Ireland enforcer insists ‘there’s no fear’ against the Springboks despite last year’s scrum capitulation
Ireland scrum collapses against South Africa in 2025 and, inset, Joe McCarthy
Joe McCarthy has come swinging ahead of Saturday’s rematch with the Springboks, insisting there is no fear despite last year’s battering in the scrum.
Rassie Erasmus’ side broke Andy Farrell’s pack at the set-piece in their 24-13 win in November 2025. Too many penalties culminated in yellow cards for looseheads Andrew Porter and Paddy McCarthy.
With France getting destroyed in the scrum last Friday in Paris, the battle of the Irish and South African packs has generated plenty of interest ahead of next Saturday’s match in Dublin.
Second-row McCarthy missed last year’s game through injury, but he is champing at the bit to get involved this weekend. “Front-rows are very proud of their craft and all the back five as well, so we have definitely gone hard at it,” he told Virgin Media Sport about Ireland’s preparations for the round six Nations Championship match.
“Relishing that challenge…”
“Something we talk about a bit, maybe doing some extra bits in the gym, see how that correlates. It’s obviously been a year since that (loss in Dublin), but there’s no fear of that going in. We’re quite excited because they are obviously a quality scrum and lineout, but we’re really looking forward to putting our scrum on the pitch and just trying to go after them because it’s going to be tough, but we’re relishing that challenge.”
The French provided the Irish with the blueprint for how to cope with losing the scrum and still winning the match. Fabien Galthie’s side clung on to win 21-19 last weekend at Stade de France despite conceding multiple set-piece penalties, and McCarthy stressed that the Ireland mindset will be to attack the game, not just trying to contain the Springboks.
“I don’t think we’ll be looking to contain them. It’s not the mindset we’ll go in with. We’ll look to attack the game. We want to be dominant, put our game on them. With such a high-octane game, the France-South Africa game, I feel like a big area is those box kicks and winning the scraps and working back fast.
“And I also feel like when you play South Africa, when we have beaten them, you feel like every single contact matters. Like every single tackle, carry is going to matter in the game. If you leak a few metres, they’re on top of you; you’re on the back foot. In the carry, if you get smashed then they’re on the front foot attacking you, so we’ll go with the mindset that every contact matters.
Rassie Erasmus faces possible World Rugby sanction after questioning ‘match-fixing’
“Set-pieces, maul and scrum, everyone knows that is a big factor, but we have really targeted that this autumn and have got some world-class set-piece players in our team, so we’re looking forward to the maul battle as well. It’s one of those weeks where you have to make sure you hit your slot proper hard, extra hard in training to get you fired up for it. We’re looking forward to that.
“They are the world champions and the best number one side in the world, so that obviously sharpens your concentration during the week knowing you have to be on it, but we’ll just try and do our things as well as possible. You’re obviously going to look at individuals, look what they do in the lineout and things like that. That’s important, but you really have to kind of free yourself up and play your game.”
McCarthy picked out the break made by France’s Peato Mauvaka in the creation of the Louis Bielle-Biarrey try last Friday as something for Ireland to replicate when they host the Springboks. “Those moments when you’re working back to try and get on the scraps from box kicks is important. Being a bit unpredictable in their attack. Obviously, France are extremely good players who have pace and flair, but just maybe a bit of variety.
“Like, Mauvaka picked through the ruck, caught them off guard and threw an offload. If we can find play like that. France did concede a maul try, but I thought they did a decent job at defending the maul as well. There’s a few bits to look at, and whatever way you look at it, it’s going to be tough. You’re going to have to go to a dark place, but no, we’re looking forward to it.”
Eleven months out from the next World Cup, what would beating the Springboks mean for Ireland? “It would feel great. It’s kind of crazy; there is not that many games to the World Cup and that’s something we talked about.
“You want to be focused in the moment, but every game is a sort of a building block, and you want something to give you that confidence going in, so you have kind of marked landmarks on the way in. It would feel pretty good and it’d be good buzz for the Irish fans. It would be a special day to do that.
“You want to be going to the World Cup full of confidence. You can’t just say that we’re good; you want to have proper, marked evidence that you’ve done it. Going into World Cup would you want to get a few more of those milestones.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
“We’ve had great days against South Africa. You look to the World Cup (2023), and obviously that’s a few years ago, but it does help because we know we can absolutely beat them if we’re on our game, but if you’re slightly off it, they’ll punish you. It does give you confidence because we’ve been there and done that, but it’s a different beast now a few years on.”
McCarthy himself feels he is a different beast now compared to his 2022 breakthrough with Ireland. “My biggest improvement? My skill set has got a lot better just in terms of my ability, just taking restarts, handling, offloading, and I just see space; I run into a hole earlier or chase an opportunity attack which I probably wouldn’t have seen.
“In ’22 I was still effective somewhat, but I was a bit narrow focus and just running straight, running harder or in defence maybe just eyes on the man. My general skills have gone up and how I see the game, I see a few more opportunities which get me into better places. I feel like I have improved in a few areas.”
READ MORE: Why Tadhg Furlong wasn’t banned over alleged testicle grab: URC finally issues 22-page decision