Ireland v Italy: Five takeaways as Sam Prendergast experiment ‘should be over’ with Jack Crowley ‘changing the match’
Ireland fly-halves Sam Prendergast and Jack Crowley.
Following a 20-13 victory for Ireland over Italy on Saturday, here’s our five takeaways from the Six Nations clash at the Aviva Stadium.
The top line
Ireland survived Italy’s challenge to stop the rot after Paris, though it took every bit of their bench quality to hold off an Azzurri side that deserved better. It’ll do, just about, though Ireland needed every point after the French mauling left them staring at back-to-back defeats. A great advert for attacking rugby, pacey throughout, with Italy pushing them closer than the home crowd wanted to see.
The turning point arrived across two lineouts either side of half-time, the first seeing Italy drive deep into Irish territory while leading and sensing blood, only to get turned over when a score would have stretched the margin beyond Ireland’s fragile confidence to recover. Straight after the restart Ireland responded with Jack Conan powering over from close range, shifting momentum decisively in those two moments – one defensive stand, one immediate offensive response.
The outstanding Jamie Osborne scored Ireland’s opener, Rob Baloucoune crossed for his Six Nations debut try after Crowley’s introduction changed the game’s tempo, but Giacomo Nicotera’s first-half score kept Italy within touching distance throughout with the Azzurri’s belief never wavering even as Ireland’s bench quality gradually told. Three tries to one reflected superior finishing rather than territorial dominance, the margin flattering Ireland somewhat given how competitive Italy stayed.
Ireland got the win they desperately needed to steady nerves before Twickenham, but this performance won’t trouble England’s analysts much. Jack Crowley’s impact off the bench settled things where Sam Prendergast’s limitations were exposed again, and whilst the victory stops the bleeding it hardly suggests Ireland have rediscovered their best form. Job done, but the questions remain.
Big bang
Ireland’s bench settled this. Tadhg Furlong arrived at half-time, Jamison Gibson-Park and Tadhg Beirne entered together around the hour mark, and Italy didn’t have three British & Irish Lions waiting to deploy.
Furlong couldn’t solve the scrum, though, and Italy stayed competitive there throughout, but his 82 caps brought authority the starting front-row lacked and additional power in the carry and the breakdown.
Gibson-Park changed the kicking game immediately, his box-kicks finding grass behind Italy’s defensive line where Casey’s had hung predictably. The tempo lifted and Beirne added additional breakdown steel that had been absent, his work slowing Italian ball at the contact area and forcing turnovers that gave Ireland’s defence the platform to pressure rather than chase shadows.
The depth disparity told in the final analysis. Italy’s starters matched Ireland through 60 minutes on heart and structure, but when Gonzalo Quesada reached for his bench he found honest professionals, but Andy Farrell had the luxury of unleashing three Lions who’d toured eight times between them.
Baloucoune’s try – converted by Crowley after Prendergast’s departure – came off this upgraded platform. Whilst Italy’s improvement is real, their injury list is reaching epidemic proportions and there’s little doubt that Test rugby rewards depth, and Ireland’s bench quality remained a tier above what Quesada can muster at this moment in time.
Aerial improvement
After Paris’ aerial humiliation, Ireland finally remembered how the kicking game works. Craig Casey kicked much shorter from nine, finding chaser or grass behind Italy’s line instead of the endless hang time that gifted France easy takes last weekend, and when Gibson-Park arrived the execution sharpened further with box-kicks that put Italy under immediate pressure rather than giving them time to organise.
James Lowe proved huge in the air, and there’s plenty of him – the wing carrying a backside that belongs on a shire horse. He was winning contests through sheer bulk where athleticism alone wouldn’t cut it. Osborne competed well under the high ball too, his positioning and timing creating doubt in Italian minds about whether to challenge. Not graceful, but utterly effective against Italian back three players who couldn’t quite match their physicality.
Gibson-Park’s introduction transformed the momentum management entirely, despite Casey’s powerful shift. Ireland suddenly played in the right areas, their chase lines actually competing for their own kicks rather than spectating as they had in Paris. The basics worked: kick shorter, chase harder, win territory.
Italy’s kick-chase had troubled Scotland in Rome, but here they found Ireland’s defensive organisation far more robust with the home side’s back three putting bodies on Italian catchers fast enough to force errors. No highlight reel material, but it controlled the match through territory won and tempo dictated, forcing Italy to cover 80 metres rather than being gifted position through sloppy execution.
Brave Azzurri
Italy deserved better than a seven-point margin suggests. A win was a possibility and a draw wouldn’t have flattered them given how they matched Ireland through the first hour, pushing the home side to breaking point before superior depth told.
Manuel Zuliani was immense throughout, his 16 tackles and five turnovers providing the defensive foundation that kept Italy competitive long after the momentum should have swung decisively. The starting front-row of Danilo Fischetti, Simone Ferrari and Nicotera delivered serious grunt work that made Ireland genuinely fear scrummaging for the first time in months, their power and technique creating genuine doubt in Irish minds about whether they could dominate their traditional strength.
Leonardo Marin proved an excellent replacement for the absent Juan Ignacio Brex, his running lines and distribution keeping Ireland’s defensive alignment honest, though you sensed Brex’s defensive steel was missed in those crucial late moments when Ireland’s bench quality began overwhelming Italian resistance. The Azzurri conceded soft metres in channels where Brex would have shut down opportunity before it developed.
The Tommaso Menoncello to Louis Lynagh try that got chalked off for a forward pass looked botched at best – the kind of scoring chance that simply has to be taken at this level. On another day it sticks, and suddenly Italy are chasing a famous victory rather than damage limitation.
The Azzurri pushed Ireland harder than the scoreline admits, and a side on their trajectory will be bitterly disappointed at this loss, but Test rugby rewards depth and Ireland’s bench quality eventually told the story.
The battle at 10
The battle for Ireland’s 10 jersey was settled at the Aviva Stadium just after half time when Crowley came on and changed the match picture conclusively.
Prendergast’s service from the base moved at a tempo that gave Italian defenders time to read the pass, set their feet, and arrange the welcome committee. Every delivery arrived with a postal code attached, receivers standing static as the rush defence closed the space. His footwork offered no deception, no threat to the gainline; just the predictable rock-and-pivot that told opposition back-rows exactly where the ball was going next. Two missed conversions from kickable positions merely underlined yet another bad day at the office for the Leinster out-half.
The deeper issue sat in how Ireland’s backline operated under his control. Stuart McCloskey and Garry Ringrose had no rhythm to work with, no snap in the delivery that creates fractional advantages. Attacks stalled through tempo, or rather, the absence of it. The ball reached wide channels cold, with defenders already loaded and waiting.
Then Crowley entered and Ireland’s backline finally discovered it could actually move. Quick hands with genuine threat on the carry and Italy’s primary defence suddenly lost the collision and simply allowed Ireland to load the next receiver. Baloucoune’s try came off ball delivered with pace and a brilliant offload from McCloskey, but it was Crowley’s footwork and impudence forcing defensive hesitation that created the outside space.
Ireland went from static to fluid through one substitution. The evidence is overwhelming and the Prendergast experiment should now be over.
READ MORE: Lifeless Ireland indebted to bench’s rescue act as they edge past improving Italy