Rassie Erasmus faces possible World Rugby sanction after questioning ‘match-fixing’
Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus and an inset of France's Esteban Capilla tackling Cameron Hanekom.
Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus could face another sanction from World Rugby after his latest rant on officiating and disciplinary outcomes.
Erasmus took exception to the fact that Tadhg Furlong escaped a ban for groping Munster’s Gavin Coombes after Jan-Hendrik Wessels was suspended for nine weeks for a similar incident last year. This came after he predicted that Ireland’s Sam Prendergast would be free to play against South Africa this weekend in the Nations Championship despite the fly-half being cited for a hip drop tackle on Fiji captain Peceli Yato.
The Springboks boss also hit out at the officials in his team’s defeat to France, claiming that Les Bleus made 16-17 knee-drop tackles that went unpunished. Both the hip-drop and knee-drop tackles were recently outlawed by World Rugby on player safety grounds. However, he was clearly annoyed by the lack of penalties against Les Bleus and the lack of sanction for Prendergast.
Potential sanction awaits Rassie Erasmus
According to a report by Sky Sports News, World Rugby will review the comments Erasmus made after naming his team to face Ireland this weekend in the context of the match official abuse sanction framework that was introduced earlier this year. That process was brought in to reduce comments that lead to ‘the unacceptable increase in abuse and threats towards match officials.’
Erasmus suggested that Northern Hemisphere nations are treated differently when it comes to disciplinary hearings, pointing to Furlong and Wessels’ bans, which leads him to think that Prendergast will be cleared for the clash at the Aviva Stadium.
“We are in the Northern Hemisphere; I think there’s going to be a technicality, and he’s going to play,” he said when asked about the fly-half’s availability.
Pressed for clarity on his comments, he added: “I’m not 100% sure how it works. I’m not a legal guy. I don’t have the right to say anything on it. I don’t have a pleasant experience here from going through Lood de Jager, Jan-Hendrik Wessels, and Franco Mostert. It never seems to go our way, and I’m not saying anybody’s doing anything wrong. I’m just not expecting him to get banned; he’ll play on Saturday.
“Like, Tadhg got three weeks (sic) for the same thing that Jan-Hendrik did. I don’t want to go into details there because I’m not a legal person, but from a South African point of view, that was that hurt; we felt it was more or less the same situation, and Jan-Hendrik got nine weeks and he got three.”
He added that the hip-drop tackle was ‘terrible’ and that Prendergast’s one against Fiji was a perfect example of what was discussed during the World Rugby meeting before this month’s Test matches. That left him puzzled as to why the TMO did not step in and highlight the incident with the referee.
“It’s difficult to understand when a TMO sits there, and he sees that, and it was something we discussed at the World Rugby meeting, and the examples of how it is were shown over and over; we’re all at input, and somebody sees that, and he decides there’s nothing wrong with that,” he said.
“So when you see that, and you decide that there’s nothing wrong with that, why do the other coaches or the other people what did Jake [White] feel, how what did that guy that got in carried off feel? We all thought it was an immediate red card. I mean, everybody watching the game live because that’s exactly what they said the hip drop tackle is.
“I swear I’m not moaning. I’m just trying to give you a perspective of somebody who comes and plays in France or Ireland – it’s foreign to us.”
France’s unpunished hip drop tackles
Erasmus then claimed that there were 16 knee-drop tackles that France were not pushed for during the match at the Stade de France last weekend. He added that he cannot understand why there is a push from within World Rugby to limit the TMO stoppages in matches.
“We should have lost against France. We deserved to lose. It’s just our own fault. But the other thing that was brought up at the World Rugby meeting was knee-drop tackles. Now I give you my word, there were 16 against us by France. 16 knee-drop tackles, and again, I’m not saying the referee didn’t see it or the referee didn’t judge it wrong, but I don’t understand the narrative that people want the TMO to stay out,” Erasmus continued.
“I’m going to say it as it is: for me, if you want a TMO to stay out, two things are going to happen; firstly, safety, which everybody in the Northern Hemisphere and South Africa and the world are promoting and saying, listen, the safety of the game is the priority. Head knocks, concussions, people’s well-being must be protected, and then the second one is that the right team must win. So if you see something that should be penalised or a yellow card, and you ignore it, the conclusion must be that you are influencing the result of the team or you are letting somebody get hurt if you see it.
“If you didn’t see it, it’s a mistake. I don’t understand why we had those meetings, and then in our game, I’m honestly now saying to you there were 17. Let’s say 11 of those I thought were at least a penalty, and three I thought were at least yellow cards, and not one was sanctioned and not one was shown out or cited, and I’ll send you the playlist, but I’ll get into trouble. I can’t send the playlist to anybody, and we can only send five clips to World Rugby. So we will probably query it, but the answer will be, ‘Yes, it was a mistake; they should have penalised that.’ The same with the Prendergast thing. So who am I to justify that? My gut feeling is he’ll play on Saturday.”
Match-fixing question
He also questioned that if the TMO is not intervening when seeing an incident that should be sanctioned or penalised, is it not a form of match-fixing.
“I’m saying if he didn’t see it, it must be a technology problem. If he saw it and he decided not to act on it, is that not match-fixing? Is that not interfering with the outcome of a game? If you see there’s an injury that happens there, there’s a knee-drop tackle happening there. It’s been decided that knee-drop tackles are out.
“Numerous times, we went to the referee and said we think there is a knee-drop tackle. 17 times in our game and not one was penalised, and if a TMO didn’t see it, well, maybe then technology must be better. If he saw it and ignored it, what does that boil down to? Manipulation of the game or the result, or players getting injured? So all I’m asking is: don’t take TMOs out and discourage them from getting involved. Then the wrong team will win, and players will get injured.”
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
He clarified that he was not accusing the officials of match-fixing, saying: “It’s not an accusation. Jake White’s team lost their hooker (sic) with a hip drop tackle that was three weeks ago at the World Rugby meeting, decided over and over the clip; this is the hip drop tackle now all of us who were there saw it. It was exactly what they explained to us there. Now the TMO sees it. Now if he didn’t see it, that’s a different thing. But if he saw it and he decided, ‘Well, I’m gonna ignore it’. What would you make of it? If he missed it live, different story. But if he saw it and he ignored it, what is that?”