Referee ‘wasn’t up to scratch’; if Springboks played that again, they would definitely win
Springboks and France captains Siya Kolisi and Antoine Dupont shake hands and an inset of referee Andrea Piardi.
Hanyani Shimange believes that the Springboks will beat France in a rematch, saying that referee Andrea Piardi ‘wasn’t up to scratch’ under the pressure of the Stade de France.
Shimmy’s prediction could be stress-tested depending on the results of the final round-robin weekend of the Nations Championship with South Africa and France both in the mix for the main event on Finals Weekend at the Allianz Stadium next week. If Les Bleus and the Boks top Northern and Southern Hemisphere tables after this weekend, it will set a rematch date at home of English Rugby next Sunday.
The French crowd
That will be an entirely different fixture, according to the former Springboks hooker, who believes that the Paris crowd influenced proceedings last weekend and Italian referee Piardi wasn’t up for the pressure he was put under to officiate a fixture of that magnitude.
“It was a slow start. I thought it was all France in the first half, all South Africa in the second half. But then again, pressure leads into points and we’re applying the pressure but not getting the points,” Shimmy said of the match on the Verdict show reacting to Rassie Erasmus’ suspension.
“The thing is with the French crowd is they’re probably the loudest crowd you’ll get and you look at Ben O’Keeffe in that World Cup quarter-final, you need a strong ref there to give you the reward and unfortunately, Piardi wasn’t up to scratch in terms of that.
“He probably felt the pressure from the French crowd; he was playing away from the scrums, playing away from the physical facets and it’s not him by himself. You also got to look at the rest of the officiating staff, the assistant refs, the TMO, how they couldn’t help him in terms of the tackles, those offsides quite a bit.”
‘Angry’ Springboks will be galvanised against Ireland after Rassie ban: ‘They’ll come out fighting’
Springboks will win a rematch against France
Erasmus took aim at the officiating of the fixture as he believed that 16/17 17 knee-drop tackles by France went unchecked and insinuated that could be a form of match-fixing. While Shimmy predicts a Boks win when the two sides meet again, he would not pin the defeat solely on the match officials.
“I think if the Springboks had to play that again, they would definitely win that game and hopefully we meet France again,” he said.
“But a game of what-ifs for the Springboks. We lost the game; they won; they showed heart; they showed passion.”
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
France took a 21-7 lead into half-time after Kurt-Lee Arendse’s try was chalked off just before the break. That buffer was just enough to secure the win as they failed to add to their tally in the second stanza.
It happened against the All Blacks
South Africa dominated large chunks of the second 40 minutes, particularly at scrum time but failed to capitalise on that dominance. When asked why they were unable to do so, Shimmy said that it’s not the first time this has happened this year and pointed to Piardi ‘bailing out’ of making a decision at scrum time.
“It’s just opportunities; it happened against the All Blacks when we chose the scrum over, over and over again. Eventually the ref looks for a bailout… and I thought that’s what Piardi did,” he explained.
“That last scrum was a penalty all day, but then also they don’t show the replay. So it’s move on, move on. Look, there’s a lot of refereeing error but also, we’re not innocent; we could have played a lot better.
“There were a lot of errors around key decisions that we didn’t get the rub of the green and it’s not complaining. It’s well done to France that won the Test, but I don’t think we would get another performance like that yet.”