Nations Championship permutations: How France, England, Ireland, the All Blacks and Springboks can reach the Grand Final

Who will make the Nations Championship Grand Final?

Who will make the Nations Championship Grand Final?

With a thrilling last round of the inaugural Nations Championship ahead of us on Saturday, and six Tests staggered across one afternoon and evening, here’s what every side needs to do to get through.

The top line

Last weekend really tore up the form book in both conferences, with France edging the Springboks 21-19 in a thriller in Paris on the Friday night and Wales surprisingly ending 73 years of misery with a 35-28 win over the All Blacks in Cardiff the following afternoon. The upshot is a final Saturday on which five sides can still reach the Grand Final and all six possible pairings are still alive.

Only two of them, France and New Zealand, can guarantee their place with a bonus-point win, so everybody else needs a helping hand from another team. Here’s the thing about Saturday: it’s played in order, so England and the All Blacks kick off at 14:10 knowing nothing, the Springboks run out in Dublin at 16:40 knowing exactly what New Zealand have left them, and by the time France kick off against Argentina at the Stade de France at 20:10, they’ll know precisely the points they need. In cricketing terms, France bat last, which in any run chase is the seat you want, because the target’s on the scoreboard before you take guard at the crease.

The table runs on four points for a win and two points for a draw, with a bonus point for scoring four tries, win or lose, and another for losing by seven or fewer. Sides level on points are split by wins first, then points difference, then tries difference and tries scored and, remarkably, should anybody still be standing after all that, we go to a coin toss. Undoubtedly Rassie Erasmus is minting a double-headed coin as we speak.

Saturday’s fixtures (all times GMT)

14:10 England v New Zealand, Allianz Stadium
14:10 Scotland v Japan, Scottish Gas Murrayfield
16:40 Ireland v South Africa, Aviva Stadium
16:40 Italy v Fiji, Bluenergy Stadium, Udine
20:10 France v Argentina, Stade de France
20:10 Wales v Australia, Principality Stadium

France, England and Ireland

France lead the North on 21 points and a points difference of +80, with England and Ireland a point behind on 20 apiece. England have a massive +134 points difference, with Ireland on +57. All three have won four of their five, and that’s worth taking note of, because wins are the first tie-break.

A bonus-point win against Argentina takes France to 26, untouchable and out of everybody’s reach, and then that’s them through. A four-point win takes them to 25, where only a bonus-point win by England or Ireland can catch them, and with five wins apiece, points difference would decide it. England start 54 ahead of France on that count, so France would need to defeat Argentina by at least 55 more than England beat the All Blacks by to go past them outright, whilst Ireland start 23 behind and need to win by at least 24 more than France do.

Springboks team: Five takeaways as Rassie Erasmus recalls ‘no respecter of the Irish’ and takes ‘cleaver’ to bomb squad

If France draw or lose, any win for England or Ireland puts that side above them, because even France’s best draw, with four tries, only matches a plain win on points, and the winner would have the fifth win to settle it. If neither England nor Ireland win, France can still go through depending on bonuses and margins, and the sum is simple enough: two more table points than France on Saturday puts England or Ireland above them outright, and one more brings them level and hands it to the tie-break process.

England and Ireland start level on points and wins, so whichever takes more table points finishes higher, and if they take the same, it goes to points difference, where England are 77 ahead.

For England, a bonus-point win against the All Blacks takes them to 25 and through if France draw or lose, as long as they stay ahead of Ireland; if France win without a bonus, England also have to hold on to that 54-point lead. A four-point win can still do it if France fail to win and England stay ahead of Ireland, and a draw or defeat leaves a route only if France fail to win and Ireland finish below England as well.

For the Irish, the clean route is a win over the Springboks, with France failing to win and England taking fewer table points than they do. A bonus-point win gets them to 25, but if France win without a bonus, Ireland need to win by 24 more than France, and if England match Ireland’s haul, the 77 points England have in hand on points difference have to go as well. There are routes from a draw or even a defeat, but both England and France would have to slip a long way.

All Blacks or Springboks

The South is just a two-horse race, with a point and a mountain of points difference between the two horses. New Zealand lead on 22 points with a difference of +66, South Africa sit on 21 with +138, both have won four, and that 72-point gap is the Springboks’ cushion if ever the two finish level on points and wins. The Boks need two more table points than the All Blacks on Saturday to go ahead outright, and one more puts them level with that cushion in hand.

