Glasgow Warriors player ratings: Jamie Dobie ‘wreaks havoc’ before Scottish ‘Bomb Squad’ explodes to seal the 1872 Cup
Glasgow Warriors back Jamie Dobie and prop Zander Fagerson.
Following Glasgow Warriors’ 21-3 victory over Edinburgh in the 1872 Cup and United Rugby Championship, here’s how we rated Franco Smith’s men.
Glasgow Warriors player ratings
15 Ollie Smith: Hardly a poor game from the full-back, but he will certainly be disappointed by the high number of turnovers he conceded (4). He did get involved a lot in attack, which does lead to mistakes. Can’t fault the effort, but can fault the execution. 5
14 Kyle Steyn (c): Raised the bat in the 1872 Cup fixture, and the skipper did much of what he did in his previous 99 caps. He contested in the air well, carried powerfully and defended well. One of Glasgow’s best in possession. 7
13 Stafford McDowall: Edinburgh’s attack faltered for much of the match, and McDowall can take a lot of credit for that as he shot up on defence. Hardly a fixture for free-flowing attacking rugby, but the centre executed the basics well. 7
12 Sione Tuipulotu: Led the defensive line with McDowall, while his link-up play was silky as per usual. Didn’t gain much when taking the ball to the line, but did draw a few defenders when doing so. 6
11 Jamie Dobie: Whether he is at scrum-half or on the winger, Dobie shines. He caused all kinds of havoc for Darcy Graham under the high ball and landed a fantastic hit on Lewis Wells to stop an attack dead in its tracks. The Scotland international latched onto Hastings’ cross-kick to score in what was another statement of intent ahead of next year’s Six Nations. Doubled up before the final whistle. Comfortably the best on the par and completely outplayed Graham. 8
10 Adam Hastings: A stunning crossfield kick was the highlight of his performance as he sent Dobie over the try line. Replaced after a solid 60 minutes where he dictated territory well and shifted the ball on well on occasion. 7
9 George Horne: Kept Edinburgh honest under the fringes and under the high ball, really getting purchase from the latter. Controlled matters rather effectively in a game where defence ruled over the attacks. Grabbed the try that delivered the 1872 Cup. 8
The forwards
8 Jack Dempsey: Was building towards another busy and effective performance when he was replaced on 48 minutes. However, he made good metres from his carries and made his tackles. 6
7 Angus Fraser: His yellow card was more of a rugby incident than anything else. He couldn’t have done much more in then. Other than his 10 minutes in the sin bin, Fraser was quietly effective. 6
6 Matt Fagerson: Another workman-like shift from the ever-present back rower. He made more metres than any other forward on the park, and was one of his side’s top tacklers. Can always count on Fagerson to put in a tidy shift and that’s precisely what he did and with little fuss. 7
5 Alex Samuel: The blame for the lineout concerns does not lie solely at the feet of the locks, but they must take some responsibility for it. Still, Samuel did what was required of him before he was replaced. 5
4 Alex Craig: His four penalties conceded were a real blight on his performance. That aside, he was solid on defence and got his hands on the ball plenty. 4
3 Sam Talakai: Did concede a penalty but was otherwise strong and effective in everything else he did. The scrum battle was largely even when he was on the park. 6
2 Johnny Matthews: The lineout had some issues, but Matthews shone in other facets of the game as he regularly crossed the gain-line and made his hits on defence. 7
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
1 Patrick Schickerling: Regularly got his hands on the ball, and Glasgow benefited greatly from it. Also held his own in the scrums. 6
Replacements: The Glasgow ‘Bomb Squad’ exploded in the latter stages, with Franco Smith getting dividends from his early substitutions. Nathan McBeth and Zander Fagerson turned the screws in the scrum while Dan Lancaster made good decisions for the most part, as the attack was much improved. A word for Scott Cummings, who earned his 150th cap for his boyhood club. 8