because it’s the whole match. Every breakdown penalty against this South Africa is a compound charge.
The immediate cost is territory, Kolbe or Libbok banging the ball fifty metres downfield. The secondary cost is the lineout drive that follows, the best maul in the world given a licensed platform. The tertiary cost is what the pressure does to tired minds five phases later, when the next penalty arrives because the last one emptied the legs defending it. That’s how six-floor penalties become an avalanche: each one buys the Boks 60 seconds of attack and sells England 60 seconds of defence at altitude, and the exchange rate compounds until someone’s judgement snaps. It snapped twice. Tommy Freeman went high on Damian Willemse and kept his yellow only because the bunker found some body contact. Guy Pepper followed within minutes for an early tackle with the Boks holding an overlap.
And the season-long numbers behind those two cards are the most damning indictment of the Borthwick era yet. England have collected ten yellow cards this year. Across their last six Tests they have spent more than 100 minutes without a full complement on the field, longer than an entire Test match, and they have conceded 95 points in those minutes. England are effectively playing every big game with an arm behind their back. Cards in Rome handed Italy history.
A lapse in Paris cost a Test England led. Now a final quarter in Johannesburg where a 10-point deficit became a 24-point hiding entirely through self-harm, the accuracy gap converting directly into the discipline gap, because the team making no errors never has to defend exhausted. South Africa’s brilliance killed England in the first 15. Their own indiscipline killed them in the last 30.
Add the wider ledger: 96 points shipped in two Tests, one win in six, and until this is fixed nothing else Borthwick does will matter. Even the crowd’s verdict was damning. Barely a boo from 52,790, because South African fans are past caring about this version of England.
They gave it to the wrong Damian
Damian de Allende was named Player of the Match, and with respect to a fine player on a fine night, they got the wrong Damian. De Allende made 14 tackles, won a match-high three turnovers and provided the midfield glue he has supplied for a decade. But Damian Willemse, winning his 50th cap on the same night as Kolbe earned his, produced the individual performance of the entire opening round in either hemisphere.
Springboks weather pre-game loss of Siya Kolisi and Eben Etzebeth to blow England away at Ellis Park
He ruled an aerial battle South Africa won 12-7, taking six clean claims that launched attacks. He hit a 70-metre 50-22 that bordered on cheek. He threw the step that took two England defenders out of the game and sent Jesse Kriel through the hole to break the fightback; the second defender’s eyes turned by the movement, and ran for 57 metres with two clean breaks besides. His involvements across the eighty were flawless. Five years of debate about his best position ended in Johannesburg. He’s a 10, a 12 and a 15 all at once, the second-playmaker full-back the rest of the world is still trying to build, and he was the best player on the park by a distance. That two men who have carried so many injuries between them since 2018 reached fifty caps on the same evening only sweetened a special Springbok night.
England’s hour of character was real, and it changed nothing
The middle of this match deserves its record. From 17-0 down with the aerial contest at 8-1 against them, England scored 14 unanswered points and went in at 17-14, and there was a Test match there to be won at half-time.
Genge answered his own high tackle with a defiant quick-tap try. George Martin thundered over off a designed three-phase strike play, Lee Blackett’s fingerprints all over it, swatting Wiese and Kolbe away, and until he went off he was England’s best player, his absence felt at the breakdown within minutes. Ben Earl was heroic, 21 relentless carries and 18 tackles in a tireless display. Seb Atkinson carried and kicked with intelligence, Fin Smith steered the recovery and struck a 50-22 of his own, and Henry Slade needed minutes off the bench to cut the line that made Alex Coles’s try. Three tries against this defence is proper currency. Most sides don’t get three in two attempts.
But the start of the second half repeated the start of the first, South Africa too strong, too powerful, too fast out of the traps, and everywhere the game was actually decided England came second. Beaten 12-7 in the air, where Marcus Smith had a torrid night at full-back after George Furbank’s appendicitis on the morning of the match. Beaten on the floor, six penalties conceded. Beaten in the detail, a try disallowed for hands at the ruck, a lineout slapped to the scrum-half’s feet with the game live. Rugby is a game of fine margins. This game wasn’t.
The Springbok machine doesn’t run on individuals
Siya Kolisi’s hamstring went in the captain’s run. Eben Etzebeth was pulled on the morning of the match. Replacing Etzebeth is like Queen replacing Freddie Mercury, you can’t, you just carry on as a different band.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
The frightening discovery of the day is that the different band sounded identical. Pieter-Steph du Toit moved from flank to lock, took the captaincy and put up 14 carries, 14 tackles and a clean break without a flicker of disruption. Paul de Villiers, given a debut at openside with a day’s notice, tackled and jackalled like a veteran. Cameron Hanekom switched from bench to starter and nobody noticed the join. That was 244 caps of leadership gone by breakfast and irrelevant by tea, because the clarity lives in the structure, not the personnel.
England fans were excited when they saw the changes on paper. Sadly, the enthusiasm was quashed when they remembered the game was played on the Highveld at Ellis Park, against a squad this deep and a system this settled. And in its way the whole day honoured the new tournament. Nearly 53,000 in Johannesburg watched the world champions treat round one like a knockout final, hours after a sold-out Christchurch produced a two-point epic, and Wales, of all teams, ended the day top of the southern hemisphere table on points difference.
If anyone doubted the authenticity of the Nations Championship, its first Saturday ended the argument. England have three weeks to show they belong in it.
READ MORE: South Africa v England: Result, match details, stats, line-ups