Springboks player ratings: Marco van Staden’s ‘brain fade’ proves costly as Bomb Squad implodes
Springboks flanker Marco van Staden and an inset of Malcolm Marx and Morne van den Berg.
Following South Africa’s 20-17 defeat to Ireland, here’s how we rated the Springboks in the Nations Championship loss at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin.
Springboks player ratings v Ireland
15 Damian Willemse: Lasted just 25 minutes before he was forced off the pitch. Caught out a few times in defence before he left proceedings, as he was targeted in defence and under the high ball. Willemse hasn’t quite been his usual excellent self this November, and he struggled today, not his finest outing. 4
14 Kurt-Lee Arendse: Ireland were fantastic in the air and while Arendse toiled well, he was bested on a few occasions. Still, he had flashes of brilliance and stunning footwork. 5
13 Jesse Kriel: Some great defensive reads as he worked relentlessly throughout the match. Didn’t do too much wrong but wasn’t brilliant. 6
12 Damian de Allende: Forced off after the hour mark but again, another grafter’s shift from the powerhouse centre who set up Marx for a pivotal try. He was important on defence yet again, lining up against the excellent Stuart McCloskey. Remains a key cog in the Springboks‘ lineup, and they will hope his injury doesn’t rule him out of next week’s match. 7
11 Ethan Hooker: The Springboks flyer has been sensational in the air this year, but Robert Baloucoune perhaps provided him the best challenge yet. He held his own, though, and was a real handful for the Irish defence when he did get the ball. 6
10 Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu: Made a fantastic try-saving intervention to hold up Dan Sheehan, but Feinberg-Mngomezulu didn’t stamp his mark on the encounter, which was the case last week as well. He wasn’t poor, but he wasn’t fantastic either. 4
9 Morne van den Berg: Interesting that the scrum-half was on line-kick duties today and he did so well. He was live throughout and scored the ninth try of his Test career in just his 14th cap. When the Boks got more possession in the second half, he controlled the attack well as South Africa went route one. 7

The forwards
8 Cameron Hanekom: Two crucial breakdown interventions in the first half but it was very much a mixed bag for the talented back-rower who didn’t provide the same go-forward as Jasper Wiese has this year. He was hooked early in the second half but returned for Pieter-Steph du Toit. Only improved on his shift when he came back on. 7
7 Pieter-Steph du Toit: Led the defensive charge in the first half along with Mostert and was sharp in the lineouts too. Rarely has a poor game but wasn’t as impactful as he usually is. He was forced off to conduct an HIA and didn’t return. 6
6 Siya Kolisi (c): A quiet evening from the Springboks skipper as Ireland dominated possession for much of the time he was on the pitch. He conceded a penalty too and wasn’t overly effective with the few carries he did have. 4
5 Franco Mostert: Came into the team on the eve of the game in place of Ruan Nortje and as per usual, it was all work-rate from the veteran lock. He topped the tackle count for South Africa whilst the lineout operated smoothly when he was on the park. Always a trusted, solid performer. 7
4 Eben Etzebeth: First game back and Etzebeth grew into the match as it went on. Part of a lineout that functioned well in the first half and was a wilful carrier while pestering the Ireland kickers. A solid return to Test rugby from South Africa’s most capped player. 6
3 Wilco Louw: Forced a couple of penalties out of Andrew Porter in the scrum but the Boks weren’t absolutely dominant in the set-piece. Offered his heft on the few occasions South Africa had possession in the first half and was solid defensively. 6
2 Malcolm Marx: The lineout was flawless while he was on the pitch, while the scrum had mixed success. Marx bashed his way over the try line, grabbing his 33rd of his career, and was a pest at the breakdown. A world-class operator and proved it again. One of the best Springboks on the park again. 8
1 Ox Nche: A tough scrum battle with Tadhg Furlong after battering the Irish 12 months ago. On the balance of things, Nche got the upper hand, particularly as the Boks hammered Ireland with Van den Berg scoring. The best loosehead prop in the world and while he wasn’t dominant in the set-piece throughout, he still won the battle. 7
Replacements: So often the Springboks’ Bomb Squad came to the rescue and to a degree, they did until Marco van Staden’s brain fade. The flanker’s outburst after he was croc-rolled meant that instead of playing with a man advantage, it was 14 versus 14. It’s the second week in a row where one player’s discipline has cost the Springboks. The replacement front row did well, but Jan-Hendrik Wessel’s inaccurate lineout throws and conceded a pair of penalties that were silly too. Grant Williams was solid on the wing while Lood de Jager and Paul de Villiers were excellent in the loose. Ultimately, the Bomb Squad imploded when it needed to explode. 4
READ MORE: Ireland v Springboks, LIVE BLOG: Coverage of the Nations Championship fixture