Springboks v Wales: Five takeaways as Rassie Erasmus left with ‘far more irritation than satisfaction’ despite sign of depth ‘deeper than the Indian Ocean’
Our five key takeaways from the Springboks' win over Wales
South Africa marked Mandela Day with a seven-try, 43-0 Nations Championship victory over Wales at Kings Park, handing four players Test debuts and completing a perfect July, yet the world champions will review a frenzied, error-strewn performance with far more irritation than satisfaction.
Here are our five key takeaways from the Nations Championship Test.
The top line
The Springboks finished their Nations Championship window with seven tries, a shutout and a scrum that reduced Wales to rubble, and still walked off dissatisfied, which tells you everything about where this squad’s standards sit.
Jasper Wiese, Cobus Reinach, Jesse Kriel, debutant Jaco Williams twice, Kurt-Lee Arendse and Paul de Villiers did the scoring on a humid Durban evening, whilst Wales extended a run without a single point against South Africa that now stretches back to 2024 and through last November’s 73-0 drubbing in Cardiff.
The gulf was never in doubt but in the final analysis, perhaps the champions’ sharpness was, and with New Zealand posting 40 clinical points on Ireland at Eden Park hours earlier, July closes with both southern superpowers on maximum points and only one of them entitled to feel completely pleased with their rugby.
A scrum destruction for the ages
The comparators for what happened to the Welsh scrum are not kind ones: Marseille 2007, Sydney 2013, Yokohama 2019. Andrew Brace briefed both packs to stay flat and straight, removing every angle and every excuse, and in those laboratory conditions Gerhard Steenekamp and debutant Carlu Sadie simply drove Wales backwards from first engagement to last.
Springboks rookies shine to nil Wales as Rassie Erasmus flexes depth in seven-try Durban victory
The second try was the destruction’s signature: Reinach broke off a retreating set-piece with the Welsh eight going backwards so fast they threatened to overtake him, the back-row welded to the bind and unable to detach, and by the hour both starting Welsh props had been hooked, a coach conceding the contest in personnel rather than words.
The law then supplied the black comedy, because the late yellow card forced Dillon Lewis back on for a second helping, and his first scrum folded on cue. At one stage, Wales were even penalised for pulling out of the contest, which rather generously assumed there had been a contest to pull out of.
South Africa, tellingly, needed only five scrums of their own all night and won all five, whilst feeding Wales 12, the statistical residue of the knock-on count. Two things kept the ledger from looking historic on paper: Aaron Wainwright performed regular miracles retrieving the ball from a disintegrating base, and Brace visibly (and naturally) eased off the whistle in the second half, managing the set-piece as a restart because refereeing it fully would have meant cards, a penalty try and carnage. The count understates it, but the eyes of scrum fans did not.
Wales fell apart, then stood up, and still couldn’t score
The opening quarter threatened total collapse. Wales missed nine of their first 20 tackles, a 55 per cent completion figure from the schoolyard rather than Test rugby, and South Africa averaged six metres a carry as runner after runner arrived off Reinach’s shoulder onto passive contact. Wiese’s opening try came through first-up tackles that amounted to a wave-through, and with the scrum gone and the clean-out failing to shift the first threat, Malcolm Marx helped himself at the breakdown.
From that position, the 73-0 script sat open on the table, and to their genuine credit Wales declined to read from it, dragging their completion back to 82 per cent by the whistle with Jac Morgan’s match-high 22 tackles leading the recovery. The bench transformed them a little; Ryan Elias arrived and became their best player, James Botham carried and scrapped, and a proper spell either side of the 50th minute produced four visits to the South African 22.
The returns are the heartbreak and the indictment in one list; Ellis Mee held up over the line, a three-man overlap butchered by comedic handling, and two raids killed over the ball by De Villiers. Morgan, beaten by Wiese’s line in the sixth minute, held up a 10-metre championship maul in the second half, and the shutout survived on that defiance until fatigue produced the sin-binning and Arendse strolled over unopposed from the cross kick, Louis Rees-Zammit stationed so far from his wing he was practically in standing in nearby Pietermaritzburg.
