Italy player ratings: Usual stars the ‘best of a bad bunch’ as Azzurri end Six Nations on ‘sour note’

Colin Newboult
Juan Ignacio Brex and Tommaso Menoncello in action for Italy against Wales in the Six Nations.

Juan Ignacio Brex and Tommaso Menoncello in action for Italy against Wales in the Six Nations.

Following a disappointing 31-17 defeat to Wales in the Six Nations clash at the Principality Stadium on Saturday, here are the player ratings for Italy.

15 Lorenzo Pani: Is a useful kicking option but it was generally a panicked display from the full-back, who was generally spending his day chasing back after yet another turnover. 4

14 Louis Lynagh: Competed well in the air for the most part and tried his best to influence the game, but mistakes from his team-mates reduced his influence. 6

Best of a bad bunch

13 Juan Ignacio Brex: Arguably Italy’s best player but even he had the odd mistake. There was a superb tackle on Eddie James behind the gain line and some lovely touches, but he was let down by the forwards and half-backs. 7

12 Tommaso Menoncello: Apart from one run in the first half, Menoncello was quiet until he burst into life late on in the match, showing his class. 7

11 Monty Ioane: Like Lynagh, you can’t really fault him for too much as his basics were good, but Ioane failed to really challenge the Welsh defence with ball in hand. 6

10 Paolo Garbisi: Not great, unfortunately. Missed an early penalty which set the tone as Garbisi stood a bit too deep with ball in hand and made a series of poor decisions. 4

9 Alessandro Fusco: His kicking wasn’t too bad but it was a bit too ponderous at the base of the ruck. Italy were dreadful with ball in hand in the first period and Fusco has to take some responsibility for that. 4

8 Lorenzo Cannone: Very few of his customary big carries as the number eight were well shackled by the Welsh. Went off after about an hour after a struggling to make an impact. 5

Wales player ratings: Mammoth performances all-round as written off individuals show ‘Test credentials’

Dominated at the breakdown

7 Manuel Zuliani: Not the threat he usually is at the breakdown as Wales’ clearing work was superb. It was a tough day at the office for the back-row. 5

6 Michele Lamaro (c): Certainly not a captain’s performance from Lamaro as he failed to inspire his team-mates on what was a disappointing day for the Azzurri. 5

5 Federico Ruzza: They challenged well on Wales’ lineout early on but, like his fellow forwards, Ruzza soon started to go into reverse in the physical battle. 5

4 Niccolò Cannone: Probably Italy’s best forward. Was relentless in the carry, won a couple of turnovers and won some individual duels. 6

3 Muhamed Hasa: A dreadful day for the tighthead, who came in for the injured Simone Farrari. Hasa was absolutely dominated by Rhys Carre in the scrum and offered very little elsewhere. 4

2 Giacomo Nicotera: Overpowered by the Welsh, while the hooker also had the odd issue at the lineout. Nicotera’s an excellent player, but this was a poor day at the office. 5

1 Danilo Fischetti: Set-piece had its issues, albeit the problems were really on the other side. Fischetti was one of their better players as he carried well and competed hard at the breakdown. 6

Replacements: They had better joy in the scrum in the second period while Stephen Varney lifted the tempo. There was also a good impact from David Odiase, but by that point the game was done and dusted after a dreadful first half as their Six Nations campaign ended on a sour note. 7

READ MORE: Scotland player ratings v Ireland: Finn Russell’s ‘efforts in vain’ as visitors blow Six Nations title hopes