Bulls player ratings: Willie le Roux has a ‘shocker’ as Pretoria outfit fail to benefit from fantastic front five

Colin Newboult
Willie le Roux in action for the Bulls and prop Wilco Louw (inset).

Willie le Roux in action for the Bulls and prop Wilco Louw.

Following a disappointing 29-19 defeat to the Sharks in the United Rugby Championship clash at Loftus Versfeld on Saturday, here are the player ratings for the Bulls.

15 Devon Williams: In a poor day for the Pretoria outfit, their backs struggled to make an impact, including Williams, who failed to test the visiting defence. 5

14 Canan Moodie: A huge talent but not a great day for the Springbok. Did a couple of good things but the Bulls failed to take advantage of their forward dominance. 5

13 David Kriel: The centre took on kicking duties but he was awry on a few occasions, and it wasn’t the only facet which he struggled in. Both with and without a ball, it was a bad day at the office. 4

12 Harold Vorster: Had a better game than his team-mate but the centre partnership were ultimately ineffective throughout the clash. 5

11 Sergeal Petersen: Struggled to impact the game like the rest of the back three, with the Sharks by far the greater threat behind the scrum. 5

Playmaking issues

10 Willie le Roux: A lot of the Bulls‘ issues in this URC loss ultimately came because their half-backs failed to fire. Le Roux, who has been shifted from full-back, did not ignite his outside backs, while he was also sin-binned for a cynical infringement. Replaced early in the second period after a shocker. 4

9 Embrose Papier: A good start on his 100th appearance by playing a role in the first try but did not impress after that. Papier and Le Roux were outplayed by the Sharks’ playmaking duo. 5

Planet Rugby player ratings key 10 - Career defining performance 9 - Outright blockbuster effort 8 - Significantly influenced the result of the game 7 - Committed and effective outing 6 - Flashes of brilliance outside of executing fundamentals 5 - Fulfilling the role required by position (base level) 4 - Poor execution of fundamentals 3 - Costly errors and/or discipline in the game 2 - Poor performance that directly impacted the result 1 - Grossly ineffective throughout 0 - Should have carried water instead

8 Nizaam Carr: The back-row was part of the loose trio that failed to make much impact in the loose. The pack dominated but they needed more front foot ball from their big carriers. 6

7 Reinhardt Ludwig (c): The lineout went well and Ludwig was a key part of that as he won plenty of ball and put pressure on the Sharks’ ball. 7

6 Marco van Staden: Set up the first try for Jan-Hendrik Wessels but that was as good as it got for Van Staden. Couldn’t quite find the dominance at the breakdown that he usually gets. 6

Sharks player ratings: ‘Magnificent’ loose forward shines in Siya Kolisi’s absence while consistent Ethan Hooker looks ‘ready-made’ for Springboks

Super front five

5 JF van Heerden: The youngster is a real talent and made his presence known here, especially in the set-piece. A very good performance at set-piece, but the backs let him down. 8

4 Ruan Vermaak: See Van Heerden. A dominant presence in the lineout, on both the Bulls’ ball and the Sharks. Also put it about in the loose in what was a fine individual display. 8

3 Wilco Louw: A monstrous scrummaging performance yet again from the tighthead, who destroyed the Sharks throughout his time on the field. 8

2 Johan Grobbelaar: It certainly wasn’t the greatest first half from the Bulls, but the hooker did his best to turn the tide, winning a turnover at a critical time. The hooker then touched down twice in the second period, but it was not enough. 8

1 Jan-Hendrik Wessels: Like Louw, Wessels enjoyed a fine game, consistently getting his side field position via scrum penalties. Also got over the tryline himself before being replaced by the equally effective Gerhard Steenekamp. 8

Replacements: Steenekamp unsurprisingly continued to give the Bulls scrum dominance, but the rest struggled to impact the match. While Le Roux was poor, Boeta Chamberlain perhaps showed why the Springboks full-back has been shifted to 10 as he did not improve matters. 4

READ MORE: Bulls v Sharks: Five takeaways as ‘delicious’ Siya Masuku sends Springboks message as visitors ‘wriggle’ their way to famous victory