Italy v Ireland: Five takeaways as Easterby’s men ‘let off the hook’ by Azzurri’s ‘utter lunacy’

Ireland's Mack Hansen and an insert of Italy's Michele Lamaro during the 2025 Six Nations.

Our five takeaways from the action in Rome as Ireland emerged 17-22 victors.

Following Ireland’s narrow 22-17 victory over Italy in Rome, here’s our five takeaways from the Six Nations clash.

Top line

Ireland’s hope of a Six Nations three-peat remains intact for a few more hours as Dan Sheehan’s hat-trick papered over an underwhelming performance where they were let off the hook countless times by their gracious hosts.

Sheehan’s five-pointers either side of the break courtesy of a powerful driving maul saw the forwards flex their dominance, before he latched onto a loose ball after a bit of brilliance from Mack Hansen.

Prior to Sheehan’s hat-trick, Hugo Keenan grabbed the opening try for the visitors as Simon Easterby’s men left Rome with a crucial bonus point as they now pray for miracle results in Cardiff and Paris.

The Italians certainly served up another delicious course of attacking rugby with Monty Ioane and Stephen Varney scoring stunning tries but their efforts and the side’s courageous measures on both sides of the ball were completely undone by three utterly foolish actions resulting in a yellow card and two reds.

☘️ Dan Sheehan hat-trick papers over ropey Ireland showing as Six Nations ends with victory over Italy

Italy lose their heads and gift Ireland the victory

For 38 minutes, Italy were the better team on the park. That was until usual captain Michele Lamaro produced a moment of utter lunacy. With Ireland on the attack inside the Italian 22, Lamaro made the sensationally stupid decision to slap the ball out of the hands of Jamison Gibson-Park at the breakdown. It was the kind of bold move that even the great Richie McCaw would think twice about attempting despite the TMOs having less say in his pomp.

Ireland’s ruthlessness has slowly dissipated as the Six Nations went on but, sniffing blood, they went for the jugular with Sheehan powering over for yet another try off the back of a rolling maul just moments after Lamaro’s yellow card.

It was a massive momentum shift after that moment of madness from Lamaro, unacceptable for a man of his calibre and experience, with Sheehan doubling his tally before the Azzurri leader rejoined proceedings in the second half.

However, the two teams did not remain on an even footing for long at all as from the ensuing kick-off, Ross Vintcent clearly looked to lay a marker and sprinted up to hammer Hugo Keenan. But his timing and execution was wildly off the mark as he made head-on-head contact with the Irish full-back and was sent to the sidelines with his actions reviewed by the Foul Play Review Officer – who came to the simple conclusion that his actions warranted a red card.

With a shot at clinching a late upset, the Italians managed to fire one final shot in their own foot as Giacomo Nicotera hammered into retiring Ireland legend Peter O’Mahony at a breakdown that was already sewn up by the visitors.

All of the Azzurri’s brilliant efforts throughout the match were simply wasted by the actions of the aforementioned trio. Italy had a good chance of grabbing just their second-ever Six Nations win over Ireland but they were the architects of their own demise.

🔢 Italy player ratings v Ireland: Azzurri dazzle with ‘Prosecco rugby’ but ‘moments of stupidity’ cost Quesada’s side

Ireland’s decline clear to see

As much as Italy deserve praise for staying in the fight despite the plethora of injuries and the utter stupidity of a select few, Ireland are due their criticism.

It was a clunky performance all around from Easterby’s charges, who only really got a foothold by resorting to their driving maul. The attack failed to make inroads into the Italian defence – which was brilliantly led by their world-class midfield combination of Juan Ignacio Brex and Tommaso Menoncello – while their defence just about scrambled enough to deny the Azzurri.

The broadcasting crew kept the cameras zoned in on the respective coaches and for much of the match, Gonzalo Quesada was by far the happier man with Easterby uncharacteristically showing just how angry he was.

However, this has not been a one-off for Ireland as the longer the Six Nations has gone on the worse the Irish have played. The attack has clearly digressed this Championship while their discipline proved incredibly costly against France.

There is still a minute chance they could be hoisting the trophy aloft for the third time in a row but it’s incredibly unlikely and considering the performances over the last fortnight, they would not be worthy winners on this occasion.

Today two legends bid farewell to the Irish jersey with Cian Healy bowing out last week and while the trio are not as crucial now as they have been over their glittering careers, it’s plainly obvious that Ireland are now in transition.

☘️ Ireland player ratings: Several stars have ‘stinkers’ as bench rescues fortunate Irish but ‘still more questions than answers’ over fly-half battle

Ugly scenes

While Italy repeatedly managed to throw the game away with their discipline, they were certainly not aided by the injuries they sustained throughout the match with three men leaving the pitch by the half-hour mark.

After Antoine Dupont was forced off last week after a nasty collision at the breakdown, it was disappointing to see yet another breakdown incident result in an injury, this time to Italian lock Dino Lamb. Last time out the citing commissioner did not believe the actions of Andrew Porter and Tadhg Beirne were worthy of a red card or further sanction and that may well be the case again today. However, it’s an uncomfortable theme that these kinds of lower limb injuries are occurring in Irish Test matches.

It can’t just be a coincidence. World Rugby have implemented laws to protect the players and have outlawed the targeting of lower limbs but these are still sneaking through the cracks. None of these incidents have been of a malicious nature but questions have to be raised of the tactics and execution in the rucks.

Lions concerns

While Italy will turn their attention to their trip down to South Africa in July, so many of the Ireland players will be hoping that their names are called out by Andy Farrell to tour Down Under with the British and Irish Lions.

However, a number of the Ireland stars have not done their hopes much good over the past fortnight. Jack Crowley’s horrendous placekicking display today will not be viewed kindly while James Lowe was largely ineffective before his brilliance to set up the disallowed try.

Garry Ringrose looked to be one of the frontrunners to start at 13 for the touring team before the tournament, but following his red card and an underwhelming shift on his return, question marks will be raised. Porter was put under pressure yet again in the scrums, particularly during the opening knockings.

It was not all doom and gloom though as Tadhg Furlong made a telling impact on his return as he bossed the tight exchanges and hugely improved the scrums. Bundee Aki also had a blinder off the bench kicking the attack into an entirely different gear.

Then there was the performance of Sheehan, who not only grabbed another three tries but was excellent in all facets of the game. So many of the Irish players came into the tournament as clear frontrunners for a starting Lions jersey but perhaps only Sheehan and arguably captain Caelan Doris have opened up a commanding gap between them and the chasing pack.

READ MORE 👉 ‘Great tactics by the Italians to get inside Ireland’s heads’ – Fans slam ‘atrocious’ Ireland’s Call rendition