Loose Pass
This week we'll be concerning ourselves with contrasting rebellions, the England hot seat, calendars, B&I Lions and point changes.
This week we will mostly be concerning ourselves with contrasting rebellions, the England job, calendars, Lions and point changes.
In the aftermath of the two campaigns, and without wanting to flog England's dead horse too malevolently, it's worth pointing out that theirs was not the only RWC campaign to look decidedly off the rails at times.
Yet the aftermath of France's odd roadshow is perhaps the most poignant indictment yet of how England's squad so miserably reacted to the adversity evident in their camp. Put succinctly, France's players rallied themselves, England's went on the ale and gave up.
It may have something to do with experience – of France's final and semi-final starting XV, only four were under thirty. But despite the obvious disparity with the coach and some of his selections, the media antipathy and poor form on the pitch, the French players ultimately did man up and get on with the job, even if they rode their luck a little at times.
Marc Lièvremont was furious when some of his players went out after the semi-final win, but there were no stories of dwarf-throwing, sexual harassment, ferry-jumping etc. Nor was the night out and details concealed from the coach. Contrast that with the lies and debauchery surrounding England's night out and there is a picture of one team that knows when to let off steam and how, and another that just couldn't care.
The overwhelming number of players who voted in Francois Trinh-Duc – left out in the RWC cold by Lièvremont – as player of the year can also be seen as a little post-partum dig in the ribs at Lièvremont's odd tinkering from the players; Imanol Harinordoquy's 'I won't miss him' line was clearly a little further. But there's that element of honesty, an expression of feeling that clears the air that was so damningly absent from England's squad at any time.
Instead from England, there's been anonymous player surveys, leaked confidential documents, mysterious reshufflings of roles… nothing honest. Nothing that says, we were rubbish and wrong. There's merely been a culture of blame.
The point of all this being that as well as all those in tracksuits and three-piece suits currently examining themselves and their role, a lot more of the current England squad ought to be as well. The longer all this drags on, the worse the players look.
OK, one more brief England snippet: Who the hell is going to take this job on? Who would want to? The South African job has always been the most dangerous and pressured in the world with its own unique political ramifications and pressures, but in the chaotic and corpse-strewn aftermath of the RFU's 2011 performance, England's looks just as bad now – at least the Bok coach has an idea of who his employer is and at least he has a loyal and proud set of players.
The right man would look to be Nick Mallett; as alluded to above, someone in the camp needs to be a straight-talker and there are fewer who talk straighter than he. Jake White is one, but he has a job – for him to leave the Brumbies before his first season has even kicked off would be a move that would make the RFU look angelic in its dealings.
Richard Cockerill shrugged off his mooted interest, but he would also fit the bill: a belligerent coach with a direct attitude to both media and players. The slight problem there is that both he and the lone surviving RWC coach are Leicester-bred and forward coaches.
Mallett has resolved not to talk to the RFU until their own structures are sorted out, which is a healthy stance to adopt. You also get a feeling that he may even have told the RFU which structures he wants sorting – and how firmly sorted they need to be – before he applies. He at least sounds conditionally interested. But beyond him, there's been little immediate or enthusiastic interest; again, an indictment of how extensive the damage is.
The Lions tour! Were we the only ones twingeing with excitement when the fixture schedule was released Sunday?
Five Super Rugby teams, one select team, three Tests… June/July 2013 is going to be fabulous.
There's an awful lot to run under the bridge until then of course, not least the naming of a coach for the tour (your thoughts welcome on this one: we're not convinced Warren Gatland is the man despite his obvious front-runner status), but for now, for an idle moment, here's a little youtube treat for you from the last time the Lions went to Oz!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gR_iy8SmkK0
Finally, we've been campaigning for it for some time now, albeit on the reasonably quiet, but keep an eye on this year's Varsity Cup in South Africa (a treat of a competition for the uninitiated by the way, highlights are all over youtube.
The cup will this year have penalties and drop goals scored at 2 points, conversions at 3 points, while a try remains at 5. We believe it will change the dynamic of the game, with many teams far more willing to give away two points than potentially eight. Expect a glut of yellow cards.
Still, we may be proven wrong. But it's a good time to restate our preferred solution to the over-use of penalties and drop goals: reduce the drop goals to two or even one (Munster would still have won their HEC matches with a two-point drop goal), award free-kicks for all offences bar cynical and foul play, but change the dynamic of a free-kick so that a kick for touch will yield a line-out for the kicking team. Fewer kicks for goal, more dangerous attacking positions. Your thoughts?
Loose Pass compiled by Richard Anderson