Ex-All Black questions whether a Dan Carter-esque playmaker is redundant as focus shifts away from 10s
All Blacks scrum-half Cam Roigard and former New Zealand and Blues hooker James Parsons (inset).
Former New Zealand and Blues hooker James Parsons has questioned whether scrum-halves have replaced fly-halves as the most influential players in rugby union.
For several years, the fly-half role has been viewed as the 15-a-side game’s most authoritative position, with playmakers like legendary All Blacks number 10 Dan Carter usually running the show, but Parsons believes the influence of scrum-halves have become more significant in recent years.
Although he did not have a definitive answer to his question, Parsons pointed out the emergence of top-class number nines in the international arena and how they have dictated the game at that level.
‘Are nines now the 10s?’
“Is the game starting to be dictated by nines? Are nines now the 10s? And bear with me here, this has just come to me now, but like whenever you talk to someone, you go oka,y who sets you alight as a player?” he said on the Aotearoa Rugby Pod.
“It’s (Antoine) Dupont, we’re now hearing (Cam) Roigard, we’re hearing (Grant) Williams, we’re hearing Jamison Gibson-Park.
“I don’t know, because if you look at all the nines, that’s where the consistency is.
“And a lot more attacking play comes off nines in terms of showing face, working with the forwards and then releasing to the 10.
“Really the 10’s are still running when that gets released, but a lot of the in-game decision making and the person who has the ball the most is the nine.”
The show’s host Ross Karl then asked him whether the fly-half position has evolved into have become become a strike playing role and the scrum-half slot is now more of a management player.
Parsons admitted that he does not know the answer to that question but feels that it could be due to most Test sides stacking their replacement benches with forwards of late.
‘If you look at all the international teams around like the nines are quite set’
“Well, I don’t know, but if you look at all the international teams around, like the nines are quite set,” he said.
“Maybe not so different, but they do seem to be more set at nine because normally they’ve got more forwards on the bench anyway.”
Former Crusaders scrum-half Bryn Hall, who is now plying his trade with Japan Rugby League One outfit Kubota Spears, agreed with Parsons and feels the emergence of Cam Roigard as the All Blacks‘ first choice number nine and his brilliant attacking skill-set could benefit whichever fly-half is partnering him.
“Just coming back on Cam Roigard and I think with what his skill-set is going to be, it’s actually going to open up for our 10s in terms of going forward, going into the World Cup, because look you post so much questions at the breakdown in terms of the first three defenders, it might even be a little bit out,” he said.
“If we can get our pivots, or not so much our pivots, like our pods being able to run the right lines and a Roigard sniping in and around that, then I think it’s going to open up for the likes of Richie (Mo’unga).
“Cam Roigard can actually unlock our attack a little bit, I think even more, in terms of what’s going to be able to be our face play shape.
“So a very good point, Jip (Parsons), in terms of the nines probably being maybe a little bit more consistent, whereas 10s maybe might be a little bit more fluctuated.”