Gloucester player ratings: Contrasting fortunes for Test half-backs as ex-Ireland playmaker ‘hinders’ hosts while Wales star ‘in a league of his own’

Tomos Williams and Ross Byrne (inset) in action for Gloucester.

Tomos Williams and Ross Byrne in action for Gloucester.

Following a 30-21 defeat to Saracens in the Gallagher PREM clash at Kingsholm Stadium on Saturday, here are the player ratings for Gloucester.

Backs

15 Charlie Atkinson: Gloucester surely have to move Atkinson to fly-half as the classy footballer produced yet another good showing. He didn’t do too much wrong and made things happen with ball in hand. 7

14 Ben Loader: Has just returned from a hamstring issue, only to seemingly suffer the same injury against Saracens on Saturday. Such a shame for the very talented Loader, who had started the game well. N/A

13 Will Butler: Went off early for HIA and never returned. N/A

12 Seb Atkinson: Some mistakes here and there, but Atkinson was otherwise one of Gloucester’s brightest sparks once again. Carried hard into contact throughout and displayed some good hands on the gain line. 7

11 Ollie Thorley: Was a threat every time he had the ball but, unfortunately for the Cherry and Whites, his opportunities were few and far between. 6

10 Ross Byrne The Ireland international has been a poor signing for the West Country outfit and there wasn’t any improvement here. Byrne is standing too deep and just shovelling the ball on, which is hindering a talented set of outside backs. 4

9 Tomos Williams (c): Once again, Gloucester’s best player. Showed his future employers the class that he possesses, as Williams never stopped creating despite his team’s struggles. The assist for Arthur Clark’s try was absolutely staggering as the scrum-half was in a league of his own. 8

Saracens v Gloucester: Five takeaways as Tom Willis delivers where England ‘lack’ as Tomos Williams illustrates his ‘sheer brilliance’

Planet Rugby player ratings key 10 - Career defining performance 9 - Outright blockbuster effort 8 - Significantly influenced the result of the game 7 - Committed and effective outing 6 - Flashes of brilliance outside of executing fundamentals 5 - Fulfilling the role required by position (base level) 4 - Poor execution of fundamentals 3 - Costly errors and/or discipline in the game 2 - Poor performance that directly impacted the result 1 - Grossly ineffective throughout 0 - Should have carried water instead

Forwards

8 Jack Clement: Another individual who you couldn’t really fault. Clement was a destructive ball carrier and generally made ground in contact, but they couldn’t quite build on that front-foot ball. 7

7 Lewis Ludlow: Always gives his utmost for the club but Ludlow was part of a pack that was quite simply outplayed. Ludlow did everything he could but it was just wasn’t enough. 6

6 James Venter: Another signing which looked great on paper, that hasn’t quite worked out just yet. Having said that, they are playing in a system which just appears broken. 5

Saracens player ratings: ‘Absolutely elite’ Tom Willis increases Steve Borthwick’s pain as Owen Farrell ‘shows his class’

5 Arthur Clark: Highly rated by the England coaching staff and you can see why but the lineout was an issue and Saracens won the physical battle at close quarters. 5

4 Freddie Thomas: See Clark. Got himself on the scoresheet like his lock team-mate but the fundamentals were slightly lacking against the well-drilled Saracens forwards. 5

3 Afolabi Fasogbon: One of Gloucester’s better performers as Fasogbon scrummaged well and did plenty of good things in the loose, including a not too shabby grubber through. 7

2 Jack Innard: A nice kick through allowed him to stretch his legs and show some surprising pace, but that was very much the highlight for Innard, who’s had better days. 5

1 Val Rapava Ruskin: Had Marcus Street in trouble in the set-piece but Rapava Ruskin couldn’t quite influence the match at the breakdown like he usually does. 6

Replacements: Youngster Will Knight came into the game early and displayed some nice touches, ending the match with a try, while Jamal Ford-Robinson continued the good work at the scrum, but that was about it. Gloucester stayed in the contest, but there was a difference in class between the teams. 4

READ MORE: Bristol vs Newcastle five takeaways: Red Bulls secure first EVER points while Rees-Zammit becomes ‘fully-qualified’ in new position