All Blacks centurion ‘barking’ at Blues to make key Beauden Barrett call with Vern Cotter’s reluctance possibly affecting Scott Robertson
Beauden Barrett for the Blues against the Hurricanes in 2025 (James Foy/Speed Media/Icon Sportswire) and All Blacks head coach Scott Robertson.
Mils Muliaina has become the latest former All Black to urge the Blues to shift Beauden Barrett to fly-half after his starring role at the weekend.
For the third game in a row, the 33-year-old started at full-back with Harry Plummer once again taking the fly-half jersey.
However, the game changed once Barrett stepped into the 10 shirt and the Auckland-based outfit claimed their first victory of the season.
They defeated the Hurricanes 33-29 to finally get on the Super Rugby Pacific board, with the All Blacks star absolutely crucial to their success.
Asked on The Breakdown whether the Blues would have won the game without Barrett stepping into fly-half, Muliaina responded: “I’m not sure they would have.”
Barrett shows his class
The All Blacks centurion added: “I’ve been barking this before Round One, Beauden Barrett should be at 10. When he moved to 10 at the weekend, he just showed all his class.
“He was dominant, he was decisive in his decision-making. Even when he counter-attacked from the back, just some of the things he did.
“The guys were all on the same page. He understands the ability to get down the other end. I don’t know if I’ve seen anything so great in the last couple of years.”
Injuries and the form of Harry Plummer last season has contributed to the decision to put Barrett at full-back, but it is a call which could be harming Scott Robertson and his All Blacks side looking ahead to the 2025 Test season.
Although there is still plenty of time left in the Super Rugby campaign and no doubt the experienced playmaker will get plenty of chances in the 10 jersey this season, fly-half was a problem area in 2024.
Barrett ended the campaign as New Zealand’s number one in the position, but neither he nor Damian McKenzie really nailed down the shirt last year.
McKenzie is another key playmaker who has started every game at 15 so far in 2025 and, before Round One even started, it begged Rugby World Cup winner Stephen Donald to ask whether it was beneficial for the players and therefore the All Blacks.
“It’s funny to say but when you watch Damian and Beaudy at times, you would almost say they do look like they could do with more time in the 10 jersey,” Donald said on Sport Nation’s Beaver & Guy show last month.
“It even seems funny to say that about Beaudy. Now when Beaudy goes and plays 10, he looks like he’s a 15 playing 10 as opposed to what he used to look like.”
Credit in the bank
Former Highlanders and Maori All Blacks lock Joe Wheeler appeared on The Breakdown with Muliaina and agreed that Barrett should be at 10.
However, Wheeler explained why Cotter might be persisting with Plummer instead of moving the two-time World Rugby Player of the Year to fly-half.
“I’ve got my theories. Personally, I totally agree, but do I think Vern Cotter will do it? No, I don’t. I think we will stick with Harry Plummer because Harry Plummer led this Blues team after 21 years back to the promised land (winning the Super Rugby title),” he said.
“He’s got a lot of trust in Harry Plummer in what he did last year. He went with Harry Plummer again, but I think we can see the quality when Beauden does go in there.
“He changes their game. They don’t go as direct, they use his running game, he goes flat on the line and it’s just something different. Teams have been fronting them physically and they’ve been shutting them down.”