Springboks legend slams ‘farcical inconsistency’ over Eben Etzebeth and France star’s eye-gouge bans as Jegou’s sanction dubbed an ’embarrassment’

Eben Etzebeth and Oscar Jegou's eye-gouging incidents.

Eben Etzebeth and Oscar Jegou's eye-gouging incidents.

The news of Oscar Jegou’s four-week ban has gone down like a lead balloon in some quarters of the rugby public.

The French star was given a slap on the wrist suspension for his actions that escaped punishment on the day, with the TMO missing the incident, despite the broadcaster providing a replay shortly after it occurred.

While the back-rower was able to play the remainder of the Six Nations tie, which France lost 50-40 in a result that ended their Grand Slam bid, Jegou was cited and faced a disciplinary hearing on Wednesday.

Habana slams light ban for Oscar Jegou

Ultimately, the panel deemed that the 22-year-old’s eye gouge on Scotland hooker Ewan Ashman was ‘reckless’ rather than ‘intentional’ – a crucial decision as the latter warrants a far more severe sanction.

“In applying World Rugby’s sanctioning provisions, the independent Disciplinary Committee determined that the low-end entry point of six weeks was appropriate in light of the fact that (among other reasons) there was no injury caused to the victim,” a Six Nations statement read.

“In light of mitigating factors (including the player’s good conduct and good disciplinary record), the independent Disciplinary Committee applied a two-week reduction in sanction, thus reducing the final sanction to four weeks.

“There were no aggravating factors to increase the sanction.”

Jegou’s suspension pales in comparison to that of Eben Etzebeth with the Springboks lock hammered with a 12-game ban, three times the length of the Frenchman’s.

In fact, his ban doesn’t even crack the top 16 suspensions handed out in the last 20 years for eye-gouging, as it’s half the length of Schalk Burger’s eight-game ban back in 2009.

One of Burger’s former teammates, Bryan Habana, has voiced his dismay in the decision, taking to social media platform X, posting an image featuring Etzebeth and Jegou.

“Numerous replays provided for French referee and TMO. Red card given during the game, ‘mid-range entry point. Eighteen-week ban reduced to twelve weeks for ‘good disciplinary record’ and ‘guilty plea and remorse’,” read the text next to the image of Etzebeth.

With text next to Jegou reading: “‘Reckless’ contact with the eye(s). Somehow not seen by Australian referee or TMO. Red given after citing, ‘low-end entry point’. Six-week band reduced to four weeks for ‘good disciplinary record’ and ‘no injury caused to victim’.

The Springboks legend posted the image with the caption “The inconsistency is just farcical!!!”

Eben Etzebeth breaks his silence with three videos providing ‘more context’ to eye-gouging and apologises to Springboks fans

Popular rugby account @Rugby_Ap replied: “Biggest issue, Bryan, is that it was deemed ‘reckless’ and not ‘intentional’. He had a clear line of sight and went back for a second gouge. I struggle to understand on what basis they adjudged it not to be intentional.

“Reminder that JH Wessels was banned for 12 weeks with 0 video evidence, just testimony. Testimony alone was deemed enough to construe intent, but clear video evidence in this case is not sufficient. Very odd indeed.”

Opinion: URC suspensions ‘stink of incompetence if not blatant bias’ as Springbok banned on hearsay while UFC-outlawed act overlooked

Fans and journalists weigh in

Several fans and pundits felt that the sanction was light and Jegou was ultimately fortunate without comparing the two incidents.

“Oscar Jegou only getting a 4 week ban for having 2 good shots at eye gouging is frankly an embarrassment,” one fan remarked.

With broadcaster Andrew McKenna agreeing in another post: “I am going to come off the long run here … Oscar Jegou is a VERY lucky boy! Found guilty, panel decide it’s low range because amongst other things there was no injury. All mitigation takes it from 6 week ban to 4.

“I’m sorry but for me the fact it there is no injury is just pure luck – there is absolutely no way that is mitigation. It’s like saying a player tipped in the air lands on their back, not their neck – it’s sheer luck. Now let’s deal with the elephant in the room …

“And that is – contact with the eyes or the eye area is absolutely vile. Deliberate or not it stinks. And yes it can be accidental, but it’s the risk of the outcome. For me there is no way any contact with the eye/ eye area should ever be considered as low tariff. Rant over.”

“Oscar Jegou banned for 4 weeks (6 week initial ban, 2 weeks off for good behaviour). Absolutely blessed,” Irish writer Neil Treacy remarked.

With Adam Hathaway adding, “Lucky boy. Had a couple of digs.”

Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.

Former referee Nigel Owens weighed in on the incident after the match and said that he was disappointed that the officials did not sanction Jegou on the day.

“It definitely should have been looked at. It doesn’t look good to be honest. Looking at that footage, that player is going to be in a bit of trouble,” Owens said on the BBC.

“There are processes in place now to deal with that but it should have been looked at in the game. It was quite clear what the actions were.

“It was a great game of rugby and it didn’t matter in the context of the game but on another day, where the score’s tight, things like this are the ones you really want the TMO to come in – the clear and obvious.

“Even if they have a look at it and then decide we can’t really see from the footage.”

READ MORE: Nigel Owens slams lack of TMO intervention after Scotland gouging accusation