All Blacks: How New Zealand’s media reacted to England defeat as team’s trajectory ‘difficult’ to gauge
All Blacks head coach Dave Rennie (inset) and his players ahead of their Test against England.
Planet Rugby looks at how the New Zealand media reacted to the All Blacks’ defeat to England in the Nations Championship Test at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham, on Saturday.
From the outset, the home side held the upper hand, racing to a 19-0 lead as Henry Slade, Jack van Poortvliet and Ben Earl crossed the whitewash, before Ethan de Groot narrowed the gap with a try of his own just before half-time.
It was a similar story after the interval as England continued to dominate, and soon after the restart Ollie Chessum went over for a try before Beauden Barrett scored his 51st five-pointer in his 150th Test for the All Blacks.
However, the Red Rose finished stronger as Marcus Smith slotted a penalty before Seb Atkinson crossed for the hosts’ fifth try in the 63rd minute, before the former succeeded with another three-pointer off the kicking tee to seal an emphatic win for his team.
England and New Zealand will now face off for the second time in as many weeks at Twickenham on Saturday in the Nations Championship’s third-place final after both sides finished in second place in the Northern and Southern Hemisphere tables, respectively.
New Zealand’s rugby writers did not hold back when assessing the Test, which was the most points the All Blacks have ever conceded in a Test against a Northern Hemisphere nation.
“The All Blacks never turned up – not the real ones – anyway and it’s hard to recall a game at this level in which New Zealand have offered so little: produced a data set that saw them trounced in every metric,” wrote The New Zealand Herald‘s Gregor Paul.
‘The real mission was going to be restricting the damage’
“They never looked like winning and from as early as the 20th minute, it was feeling as if the real mission was going to be restricting the damage – trying to keep the humiliation to a minimum.
“New Zealand couldn’t do anything right. They couldn’t catch the ball or hold it when they had it. They kicked too long. Their lineout was as likely to win the ball as a Soviet bakery was to produce bread, and they slipped off one-on-one tackles to let both Ben Earl and Ellis Genge run a mile each.
Head coach Dave Rennie admitted that his team were “miles off” and that the performance in London was worse than the one in Cardiff. No one would disagree.
“His honesty was refreshing, but the people of New Zealand are likely getting a little tired of hearing from beaten All Blacks coaches and wondering why it is happening as often as it is.
“This was the biggest loss the All Blacks have suffered to a Northern Hemisphere side and only the second time they have lost to England on consecutive occasions.
“The previous game against England last year was so bad as to ultimately lead to the removal of former coach Scott Robertson, but what do New Zealand Rugby (NZR) do now, because one year on, under a new coaching team, the All Blacks were worse.
“NZR can’t keep chopping coaches. But irrespective of that, the question still needs to be asked what is going on here, as a loss to Wales one week and then a hammering from England the next is hardly the stuff of legend.
“The trajectory of the team is now difficult to gauge; the results not so much. The five defeats the All Blacks have suffered this year equal the worst year of the professional age in 1998. But the all-important and subjective measurement of trajectory is still a mixed picture.”
Radio New Zealand‘s John Campbell also mentioned the All Blacks’ coaching situation and questioned some of the selections in the current squad.
“Take the coaches. As opposed to taking to the coaches, which NZ Rugby likes to do,” he wrote.
“Steve Hansen finished at the end of 2019. Since 2020, Ian Foster, Scott Robertson and Dave Rennie.
All Blacks were ‘way worse’ against England as Dave Rennie admits ‘I’m big part of that’
“Remember August 2022? NZ Rugby’s CEO, Mark Robinson, actually flew to South Africa, during the tour, to knock on Ian Foster’s hotel room door, death-row warden-like, before the players mounted a passionate defence of their coach by winning at Ellis Park.
“And then, it was Scott Robertson. Billed as the new messiah. Ridiculously oversold, the poor man. Who could possibly live up to that billing? Not him, as it turned out.
“New Zealand Rugby conducted a review (the phrase, “physician, heal thyself” springs to mind here), which is seldom good news when the review is of you. Sure enough, it was agreed he should go. (Agreed. Lol.) It felt shabby from the top. Great teams aren’t led like that. (And the players see it and know that bell tolls for them, too.)
“It felt panicky. Has that set in at a systemic level?
“Leicester Fainga’anuku as a back and a forward? Really? Why don’t we just make him the best one-of-the above that that gorgeously gifted (but not superhuman) player can possibly be? Richie Mo’unga recalled to the All Blacks after a three-year absence. Ruben Love was injured, yes. But it still felt hopeful, a coin toss, rather than a meaningful investment in something long-term.
“Fehi Fineanganofo, so brilliant with the Hurricanes that NZ Rugby lassoed him to hold him back from a lucrative deal with Newcastle. He got injured, sure. But if he was good enough to retain, he’s good enough to play.
“And if he’s not, what’s happened? It feels like a dice roll. And players aren’t dice.
“And now, I guess, discussions about Dave Rennie? Three coaches since Steve Hansen and we might now want a fourth? Wow.
All Blacks are missing Ardie Savea
“What’s needed, first of all, is some luck. The All Blacks without Ardie Savea are like fish and chips without fish. And chips. Ruben Love has to be supported to work.
“That kid is still only 25. He’ll deliver. If we let him.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
“Cam Roigard has to be given his head. Anyone can kick aimlessly, few people can create such defensive uncertainty on the fringes of tight play by passing like Aaron Smith and running like there’s space where there’s none.
“It’s the unpredictability that draws defenders and creates doubt and space. And, finally, or not, we have to stop telling hopeful stories about players we admire and are profoundly grateful for, beautiful servants of the game, but who maybe aren’t, ultimately, a long-term solution in a rugby world not scared of us anymore.
“Wallace Sititi and Pete Lakai (who’s still only 23, for goodness sake) are so exciting. Back them, back them, back them. Quinn Puketahinga Claude Tupaea (I just wanted to use his whole magnificent name), get better, stay well, and be the boss!
“And beyond that, beyond the player Lotto, we have to understand that even great teams lose. And it’s what you do next that defines you. Not what you used to do.
“The world’s onto us now. They know they can beat us and we know we can be beaten. Bummer, eh?
“But also, c’est la vie. It really is.”
READ MORE: Opinion: Dave Rennie must rip up All Blacks blueprint but won’t as inmates run this asylum