Ireland v Springboks: Winners and losers as ‘big men’ dominate and South African fans forced to eat ‘humble pie’

Stuart McCloskey and Marco van Staden image

Ireland centre Stuart McCloskey and Springboks back-row Marco van Staden (inset) were in the thick of the action in Dublin.

Ireland beat the Springboks 20-17 in a tightly fought contest at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday, in the final round of the Nations Championship pool stage.

Here are our winners and losers from the game.

Winners

Stuart McCloskey

Selected to start at inside centre ahead of Bundee Aki, the Ulsterman was excellent in the carry, beating four defenders to give the home side the physical advantage in attack. Defensively, he was solid, eventually teaming up with fellow big man Aki in the second half to smother the Springboks‘ attack.

Franco Mostert

Again, Franco Mostert defied his age, getting all over the park in another tremendously hard-working display. His superpower, besides being two metres tall, is his ability to work harder than almost anyone else on the field, and he exhausted himself with an impressive 15 completed tackles in just 43 minutes.

Malcolm Marx

Excellent in the lineout again, but it was his work in open play that set him apart, carrying the ball nine times and putting in a serious shift in the breakdown. His try midway through the second half was less about being in the right place at the right time, but more a result of his heavy involvement throughout.

Rob Baloucoune

Another two tries in the bag for the elusive Irish winger. He was again excellent with ball in hand, using his impressive finishing abilities to give Ireland an early lead. Although he failed to register any more points on the scoreboard, he continued to harass the South African line throughout, carrying the ball 15 times, breaking the line twice, beating three defenders and making over 50 metres.

Sam Prendergast

The 23-year-old playmaker was cleared to face the Springboks earlier in the week after a foul play charge from Ireland’s win over Fiji was dismissed. Prendergast put that incident behind him andput in a solid all-round display against the world champions. He missed some shots at goal but his tactical kicking was of a high standard while he also impressed with his playmaking skills and will be hoping to build on this performance when Ireland face Australia next week.

Cameron Hanekom

The 24-year-old is truly starting to make the shirt his own in Jasper Wiese’s absence. Although he wasn’t quite as flashy as he’s been in previous appearances, he proved a nuisance in the breakdown, winning some really important ball for his scrum-half, Morne van den Berg.

Morne van den Berg

He may still be fresh to the international arena, but he’s playing as though he’s been involved for years. Once again, he was terrific around the base of the ruck, leading all of the Springboks‘ attack, and was incredibly strong in the contact area.

Mack Hansen

Although the 28-year-old was overshadowed by fellow Ireland winger Baloucoune, he came to the fore with an impressive all-round performance. Hansen was in the thick of the action from the outset as he took the fight to the Springboks with ball in hand while also doing well under the high ball. His attacking efforts saw him finishing this clash with 37 metres gained which included four defenders beaten.

Losers

Damian Willemse

He was forced off the field early on with an injury, summing up what has been an uncharacteristically poor autumn for him. Go back three months, and he was overwhelmingly regarded as the best full-back in the game, particularly with Thomas Ramos out injured, but his form has certainly dwindled, and a spot out with injury certainly won’t help.

Springbok fans

After hurling a barrage of abuse at officials following their loss to France last week, Springbok fans will be forced to eat humble pie following their side’s loss on Saturday. No refereeing decisions can be blamed for their defeat to Ireland, who, simply put, were the better team on the day. A sharp grounding for the most successful team of the past decade.

Rassie Erasmus

The Springboks boss was forced to watch the game on television after accusing officials of “match-fixing” last week. But in true Rassie fashion, he’s made headlines again after potentially breaching his ban by allegedly speaking to his coaching team during the match. Erasmus hosted a ‘watch party’ with fans, but had his microphone muted for the entire first half and was seen speaking with earbuds in his ears while covering his mouth and reaching for his phone multiple times.

Hugo Keenan

A couple of mistakes here and there wouldn’t have been the end of the world, but being turned over four times certainly won’t be a statistic that he’ll look back on with any fondness. In some matches, losing possession won’t hurt, but against the world champions, it’s a risk that needs to be removed.

Marco van Staden

Marco van Staden was yellow-carded with eight minutes remaining on the clock. The main problem: it was totally preventable and completely unneeded. The Irish had won a ruck and were setting up the caterpillar before Van Staden threw his shoulder into the head of the sealing Irishman, reducing the Springboks to 14 men.

Dan Sheehan

In the same phase of play as Van Staden’s dismissal, Dan Sheehan performed a croc roll of sorts, taking his marching orders alongside Van Staden. With such close attention on these ruck incidents nowadays, to do it so obviously and at such a crucial time will have infuriated his coaches.

Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu

When will the young fly-half step up and have a genuinely good game against a top-level nation? There’s no doubting his immense talent, but his ability to control a game and shine at the highest level is yet to be realised. Against Ireland, he struggled to control the match, allowing his scrum-half to dictate play while he sat back and watched as the Springboks’ attack continued without him. If he’s to have the career that the likes of Handre Pollard and Morne Steyn had in a Springbok jersey, he needs to start work on his game management.

READ MORE: All Blacks player ratings: Another ‘terrible day’ for New Zealand as Peter Lakai ‘carries the team on his back’