‘F—ing mess’ pushed World Rugby v Rassie Erasmus to its ‘tipping point’ – Jim Hamilton
Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus and an inset of Jim Hamilton.
Jim Hamilton says frustration and confusion over the laws of the game pushed Rassie Erasmus to a ‘tipping point’ with World Rugby, describing the situation as a ‘f—ing mess’.
The former Scotland lock says that while rugby remains an ‘amazing’ product on the pitch, the game is broken off it and understands why that led to Erasmus’ rant and subsequent six-match suspension.
The way World Rugby is running the game
“I know there’s a frustration around coaches and players not being able to speak their minds properly, not being able to talk about things that need talking about,” Hamilton said in a monologue on his YouTube channel.
“The way that it’s set up now, with the referees being run by World Rugby, the lawmakers, and the referees being in that, there’s no real separation. I know a lot of the referees personally, and I don’t want to quote anything that anyone said to me, but I can sense frustration with these constant changes and iterations and evolutions of the law.”
The constant changes and amendments in the laws have made the job of officiating the game all the more difficult, according to the ex-second rower.
“I can feel the confusion,” he continued.
“I sense the confusion around the integration of the TMO when they come in to speak, and they’re under a lot of pressure. These lads have got a tough job anyway.
“There’s a load of stuff around the scrum which is going to be really difficult to fix, but around the change in tackle height that we’ve seen over recent years… and all of these conversational, anecdotal, literature that they have to contextualize on the field to the players to the stadium… It’s a f—ing mess.”
Unfair treatment
Hamilton says that Erasmus was the right man to take a stand against World Rugby; in fact, he stated he was the only one who had the ‘bollocks’ to do so. Still, he believes that his complaints were valid, particularly around the disciplinary action taken against Jan-Hendrik Wessels and the non-banning of Ireland prop Tadhg Furlong.
“I actually think it’s super important that he is the man because he is the man to bring up these things up… He’s got the video evidence. I’ve seen the videos. I’ve gone back and watched the game,” he continued.
‘Why is Sacha getting so much heat?’ – Shimmy weighs in on Feinberg-Mngomezulu’s Springboks form
“And I feel sorry for the referees because it’s changing every week. It changes in every competition: yellow card, red card, bunkers, can the TMO come in, what camera angles are you going to get? And I understand from Rassie Erasmus’ perspective that the South Africans do seem to be treated differently.
“They do, and I know the one that’s been brought up around Tadhg Furlong for the nut-grabbing or not-nut-grabbing incident that happened with Gavin Coombes, compared to Wessels with a witness statement and there was no conclusive evidence, and they went straight to that, and I get it.
“I can understand from that perspective: them trying to depower the scrum and trying to have more ball in play time, making the game less physical, and all of these things that are mentioned around the game and what they’re trying to do and what we need to do.”
Rassie v World Rugby
All of this has created an uncomfortable relationship between World Rugby and the Springboks’ head coach, one that was already strained by Erasmus lashing out at referees previously, leading to two bans before his latest one.
“There is the language element, Afrikaans and the other African languages that they speak, so we don’t really understand, and things are different when we come to the Northern Hemisphere. So he’s trying to suppress the situation by saying it’s maybe lost in translation,” Hamilton said.
“But we know that there is an issue between Rassie and World Rugby before he was putting out clips. For me, he’s the leading man in our game; he is the one who pushes the boundaries when it comes to the way that the Springboks play. He’s the one who first went with 7-1, who really dialed into hybrid players; he is the boss of his team, where nothing gets out.”
He added: “I imagine it’s uncomfortable for World Rugby, but I feel like we’ve reached a tipping point.
“I wondered when it would come. It’s been 17 days since the knee drop tackle’s been brought in, and Rassie has identified 17 in the game. I saw three in the last five minutes… That’s undeniable. The clips are out there. They’re doing the rounds.”
READ MORE: Referee ‘wasn’t up to scratch’; if Springboks played that again, they would definitely win