Prominent British critic claims URC and Champions Cup being ‘held back’ by ‘stupid’ South African inclusion

Sharks in action in the URC against Connacht while the Bulls face Northampton Saints (inset) in the Champions Cup.

Sharks in action in the URC against Connacht while the Bulls face Northampton Saints in the Champions Cup.

Prominent British critic Stephen Jones insists that the inclusion of South African teams in the northern hemisphere has “held back” all the competitions they are involved in.

That includes the United Rugby Championship (URC), Investec Champions Cup and Challenge Cup, which all feature franchises from the Republic.

After being axed from Super Rugby in 2020, South Africa aligned their club game with Europe as the Bulls, Lions, Sharks and Stormers joined the URC.

Allowed into continental competitions

They have then been allowed to compete in the European competitions – the Investec Champions Cup and Challenge Cup – from the 2022/23 campaign onwards.

Jones has never been a fan of the move and once again aired his frustration in his Sunday Times column.

“One of the drawbacks of the URC is that unless there is a local derby involved, because of the travel, the matches never draw away fans, which removes a great deal of the atmosphere — and it is also true that, occasionally, some of the clubs do not draw many home fans either,” he wrote.

“The rank stupidity of having South African teams (or, rather, South African second teams) in previously European competitions — the Champions Cup and Challenge Cup — as well as the URC has held them all back grievously.”

The URC – or the PRO14 as it was called back then – was not particularly a thriving league before the South Africans joined it.

Many believe that those sides have added plenty to the competition but Jones disagrees.

“There are directors of rugby who despair of the vast trips involved just when they are finding their rhythm in the season and who believe there is no way the competitions can last long in the present formats,” he wrote.

“Back at home in a revitalised Currie Cup, say, the South African provinces are huge brands. Here in the URC, they are pipsqueak.

“It is massive in its concept, but not in the playing. It is extremely rare that South African teams deign to field all (or even some) of their Springboks. Let us say that they get a good rest more than they get an outing.”

Planet Rugby’s Top 50 men’s players of 2025: Ex-England star ‘excelled’ while Springbok lock ‘instrumental’ in club success as 50-41 revealed

London Irish’s return

Jones’ latest tirade against South Africa come amid the backdrop of London Irish’s return to rugby.

The former is supposedly weighing up whether to start back in the English rugby pyramid or pursue a place in the URC, but the journalist has warned against the latter.

“It is natural that the URC is chasing London Irish because that would give it a representative in London. The bonus for London Irish would be that they would not need to spend time chasing promotion; the URC would take them in a shot, embrace them like brothers, sight unseen, any hour of the day,” he wrote.

“London Irish, as I say, have been told that they would have to fight their way up through the Champ rather than ploughing straight in to the Prem for old time’s sake. But beware. Impatience could be their sworn enemy.

“So is the London Irish choice clear? Absolutely. They should set themselves up to make a grand comeback in the region where they have always played, often successfully.

“Returning to their old stamping ground, refreshed and reinvigorated and re-financed. Or taking part in a pie-in-the-sky monster which has yet to scare anyone on the field. The Irish used to parade a magnificent Irish wolfhound before games. He should come barking back, in England, where they belong.”

READ MORE: London Irish issue latest ‘sustainable comeback’ update after nine months of ‘frustration and reward’