Letter from Wales: United Rugby Championship review after turbulent season both on and off the pitch
It’s been a hugely tumultuous season in Wales, and the turbulence continued right through to the end of the regions’ involvement in the United Rugby Championship (URC).
Cardiff clinched the Welsh Shield and qualification for the Heineken Champions Cup with Saturday’s 38-21 victory over the Ospreys at the Principality Stadium.
But they did so in the absence of their director of rugby, Dai Young, who had been suspended ahead of the Judgement Day clash.
That’s the kind of campaign it’s been in Wales, amid a succession of headline-grabbing off-field issues.
It’s been tough going on the pitch as well, both internationally and domestically.
In terms of the URC, there won’t be a Welsh presence in the play-offs, with all four regions finishing in the bottom half of the table.
Collectively, they played 48 league matches against teams from other countries and won just 13 of them.
For the second year in a row, Wales has had to rely on the geography-based qualification system to get a team into the Champions Cup – tenth-placed Cardiff.
🏴🏆 pic.twitter.com/v7vi5YRVFm
— Cardiff Rugby (@Cardiff_Rugby) April 22, 2023
From next season, that back door route will be closed with entry into Europe’s elite event reverting to being decided by pure meritocracy.
And, for the Welsh sides, securing the required top-eight finish will be very challenging, with playing budgets and squad numbers being reduced amid major cost-cutting.
That’s the future. As for the URC campaign just gone, here’s a more detailed look at how the four regions fared.
Cardiff
They have been the highest-placed Welsh side in the league pretty much throughout the season and, in the end, they finished nine points clear of their nearest rivals, the Ospreys.
Their tally of wins – nine – was also well ahead of the next best in Wales, the Scarlets with six. Plus, they won the most derbies – four.
So there’s no doubt they are deserved winners of the Shield.
At one point, they were looking a good bet for the play-offs, moving into the top six after winning five of their first eight matches. That strong start included an eye-popping 35-0 triumph away to the Sharks, plus notable victories over the Stormers and Munster.
But successive home defeats to the Ospreys and the Scarlets over the festive holiday period saw them lose momentum, while they will also look back ruefully on further Arms Park losses against the Lions and Edinburgh.
On the individual front, flanker Thomas Young made a big impact on his return to the club after eight years away at Wasps. He showcased both his class and his character with a superb display in the Judgement Day decider versus the Ospreys, amid the difficult backdrop of the situation with his dad Dai.
Scrum V understands that Dai Young has been suspended as Cardiff director of rugby.
Chris Horsman is full of praise for Thomas Young's performance over Ospreys despite the situation 👏
📺 BBC Two Wales#BBCRugby pic.twitter.com/j9FLgCYvHT
— BBC ScrumV (@BBCScrumV) April 23, 2023
The emergence of gifted youngsters Mason Grady and Teddy Williams has been a real plus, while prop Corey Domachowski has had a fine season, and captain Josh Turnbull has tirelessly led from the front.
Along with the notable league wins, there was also a memorable Challenge Cup knock-out victory over Sale on an emotional night at the Arms Park, just days after the death of Life President Peter Thomas, who contributed so much to the club.
Moving forward, there’s going to be a lot of change with a host of familiar faces leaving as the playing budget goes down from around £7.8m to about £5m.
Fly-half Jarrod Evans and prop Dillon Lewis are both heading for Harlequins, while centre Max Llewellyn is off to Gloucester, with a posse of further departures to follow. There is also now uncertainty on the coaching front, following the suspension of boss Young amid reports of complaints from employees.
Dragons
The coaching turbulence came at the start rather than the end of the season for the Gwent region.
Following a heavy defeat to Edinburgh in the URC opener back in mid-September, director of rugby Dean Ryan publicly criticised the players, questioning their work-rate and desire.
The Englishman was absent from training after that, with newly appointed head coach Dai Flanagan taking charge of first-team affairs amid speculation that Ryan would be leaving. His departure was finally confirmed almost four months later.
With Flanagan at the helm following his arrival from the Scarlets, there was a real early season bounce. The Dragons had three league wins under their belt before the end of October, including the scalps of Munster and the Ospreys, surpassing their tally for the whole of the previous campaign.
But they were not to win another URC game until the campaign concluding Judgement Day victory over the Scarlets on the weekend.
🐉🔴 The Dragons claimed their first #URC win of the year! #DRAvSCA pic.twitter.com/h9yO8Eqxgv
— Planet Rugby (@PlanetRugby) April 22, 2023
As for players to shine, wing Rio Dyer was to prove one of Wales’ stand-out performers after breaking into the national squad, while hooker Brad Roberts and centre Steff Hughes have been fine signings.
Some well-known names are now departing, with Welsh internationals Ross Moriarty, Will Rowlands, Sam Davies, and Rob Evans all moving on, while scrum-half Dane Blacker is coming on board from the Scarlets.
Ospreys
The high points of the Ospreys‘ season really came in the Champions Cup, where they claimed impressive victories over both the English and French title holders, Leicester and Montpellier.
As their coach Toby Booth says, the Welsh regions are now arguably better equipped for cup rugby than the league, given their limitations in squad depth and the fact Europe is one part of the season where they are able to consistently field full-strength sides.
In the URC, the Ospreys did manage to keep the pressure on Cardiff during the run-in and had an outside shot at the Shield going into Judgement Day, but their hopes were over by half-time as they trailed 24-0.
Morgan Morris, Nicky Smith, Rhys Webb, Keiran Williams and Jac Morgan all had commendable campaigns.
Scarlets
It was a tale of two halves to the season for the Scarlets.
They won just one of their opening nine fixtures in the URC amid a grim first few months.
But with the Challenge Cup kick-starting their campaign, they went on to win 11 out of their next 13 matches in all competitions.
In the league, the victories over the Bulls and the Sharks were the high points, while Europe saw them claim knock-out triumphs over French sides Brive and Clermont to set up next weekend’s Challenge Cup semi-final at home to Glasgow, which has already attracted more than 10,000 ticket sales.
🍿 Love watching Vaea Fifita in full flow! #ChallengeCupRugby pic.twitter.com/673l0lNCF7
— Planet Rugby (@PlanetRugby) March 31, 2023
Their Tongan trio of forwards Sione Kalamafoni, Vaea Fifita and Sam Lousi have been outstanding amid the resurgence, while Johnny McNicholl, Sam Costelow, Gareth Davies, Ryan Conbeer, Joe Roberts, and Dan Davis have all shown up well.
As with the other regions, there are some notable names leaving, including Leigh Halfpenny, Rhys Patchell, and the retiring Aaron Shingler, while number eight Kalamafoni is heading for France after three years of remorseless carrying.