Opinion: All Blacks players are happier but 28-year low proves they are not much better
All Blacks head coach Dave Rennie and an inset of Rieko Ioane.
Dave Rennie’s first year in charge promised so much, but a 28-year low of five defeats in a season proves the All Blacks are not much better than they were 12 months ago.
Scott Robertson’s second-last game in charge was at this ground, and it was also a defeat (33-19). Ardie Savea was pictured leaning against the Twickenham posts, dejected, unhappy and staring into the abyss, and All Blacks fans shared his dismay.
New Zealand weren’t the force they once were, and the board agreed, sacking Robertson and bringing in Rennie to ‘get the team back on track for the Rugby World Cup’. It wasn’t just the results under Razor that led to his dismissal, but the squad’s morale too, as the players were not pleased with his management style and tactics.
So out went Razor and in came Rennie, and there was an immediate bounce, as there usually is with a new coach, with All Blacks playing with a renewed swagger, an attacking style more akin to New Zealand’s heyday and with smiles on their faces. Three wins in three set them up perfectly for a tour to South Africa, and victory over the Boks in the first Test gave them more spring in their step.
All Blacks start to limp
But from there, they started to limp. They lost three on the trot against the Springboks, twice in the Republic and once in Baltimore. Battered from a tour against their greatest rivals, the All Blacks regrouped and turned their attention to Australia and did what they usually do, swept them aside with ease to retain the Bledisloe Cup.
Again, the All Blacks were smiling, playing a style of play that they believe better suits their strengths: possession-based, ball-in-hand and using their ‘superior’ fitness to run teams off their feet. Against Scotland that worked but not against Wales, with a second-string team falling to a first-professional-era defeat to a lowly-ranked Welsh outfit.
It was a 72-year-first and a result that outraged former All Blacks and rightly so, with ‘first defeats’ becoming an ugly trend since Sir Steve Hansen relinquished control of the men in black. It was a second-string outfit in Cardiff, the one that Twickenham was not. It was the best available All Blacks team to Rennie, and they couldn’t stop more ‘firsts’.
New Zealand have now lost back-to-back Tests to England for the first time in 23 years, going right back to the Sir Clive Woodward England days. It is also the first time the All Blacks have lost five times in one year since 1998. Rennie also became the quickest All Blacks coach to four defeats, taking just 11 matches – it took Robertson 13.
But the All Blacks’ players are happier, right? They are playing a brand of rugby that suits them, with ball in hand, requiring the defence to make tackle after tackle and starving them of possession, right? At Twickenham, that answer was an emphatic NO.
Steve Borthwick’s charges battered and bullied the All Blacks en route to a 19-5 half-time lead, with the sole try New Zealand scored coming after Codie Taylor peeled off the back of a driving maul and Ethan de Groot powered over from close range.
When Nic Berry blew for the end of the half, England had 71% possession and 78% territory. The All Blacks’ up-tempo, possession and territory-based attack had been starved of the ball and completely outplayed.
From start to finish, it was all England, with the happier All Blacks hanging on by a thread and their brilliant defence inside their 22 – one of the few highlights of their game. New Zealand coughed up possession time and time again at the Allianz Stadium, with their renowned skill sets failing them when it mattered.
Same issues remain
In fact, England looked like the nation known for their brilliance with the ball in hand, with Fin Smith conducting proceedings wonderfully with his boot and decision-making in a masterful attacking performance. He threaded through a stunning grubber for Henry Slade to score the opener as the hosts punished the All Blacks’ indiscipline. George Furbank applied further pressure with a superb 50:22, and England would have been in, but again, the defence in the 22 repelled it.
Cam Roigard, inspired by the all-out-attack mantra of the team, took a penalty quickly deep inside his half before punting upfield. A daft decision only saved by the chase forcing an error from England, but again, this showed that the All Blacks were hell-bent on playing ‘their style’ instead of what was required in the Test match.
England kept bashing at the door and eventually kicked it down with Jack van Poortvliet diving over after more excellence from Smith to unlock the defence from a scrum. Even when the All Blacks did do something right, they managed to spoil their opportunities with Fletcher Newell knocking the ball on right after Peter Lakai won another turnover. From the ensuing scrum, Man of the Match Ben Earl picked from the base, sped past the non-existent defence, with Roigard simply a speed bump for the number eight who scored a try that should have never been scored at level – disgraceful defence.
De Groot’s try gave New Zealand something to smile about at the break, but that was it. The second 40 was no less kind to the Kiwis.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
As much as there have been improvements in their style of play and, clearly, the morale, the same issues under Robertson remain under Rennie. The scrum is still not a weapon against competent scrummaging nations, while their lineout is shambolic. For a team that wants so much possession, they are not making big enough strides to actually win the ball.
Ollie Chessum, Maro Itoje and Alex Coles wreaked havoc on the New Zealand lineout, with the former stealing Taylor’s throw early in the second half and then stuck to the touchline to rub salt in the wound and score. 67% was the final success rate for the New Zealand lineout, while the scrum wasn’t able to win penalties when it mattered either, and when it did, the lineout spoiled the chance.
The lack of game management was clear to see too. Time and time again, the All Blacks kept going through the phases, even when going backwards, with a refusal to kick. This led to turnovers, 16 in total, compared to England’s nine, with the All Blacks crumbling under pressure and ultimately succumbing to their fifth defeat of the year and dropping to fifth in the World Rugby rankings in doing so. And then there were there aerial issues which has been constant issue throughout the year.
Morale has improved. Results have not.
Discipline was a problem too, again a continuous from the issues under Robertson, as they conceded 10 to England’s even while the defence was carved up missing 35 and conceding 12 line breaks; England conceded just three.
An examination of the All Blacks’ year is now a foregone conclusion if the 1987 World Cup-winning captain David Kirk sticks to his word.
“I’d be pretty disappointed,” the NZR said earlier this week when asked if he would still believe they’re on an upward trajectory if they succumbed to England. “I’m sure there will be a serious examination if we play poorly at Twickenham,” he added.
“You cannot judge the match on the result; we could lose playing really well, it’s possible, so that’s what I would counsel against, but yes, a bad loss would be concerning.”
England v All Blacks, LIVE BLOG: Coverage of the Nations Championship fixture
This was a bad loss. A bad performance from a far happier team, but that happiness hasn’t produced a far better team. Context is important, and three of those defeats did come against the best team in the world, but the All Blacks are held to a higher standard by the New Zealand public, and this performance wasn’t acceptable.
Rennie has become the first head coach since John Hart in 1998 to lose five Tests in one year, and with one more game to go, he could become the first in the professional era and first since 1949 to lose six. Two more firsts that they desperately need to avoid.
The players may be happier under Rennie, but the same problems remain. A 28-year low of five defeats in a year is not progress. Morale has improved. Results have not.
READ MORE: England player ratings v All Blacks: Ben Earl ‘fundamental’ to victory as Pom Squad ‘explode’