Munster player ratings: ‘Forgettable’ start to the new year as visitors lack accuracy and creativity in disappointing defeat

Munster backs Mike Haley and Alex Nankivell.

Munster backs Mike Haley and Alex Nankivell.

Munster fell to a 28-3 loss to Ulster in the Inter-Pro derby. Here’s how we rated Clayton McMillan’s men in defeat.

Munster player ratings

15 Mike Haley: A handful of sharp interventions to kill off threatening Ulster attacks, but offset that with a couple of turnovers of his own. Unable to really threaten the hosts’ defence but it wasn’t a poor outing. 5

14 Calvin Nash: Looks to be getting back to his best, though this was far from a game where he could strut his stuff. He had some good moments but was troubled by the in-form Zac Ward, too. 6

13 Dan Kelly: Started brightly and imposed himself on defence, but much like the rest of the Munster players, the intensity dropped off as the game progressed. 5

12 Alex Nankivell: A shining light in an underwhelming Munster performance as the New Zealander pilfered over the ball and carried powerfully. Result was far from his fault. 7

11 Thaakir Abrahams: Hassled and hurried throughout the game by Werner Kok. Abrahams had very few opportunities in possession. Caught out on defence occasionally, too. 5

10 JJ Hanrahan: His aerial bombs were far too frequently off the mark in what was a poor kicking display. He also struggled to get the attack firing, and while his execution wasn’t on point, he wasn’t helped by the pack losing the gain-line battle. Lacked accuracy and creativity. 4

9 Paddy Patterson: Also struggled with his kicking game in the tough conditions and Ulster’s domination of the gain-line. Missed six tackles too, a forgettable performance. 4

Ulster v Munster: Five takeaways as ‘ultimate vibe’ shines in the snow against ‘fumbling’ visitors

Ulster player ratings: Nathan Doak ‘masterclass’, wonderful Wards and Werner Kok shine to dominate Irish Inter-pro

The forwards

8 Alex Kendellen: Never lacks effort but certainly lacked execution in Belfast as he conceded three penalties and struggled to get punch holes in the Ulster defence. He was busy in defence before he was forced off after a head knock. 4

7 John Hodnett: Played just 12 minutes before being forced off the pitch injured and spent most of that time defending. 5

6 Tom Ahern: Excellent in the lineouts, but Munster really need to get him more involved with ball in hand as he made just three carries. Accurate and disciplined on defence, which was a rarity for the visitors. 6

5 Fineen Wycherley: Topped the tackle count with 22 and was a strong carrier. Nuts and bolts performance. 6

Bernard Jackman: ‘Negativity’ from the likes of Tadhg Beirne ‘blinding’ Ireland as they risk being ‘left behind’

4 Jean Kleyn: Spilt a couple of passes but was worked relentlessly from minute one to 80. Never lacks heart and effort, but couldn’t turn the tide. 6

3 Michael Ala’alatoa: Did not shy away from contact in the slightest, topping the tackle count with 21 during his 51 minutes on the park. He did concede a knock-on and a penalty, but was otherwise solid. 5

2 Diarmuid Barron (c): Set-pieces were reasonably accurate but didn’t provide the platform to offer much of a threat. The captain didn’t have a poor game, but didn’t have an impactful one either. 5

1 Josh Wycherley: Another busy tackler as Ulster were happy to go through the phases, particularly around the ruck. Decent in the scrums, though it wasn’t a major factor when he was on the park. 5

Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.

Replacements: Brian Gleeson was the standout from the bench after his early introduction. Munster needed some form of impact from the bench, but instead received a very flat effort that mirrored the starters. A disappointing start to the New Year for the proud club. 3

READ MORE: Planet Rugby’s seven bold predictions for 2026: Springboks reign to ‘end’, a new job for Ronan O’Gara and Gregor Townsend’s last Six Nations