England player ratings v All Blacks: Ben Earl ‘fundamental’ to victory as Pom Squad ‘explode’
Ben Earl (right) and Greg Fisilau (left) were among the key performers for England v All Blacks
Following England’s win over the All Blacks at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham, here is how we scored Steve Borthwick’s side from the Nations Championship Test.
England player ratings v All Blacks
15 George Furbank: Showed no signs of rust after returning from a groin issue, with yet another brilliant effort. His early 50:22, taken on the run and under pressure, was simply jaw-dropping; but away from that, his dual playmaking and running threat just added a lovely dynamic to this attack and ultimately helped get them over the line, and one that surely cements his place at the top of the depth chart once more. 8
14 Will Joseph: While he didn’t bag five tries today, he looked every inch a Test star in a fine shift. Made something happen whenever he was given the ball, churning through metres he didn’t have a right to make considering the defenders clinging onto him, and consistently put his hand up for carries. A nice way to continue his England return. 7
13 Henry Slade: Another really nice effort from Slade this autumn, as he continues to dismiss any doubts over the long-term future of the 13 shirt. Began the afternoon with a nice try, and carried on from there with some lovely flashes ball-in-hand; namely the solo break-and-kick in the build-up to Jack van Poortvliet’s score. One of a number of exquisite displays from this England backline. 8
12 Seb Atkinson: Like fellow injury returner Furbank, did not look like he’d spent a week on the physio table. His delicious, deft handling got the England attack purring, combining well with both F. Smith and Slade in the process, and added some serious heft when used as a punch runner. His try felt like a real turning point in the Test, coming at a time where England were looking to kill it off. 8
11 Cadan Murley: Chucked in at the last minute following an injury to Tommy Freeman, but goodness me did he take his chance. Seemed to have the All Blacks defence on strings at times ball-in-hand, carving it up with pretty much every touch of the ball and making things happen for the rest of his side in the process. Showed exactly what he can do in Tests like this, which will please Borthwick no end. 8
10 Fin Smith: He will be frustrated at the missed conversions, but that shouldn’t take away from what was a really nice display. His link-up with the rest of the backline and desire to play up-tempo played a huge role in getting England on the front-foot early doors, and his assist for Slade’s opener deserves some flowers. 8
9 Jack van Poortvliet: Took a conductor’s role today, and seemed to relish it. Kicked well when called upon, injected tempo into the play wherever possible and got a real tune out of the backline in the process. 7

Back-row
8 Ben Earl: You do start to run out of superlatives to describe Ben Earl in an England shirt, who was once again outstanding. He really seemed to grab the Test by the scruff of the jersey, making barnstorming carry after barnstorming carry and ending with a record-breaking 32 carries for 146, all while grabbing a nice try for his efforts. Was just a fundamental part of this victory. 9
7 Ben Curry: Complimented the rest of the back-row superbly well all afternoon, which in turn allowed the others to flourish. Rolled up his sleeves and went looking for work in the breakdown, as well as getting stuck into the battle in the loose. 7
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
6 Ollie Chessum: Probably his best outing in an England shirt yet, which is some doing considering his efforts to date. Owned every little moment he was involved in, be it at the lineout, defence or his nice role in attack as the wide forward, and that helped drive his side home in the end. His try was richly deserved too. 9
Tight five
5 Alex Coles: Will be very sore tomorrow after an industrious effort. As we’ve come to expect, ran his blood to water in the tight as he did all the ugly, nitty-gritty work to get his side playing on the front-foot. 7
4 Maro Itoje (c): Proper captain’s knock from the skipper, who continues to excel in this Nations Championship block. Had the bit properly between his teeth in an unrelenting effort up-front, and played his role well in the lineout. 8
3 Joe Heyes: Fared slightly better than his prop partner in the scrum, with tightheads very much getting the edge in their respective battles, and chucked himself about in defence as per. Solid. 6
2 Jamie George: England’s lineout was top-notch all afternoon, and he was at the heart of his with his pinpoint throwing. Got involved in the loose too, which rounded off a nice afternoon’s work. 7
1 Fin Baxter: Given a hard time in the scrum for the majority of his shift, but did look to get around the park wherever possible. 5
Replacements: The tone for the bench was set when George Martin came on and banged an All Black carrier with his first involvement, but the bench simply exploded. The initially-deployed grouping of Martin, Ellis Genge, Luke Cowan-Dickie, Greg Fisilau and Will Stuart made an immediate difference in the second-half, while Henry Pollock, Marcus Smith and Ben Spencer all had some nice involvements too. The Pom Squad is looking an increasingly big part of England’s gameplan now, and long may that continue. 8
READ MORE: Ireland v Springboks, LIVE BLOG: Coverage of the Nations Championship fixture