Opinion: Dave Rennie must rip up All Blacks blueprint but won’t as inmates run this asylum

The All Blacks fall to back-to-back defeats in the Nations Championship.

The All Blacks fall to back-to-back defeats in the Nations Championship.

Maybe that’ll prompt some honest self-reflection from the All Blacks.

They’re kidding themselves at the moment. The 37-12 loss to England was abject and even the team’s most ardent supporters would have to concede this is an average team getting worse by the week.

Their scrum’s pretty good, provided they’re not playing South Africa. The goalkicking is adequate, the haka is consistently excellent and then what?

The thinking, the execution, the physicality, the defence, the attack; none of them are up to snuff.

No idea

Teams routinely carve the All Blacks up on defence, creating space and line breaks in a way that they clearly have no idea how to themselves.

The self-reflection aspect is important, because it’s the players running this team. The same players that ran Scott Robertson out of a job have now delivered Dave Rennie five losses across an unacceptable All Black season.

They look uncoachable, quite frankly. They look like a team whose leaders are untouchable and who seem wedded to a style of play, regardless of how unsuccessful it is.

The Robertson era was baffling. After unparalleled Super Rugby success, he appeared to be a hopeless All Black coach.

England v All Blacks: Five takeaways as ‘wonderfully’ un-English performance delivers historic victory

The gameplan that served him so well at the Crusaders was strangely absent. Those teams kicked deep and won games with their defence, set-pieces and counterattack. They were desperate and ruthless.

Rennie’s All Black team is playing the same way Robertson’s did. And Ian Foster’s and the way they did towards the end of Steve Hansen’s era as well.

Someone, for God’s sake, take control of this team away from its gamedrivers. Beauden Barrett, Damian McKenzie and Richie Mo’unga have presided over a period of sustained failure – by All Black standards – and yet nothing ever changes. Except the coaches.

You figured self-preservation, even a bit of personal pride, would prompt Robertson to take control. Maybe he tried. Perhaps that’s why he appeared to face a mutiny towards the end of his tenure.

All Blacks player ratings: Another ‘terrible day’ for New Zealand as Peter Lakai ‘carries the team on his back’

Well, Rennie’s reputation is increasingly in tatters. The All Blacks deteriorate with every outing, as this team continues to insist upon shifting the ball wide despite its inability to catch and pass anymore.

They must be a dream to defend against. You just push up, hold your line and wait for an All Black to throw a speculative pass to a teammate who drops it.

The All Blacks don’t win lineouts, they struggle to make good reads on defence or to tackle and, despite being dished out a series of lessons by South Africa, Wales and now England, seem to heed none of them.

Worse than that, you sense a wilful determination not to. A self-regard that we know best, that the style we want to play is the right one and that we just have to execute it better.

Comprehensive loss

Well, I’m sorry fellas, but the record book suggests otherwise.

We’re yet to see who the All Blacks meet at Twickenham next week. But tell me, All Black fans, do you expect to see the team and gameplan overhauled? Or will we roll the same lot out again and expect a different result?

Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.

You can understand, if not quite forgive, the hiding handed out to the All Blacks by the Springboks this year but England’s another matter. They’re not nearly as good as South Africa and yet this victory was similarly comprehensive.

They were so much better across the board in this game that the All Black coaches really ought to be ripping up whatever blueprint they’re working from and starting again.

Only we know they won’t, because it’s the inmates that run this asylum.

READ MORE: England v All Blacks, LIVE BLOG: Coverage of the Nations Championship fixture