However, whilst he won’t be bigging anything up publicly, Steve Tandy will be quietly pleased his side made the world champions’ evening genuinely hard from a position of ruin, and the distance travelled since November is obvious; the side that leaked 73 in Cardiff frustrated the same opponent for long stretches here, held them scoreless for 22 second-half minutes, and forced the frenzy. He will be honestly aware, too, that the effort question was answered whilst the execution question was not. But, in the final analysis, the drought enters its third year, and effort does not appear on rugby scoreboards.
Four debutants, one doctrine, and an ocean of depth
Rassie Erasmus made 10 changes, started four new caps against a Six Nations side, and every one of them walked off examined and passed. Vusi Moyo’s 50 minutes at fly-half were promising but nothing more. 38 metres carried, tidy hands on a greasy ball, and one moment of genuine authorship, a cross-field kick weighted deliberately flat so no Welsh defender could set underneath it, won by fellow debutant Williams for Kriel to finish.
Williams himself produced the individual performance of the night, two tries and two assists on debut at his home ground, 56 metres and two line breaks besides. Sadie won a penalty with his first Test scrum and conceded nothing on his own feed; Ruben van Heerden added 11 tackles to a full engine-room shift, more than any Springbok on the night.
The Erasmus team design mattered as much as the talent he used; each newcomer was insulated by a veteran at the neighbouring post, Damian de Allende winning his 99th cap and Pieter-Steph du Toit his 98th either side of Moyo’s channel, with Manie Libbok and Damian Willemse a safety net on the bench that was barely needed. And the pipeline’s other stages were visible in the same XV, none more so than De Villiers, the campaign’s outstanding individual gain for South Africa; retained through all three rounds whilst everything rotated around him, he finished as the match’s top carrier with 16, won three turnovers including the two steals that killed Wales’s best spells, and emerged from the top of the pile with a first Test try from the closing maul.
When the Kings Park crowd rose on 67 minutes for Mandela Day, they were saluting a side whose depth runs deeper than the neighbouring Indian Ocean.
Judged by their own standards, this wasn’t it
And that is the standard by which this team asks to be judged. The platform was total; 58 per cent of possession, 60 per cent of territory, 12 line breaks to one and 294 post-contact metres to Wales’s 105. The execution on top of it was a feeding frenzy without first killing the prey: 20 turnovers conceded across the night, six of them handling errors inside the first half-hour, one contestable kick won from the first eight attempted, three missed shots at goal, and, most damning of all, 22 second-half minutes between the 41st and 63rd in which the world champions held every conceivable advantage over the 12th-ranked side in the world and scored nothing. Balls were dropped under advantage with the line begging, and a kickable penalty was declined for a scrum whose 10-metre maul yielded nothing.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
The repair jobs came from the bench, Libbok’s kicking game winning all six of his contestables after the starters had managed one all evening. And the defence upheld the jersey’s standards in full, because the nil was no accident: with complacency the obvious danger against twelfth-ranked opposition, this squad set itself the target of keeping Wales scoreless and pursued it to the final whistle, 94 per cent tackle completion, six misses all night, and a work rate through Wales’s best spell that survived the period when one more penalty might have brought a card.
40-plus points scored in all three July outings, and not one conceded in this one. The dressing room will be disappointed rather than dismayed, and that distinction is the healthiest thing about this squad: an environment where a 43-0 shutout leaves players vexed, where Williams and Libbok moved up the pecking order and the men who fumbled the frenzy moved down, is functioning exactly as its architect intended. But make no mistake, the harshest review of this performance will be delivered inside the Springbok camp before any of us publish a word.
Reinach gave the kids their platform
At 36, Reinach did the unglamorous curating that let the experiment breathe. His kick-and-return game set up the opening try, his step with ball in hand froze Rhys Carre to hand Wiese the one-on-one for it, and his break off the retreating scrum brought the second, whilst Moyo was eased into Test rugby with the hard decisions made for him for 50 minutes. Wales rarely forced him to play off slow ball, largely because Marx and the back-row kept stealing theirs. His replacement carried its own resonance, Jantjies returning for a first Test appearance since 2023 and combining with Williams for the debutant’s second try, a give-and-go between the doctrine’s past and its future.
South Africa and New Zealand now sit level on maximum points at the head of the southern pool, tonight’s margin fattening the points difference column that separates them, and the four-Test series between them in October will settle what July has only posed.
READ MORE: Springboks 43-0 Wales: Check out the stats, facts and more from the Nations Championship clash