Who’s hot and who’s not: ‘Cult status’ Wales, ‘overindulgent’ Springboks, All Blacks ‘stigma’ and ‘dinosaur’ Eddie Jones

New Zealand play first, so this is what each return from Allianz Stadium leaves South Africa needing when they play in Dublin later on in the day:

– Five points (a bonus-point win): New Zealand are through, whatever happens at the Aviva.
– Four points (a win without a bonus): the Boks need a bonus-point win, which leaves both on 26 with five wins each, and New Zealand would have to have won by at least 73 more than South Africa to pass them on points difference.
– Three points (a four-try draw): any Springbok win. A four-point win leaves both on 25, but South Africa would have five wins to New Zealand’s four.
– Two points (a draw, or a defeat with both bonuses): a four-try draw or any win, the four-try draw leaving both on 24 with the Boks’ points difference doing the rest.
– One point (a defeat with one bonus): three or more points puts the Boks through outright, and two is enough on the tie-break, because the All Blacks will have lost.
– Nothing (a defeat without a bonus): two or more points puts South Africa through outright, and one takes it to the tie-break, where a 72-point head start on a side that has just lost should be plenty.

Put simply, if England beat the All Blacks, the Springboks can reach the Grand Final without winning in Dublin.

The oddest final of the lot

The oddest Nations Championship Grand Final on the board is Ireland versus South Africa, and it would come straight out of Dublin. Here’s a scenario for you: say England beat the All Blacks 18-9 without a try bonus, Ireland beat the Springboks 29-27 with four tries, and France draw with Argentina. Ireland top the North on 25, a point clear of England with France a point further back, whilst the Boks’ losing bonus takes them level with New Zealand on 22, four wins apiece, and their points difference is the better by a distance. Dublin would have produced both finalists, and the rematch would come eight days later at Twickenham with the trophy on the line.

Everybody else

Scotland and Wales start level on 15 points and three wins each, with Scotland 20 ahead on points difference, so whichever takes the most table points on Saturday finishes above the other. If they take the same, Wales will need a 21-point margin swing to pass Scotland outright, that swing being Wales’s margin against Australia set against Scotland’s potential margin against Japan.

Nations Championship Team of the Week: Wales rock our Player of the Round as All Black slayers dominate

Either can climb to third with a bonus-point win and a big enough margin swing against an England or Ireland side that takes nothing from their game, and second needs both England and Ireland to lose without a bonus point, plus the swing against both. To pass Ireland outright, Scotland need a 66-point margin swing and Wales 86; against England it’s 143 and 163, which are cricket scores, and big ones at that. France are already untouchable and out of reach.

In the South, Argentina are third on 11 with two wins and Australia fourth on nine with one, and the Pumas secure third with a win in Paris, which is unlikely. Australia take third if they beat Wales and Argentina fail to win, unless the Wallabies win without a bonus and Argentina draw with four tries, and a four-try draw in Cardiff also does it if Argentina leave without a point. I hope you’re keeping up with us. Whatever happens, Argentina cannot possibly finish below fourth.

Japan, on five with one win, will take fourth if they beat Scotland and Australia get nothing, or if they win with four tries and Australia get only one, since the two would then be level on points and Japan would have two wins to Australia’s one. Fiji, looking for their first point, can only escape sixth with a bonus-point win over Italy (which is not beyond the realms of possibility), a pointless Japan defeat at Murrayfield and a 66-point swing to go past Japan on points difference. Italy, on a single point, are locked into sixth in the North and will face Fiji or Japan, so Saturday’s game in Udine could well be played again at Twickenham six days later.

Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.

Finals Weekend at Allianz Stadium

Every side is back in action at the Allianz from 27 to 29 November, first against first through to sixth against sixth. Here’s the card if the tables hold on Saturday, with the other permutations added (all times GMT):

– Friday 27, 16:40, sixth v sixth: Italy v Fiji, with Italy v Japan the only alternative.
– Friday 27, 20:10, third v third: Ireland v Argentina. France, England, Ireland or Scotland can face Argentina or Australia, but Wales can only face Argentina here, since the only way Wales get that high is a bonus-point win over the Wallabies, which keeps Australia out of third.
– Saturday 28, 13:10, fifth v fifth: Wales v Japan. England, Ireland, Scotland or Wales can face Japan or Fiji, and if Australia fall to fifth, they play Scotland.
– Saturday 28, 16:40, second v second: England v South Africa. France, England, Ireland, Scotland or Wales against whichever of the Springboks and All Blacks misses the Grand Final.
– Sunday 29, 13:10, fourth v fourth: Scotland v Australia. England, Ireland, Scotland or Wales can face Argentina or Australia, and if Japan make fourth, they can face England, Ireland or Wales.
– Sunday 29, 16:40, Grand Final: France v New Zealand. France, England or Ireland against New Zealand or South Africa.
The two games that make the most difference
– Of the six games on Saturday, the two most likely to rearrange our predictions are England against New Zealand, which can flip the South and put England into the Grand Final picture in the same 80 minutes, and Wales against Australia. If France beat Argentina and Australia win in Cardiff, the Wallabies take third and the Pumas drop into Sunday’s opener.

All very confusing, and I hope you followed our permutations. It’s been a brilliant tournament, and it says everything about the organisation that still nothing is settled as we move ahead to the final round.

READ MORE: Wallabies’ problems run deep and ‘sugar-hits’ from rugby league aren’t the solution