Scotland v Japan: Five takeaways as ‘pale imitation’ visitors endure another ‘brutal’ outing against ‘two hat-trick’ hosts
Darcy Graham celebrates one of his first half tries for Scotland against Japan (Liam Chester Nations Championship/Getty Images)
After an 11-try, 67-5 win for Scotland against Japan in Edinburgh, Planet Rugby picks out five takeaways from the Nations Championship round six match.
The top line
Test rugby is drudgery when the outcome is so predictable, like it was in this one-sided fixture. Japan rang wholesale changes after the battering from England, hoping for an improvement, but against a largely second-string Scottish side, the visitors to Edinburgh didn’t have the durability to make it a decent spectacle.
Darcy Graham (6 and 31 minutes), Liam McConnell (13) and Kyle Rowe (20) all scored bonus point-earning tries from moves that had their genesis in play from far out on an afternoon where winning was accompanied by some champagne fizz, unlike last Sunday when the wet-weather Sunday afternoon fare was a dull, slow-moving slog.
Ollie Smith (40) added another to move the interval scoreline to 29-0, and eight minutes into the second half the best move materialised. Approaching the halfway line at speed, Graham put up a kick through that he raced forward to latch onto and then executed a sweet offload to usher McConnell in for his second.
That was class, but the Scots, having begun to call on their bench, were temporarily caught napping when a box kick bounced awkwardly and eluded Rowe, leaving Takuro Matsunaga to take a 53rd-minute consolation.
The unconverted score was only brief respite for the Japanese, however. Catching a kick and bursting clear, McConnell completed his hat-trick three minutes later, and further tries followed from Dobie (62), Smith (67), Hutchinson (74) and Graham (79) completed Japan’s miserable afternoon, which also featured yellows for Mamoru Harada’s 69th-minute hip drop and Michael Stolberg early 79th-minute tackle.
Jury still out on these Scots
Four wins from six in the Nations Championship group stage, following on from three wins in five in the Six Nations, is a solid return not to be sniffed at by Scottish fans, and yet plenty of grumbles remain about their boss Gregor Townsend. When you watch Glasgow play, you regularly get excited, but when you watch Scotland, frustration is too often the feeling given the way Townsend runs his team.
Last Sunday’s gruelling effort wasn’t the type of success to truly gladden the heart, but you must give credit to the SRU for managing to make Saturday’s predictable match a 67,000 sell-out. Those who attended can’t say they weren’t entertained, with the well-finished first-half tries the sort of scores that had fans forgetting the cold 3°C temperature.
The livewire Graham, who took his national try record to 41 with his hat-trick, set the tone and the hat-trick contribution of rookie back-rower McConnell was another welcome reason to cheer along on an afternoon that began with the traditional lone piper on the roof banging out an inspiring national anthem.
Overall, Scotland were a decent watch, but despite a calendar year record of seven wins in 11 outings, the jury is still firmly out on whether Townsend genuinely can take them to the next level, starting with next weekend’s Nations Championship play-off at Twickenham and the 2027 Six Nations.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
Japan’s basic errors
This was another brutal outing for Eddie Jones and his black beanie. Fresh from their Twickenham embarrassment, Japan didn’t cave in as quickly on this occasion, but clinging to life rather than asking a single proper question of the second-string Scots means this was another ordeal that doesn’t bode well for their Rugby World Cup 2027 chances.
If they had a team of Warner Dearns, they would be up there competing with the best, but sadly they are a pale imitation of the side that Jones lit up the world with in 2015. Basic errors kept on killing them. An example: they had more possession and territory approaching the half hour and yet found themselves 0-17 down to three annoyingly conceded tries.
A 25th-minute incident summed up their day: five metres for the Scottish line, scrum-half Naoto Saito knocked on trying to ferry possession away from his mauling forwards and it led to a knock-on that was quickly compounded by a free at the restarting scrum, giving the hosts an easy exit.
They were also unreliable without the ball and field position, as by that stage they had missed 10 tackles and were making do with an 83 per cent success rate.
The malaise continued – it was a stolen lineout that was the prompt for Scotland’s fourth try – and it wound up being very difficult for the Pacific Nations champions to find a sliver of genuine encouragement from this latest pummelling that they are going in the right direction 11 months out from Australia.
By the finish, they had 49 missed tackles and a 75 per cent success rate. That is just not good enough at this level.
Jordan at 10
This was a huge afternoon in the career of Tom Jordan, the 28-year-old trying to show he is the real deal at Test level. Having started last Sunday as an emergency, 11th-hour inside centre, Saturday against Japan was his 15th start but just his second as the No.10.
The sacred jersey has been the preserve of Finn Russell since he made his peace with Townsend after their falling-outs, so the pressure was on Jordan to show he can be a credible alternative with regard to running the show.
He started with a missed conversion kick and then a not-moving-away penalty with Japan having carried off the back of a scrum near their own line, but he started to come more into it from there without ever threatening the jaw-dropping exploits we have grown accustomed to from Russell.
It was a shame that it wasn’t a proper contest so that his abilities at No.10 could be credibly assessed, and he exited on 58 minutes for Blair Kinghorn. Scotland wound up concentrating on playing through their nine, with Dobie kicking 16 times to Jordan’s one.
Being on the ball was also a case of tipping it on rather than threatening, as just two metres were credited from his seven carries.
Jeopardy selection
Fijian Jone Naikabula was the player summoned to fix the chasm that existed on last weekend’s Japanese left wing, but just over five minutes were needed to realise he was another jeopardy selection who wasn’t going to work out.
Riku Tokito was handed a debut against England the poor 23-year-old was left embarrassed by his 28-minutes-long appearance went before injury mercifully took him out of the Will Joseph firing line.
Unlike the debut-making Tokito, Naikabula has 17 previous Test appearances, but he quickly demonstrated in the opening 13 minutes at Murrayfield defence that isn’t his forte.
His terribly attempted catch of a Jamie Dobie box kick was the error that invited Darcy to open the scoring, and he was then left chasing shadows in the Ollie Smith/Graham link play that set up McConnell for the second.
He wasn’t alone in being an exposed wing. Kazuma Ueda was nowhere to be seen when Graham set up Steyn for Scotland’s third in the opposite corner, and it suggests a serious weakness exists in the Japanese approach. If only union was a 13-man game where you didn’t have wingers.
Poor old Naikabula went on to top the missed tackle chart with seven, followed by full-back Matsunaga and outside centre Jisu Lee on five each. These flaky backs need to hurry up.
READ MORE: England v All Blacks, LIVE BLOG: Coverage of the Nations Championship fixture