Ireland player ratings: ‘All-action’ wing rules the air while Joe McCarthy a ‘colossus’ as Springboks stunned
Rob Baloucoune and Joe McCarthy for Ireland.
Following a 20-17 victory over the Springboks in the Nations Championship clash at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday, here are the player ratings for Ireland.
15 Hugo Keenan: Magnificent under the high ball as Ireland had the better of the aerial battle, while Keenan was always there for mop up any danger. Also contributed plenty in attack as the Irish looked fluid. 7
14 Robert Baloucoune: Simply wonderful all-action display from the wing. The tries will get the headlines but Baloucoune was also incredible in the air as the hosts managed to negate one of the Springboks’ strengths. 9
13 Robbie Henshaw: Some have questioned whether the centre is still good enough for Test rugby, but he answered those critics with a fine display. Excellent on both sides of the ball with some deft touches to give them opportunities in the wide channels. 7
12 Stuart McCloskey: He has not quite been as exceptional as he was in the Six Nations but McCloskey has still strung together three good displays this month. The big Ulsterman constantly crossed the gain line and his off-loading ability makes him a duel threat. 7
11 Mack Hansen: Always scanning and looking when to inject himself, and he did so excellently once again. Hansen gives this Irish attack an extra dimension and it was his pass which set up Baloucoune’s second try. 8
10 Sam Prendergast: Again, lots to like from Prendergast, who is starting to look like a Test fly-half. Still plenty of areas to work on due to a few execution issues, but the attack has started to flow with him at the helm. 7
Superb again
9 Jamison Gibson-Park: Classy display once again with Gibson-Park making the right decisions on most occasions. The Springboks are experts at making the breakdown a mess for opponents, but Gibson-Park was very tidy around the contact area. 8

8 Dan Sheehan (c): A big challenge playing out of position at number eight, particularly against the back-to-back world champions, but Sheehan showed why he is a fantastically talented rugby player. He did get sin-binned for a needless croc roll late on, however. 7
7 Josh van der Flier: Struggled for consistency at Test level this year but this was a Van der Flier that played with real dynamism against the Springboks. Certainly not the most influential member of the pack but still a good shift from the openside. 7
6 Ryan Baird: The athletic forward has always been a talent but he has really stepped up this November. Has a great skill set but it’s his set-piece work which has become vital for Ireland in the Nations Championship with the blindside shoring up what had been a flaky lineout. He also did so much good work around the field. 8
5 Tadhg Beirne: Like Van der Flier, the lock didn’t have the greatest day against Fiji, but he stepped up nicely here, getting around the field and impacting matters in the set-piece and around the field. 7
Mammoth display
4 Joe McCarthy: The big lock colossus, who has the size to compete with the Springboks behemoths. McCarthy flew into contact, made a couple of breakdown turnovers and, altogether, had an incredible game. 9
3 Tadhg Furlong: There were big celebrations when Furlong was key to winning a scrum penalty in the first half, but that was as good as it got for the front-row, as expected. They weren’t utterly hammered like last year but the Boks very much had the upper hand. 5
2 Rónan Kelleher: Some performance from the hooker, who showed he can be a very effective starter having tended to play second-fiddle behind Sheehan. Kelleher’s throwing was accurate and he was exceptional around the field. 8
1 Andrew Porter: Similar to Furlong, his propping partner was under the cosh in the scrum, but Porter did so much around the field. He can’t get a high score as the set-piece was crucial for keeping South Africa in the game, but the loosehead was excellent in so many facets. 6
Replacements: Ireland did a lot right and the Boks didn’t, but it was the Bomb Squad that kept the visitors in it and made it closer than it really should have been. There were moments from Tom Stewart, Thomas Clarkson and James Ryan, but they simply didn’t give the impact of South Africa. 5
READ MORE: Ireland v Springboks, LIVE BLOG: Coverage of the Nations Championship fixture