England great warns Andy Farrell over Lions fly-half selection as Steve Borthwick blamed for potentially ‘costing’ Marcus Smith

Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast (left) and England's playmakers, Fin Smith (right) and Marcus Smith (inset, middle).

Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast and England's playmakers, Fin Smith and Marcus Smith.

Former England star Brian Moore has claimed that it will be a risk for the British and Irish Lions to take two inexperienced fly-halves to Australia.

Injury depending, Scotland’s Finn Russell appears certain to go, but there is a big debate around the other slots.

Players are currently looking to put themselves in contention during the Six Nations, a competition which best represents their chance of putting their hands up.

It could make or break their touring hopes, with Marcus Smith perhaps the best evidence of that so far.

After an excellent 2024, Smith appeared nailed on going into 2025, but he has been moved to full-back for England’s past two games.

The Lions pecking order

As a result, Ireland’s Sam Prendergast and Marcus’ replacement in the 10 jersey, namesake Fin Smith, could well have moved up the pecking order.

However, those two players are still inexperienced at the highest level and Moore insists Lions boss Andy Farrell will have to weigh that up in his decision-making.

“A top-two finish might tempt Andy Farrell to overlook the fact Fin Smith and Prendergast are still quite young and their experience is limited,” he wrote in his Telegraph column.

“There is no real doubt that both have talent, but we have yet to see whether this is capable of being sustained over time.

“Farrell and his selection panel must carefully consider whether it would be the right decision to take two 22-year-olds in such a pivotal tactical position.

“Neither player will have more than 11 caps and Farrell has to be sure he can cover a situation where Russell is ruled out of a Test for whatever reason.

“We will have no way of knowing if this turns out to be the case, but it would be ironic if Farrell were to prefer Marcus Smith over either his England namesake or Prendergast because he wants a player who can cover both 10 and 15 from the bench.”

Dan Biggar makes ‘big statement’ over starting Lions fly-half and predicts what will be the ‘deal-breaker’ for Andy Farrell

Marcus Smith’s situation in particular is fascinating. While he has not necessarily been poor at full-back for England and, as Moore mentioned, that versatility could count in his favour, the playmaker’s chances have surely been harmed by being switched from fly-half.

‘Harsh but technically true’

“If you wanted a less in-depth look at this issue, you could simplify it to: ‘Steve Borthwick costs Marcus Smith a Lions place’ – a harsh but technically true viewpoint when you consider the following,” the ex-England forward wrote.

“Before the tournament started, based on past performances and the form shown in the most recent Autumn international series, most people would have had Smith as one of the three fly-half choices, with an outside possibility of him starting over Finn Russell.

“There was no consensus over Sam Prendergast, Jack Crowley and Fin Smith, who most thought would scrap it out for the third No 10 slot.

“If it turns out that Ireland win a slam and England take second place, there is a good chance that Marcus Smith – now England’s full-back – might lose out altogether, with both Prendergast and Fin Smith being taken Down Under.”

Moore added: “Fan forums chatter is very much instant reaction to the last thing seen and the fact that Marcus Smith was England’s most creative force last year will be forgotten.

“The fact that he was considered the more versatile player and thus was moved to cover the absence of George Furbank will also be forgotten.”

READ MORE: British and Irish Lions winners and losers: Trio enter ‘captaincy conversation’ while Scottish stars ‘loosen grip’ on starting jerseys