Loose Pass
This week we will mostly be concerning ourselves with red cards and anti-climaxes… Alain Rolland might get a mention too.
This week we will mostly be concerning ourselves with red cards, laws of the game, laws of physics, legal precedents and anti-climaxes… Alain Rolland might get a mention too.
In the first paragraph actually. Was there any other subject on the rugby world's mind this past weekend? We can't even remember what we were thinking about last week, bar wondering whether Wales might be the only team left with a game capable of giving the All Blacks a scare. Then Rolland flourished that red card. Wales' game and shot at glory trickled away.
So: the card. Cold hard facts first. When Fabrice Estebanez and Suka Hufanga were banned for tip tackles in the aftermath of France's defeat to Tonga, the IRB once again reiterated the stance on tip tackles – the original memorandum was sent out on June 8, 2009. It ran as follows:
The three options open to referees “when a tackler horizontally lifts a player off the ground”:
A. The player is lifted and then forced or 'speared” into the ground. A red card should be issued for this type of tackle.
B. The lifted player is dropped to the ground from a height with no regard to the player's safety. A red card should be issued for this type of tackle.
C. For all other types of dangerous lifting tackle it may be considered a penalty or yellow card is sufficient.
Warburton's tackle fell squarely under B. As such, the red card was not a bad call. In fact, it was the right one.
Rolland has previous of making the calls like this; Florian Fritz of Toulouse saw red for an almost identical tackle against Wasps in last year's Heineken Cup under Rolland's eye. Again, laws are laws. Yet back then as well, there was an almost identical outpouring of indignance, frustration and finger-pointing in the aftermath.
Why this reaction? It's in the laws of the game and has been for some time so the players and observers ought to know.
There are compelling reasons. Firstly, the decision and its knock-on effects were so far removed from the context of the game – the way it had been played, the lack of aggro – that it seemed to be one of those decisions where a referee felt it necessary to overstamp authority on proceedings: a prison sentence awarded where a probation or good behaviour bond would have been appropriate. The same was thought of the Fritz call.
There are scientific arguments too – as Warburton pleaded when he said: “As soon as I hit him his body weight controlled what happened.”
Making a big hit is something all players crave much of the time; in Warburton's position you crave it once a minute. But there are some unavoidable side-effects enshrined in natural physics when a collision happens across a certain plane of movement with a certain force and velocity, resulting in the upward, or lifting, movement. Once that weight is shifted upwards, there are other natural physical forces that almost pre-determine that the tackled player will not come down safely. The weight of the upper body will tip. If you as the tackler hold on, you end up looking as though you are driving your tacklee into the turf – the worst of all tackle offences. But let go in order to avoid this and you are in trouble too. Damned if you do, damned if you don't, damned just by making a good hit. It is not the age of the tackler. To some extent, this ruling (from the IRB more than Rolland) undoubtedly eviscerates one of rugby's most enjoyable aspects: the big head-on hit.
Thirdly, there's the age-old argument of consistency, Wales' chief grievance amongst it all and one that is especially pertinent to short-term tournaments. IRB edict or not, there have been several of these tackles through the World Cup and since June 8, 2009, almost universally punished by yellow cards. Suddenly it's red, and at the most pivotal of moments. It's a tough call to change a long-term precedent halfway through a tournament, especially when referees have hitherto been quite adroit at judging levels of malice based upon the above – again, the argument of the context of the game is called in.
Referees are not supposed to judge intent or malice, but we – and indeed Paddy O'Brien who has so staunchly defended Rolland's call – have never been shy of applauding those who do. Commons sense and sensitivity to atmosphere contribute to a referee's performance. Significantly more often than not they do a good job of this, and it always makes for a better game. Steve Walsh did it well in the France-Tonga match, which was not one that ever looked as though it ought to be tainted by a red card. Under Rolland's rule, there would have been two.
Under the philosophy all of those reasons, the correct decision would undoubtedly have been a yellow card for Warburton.
We don't yet really know which side of the fence to fall on: arguments that take into account the good nature of the game, the way this tackle has been dealt with the past two years, Wales' infinite superiority and Warburton's near-lilywhite disciplinary past, or the robotic 'rools is rools' one that reminds us all Rolland was right in law. Rigid law application v philosophy and precedent. It's a match-up that neither side is going to win or lose in a public vote, one that has split the rugby world almost 50-50 in the aftermath of this semi-final.
Rolland is paying a price for it all. We had backed him for the final prior to this, but that final has gone to the referee of the other semi, Craig Joubert. It's easy for all to say that the red card cost Rolland his shot, but he was excellent for the rest of the game bar one call: the penalty from which Leigh Halfpenny saw inches separate him from the adulation of all. That was a dreadful error of judgement. In all probability, it was this more than the red card which tipped the balance Joubert's way. It's also highly likely that had Halfpenny landed the penalty, the French would have been up in arms and calling for the referee's head. Rolland was on a hiding to nothing and maybe it's just as well he is now more or less out of the limelight, although he will be running the line in Auckland on Sunday.
Nobody can change the past though, so it's the future rugby officials, players and fans now need to watch. Between them, Warren Gatland and Alan Lewis have hit the nail on the head with these two soundbites:
Gatland: “Does this now mean every time you lift a player in a tackle it's going to be a red card?”
Lewis: “I don't like those type of tackles and they need a bit of direction. I think they should be potentially banned and I think after tomorrow, it will perhaps be a watershed moment.”
Only if this red card becomes a watershed moment will Rolland end up vindicated completely throughout the rugby world. He could be the man to stamp out the tip-tackle completely, the man who listened to the lawmakers and stood up for the laws in the toughest of situations. Or he could wind up as the guy who just didn't use game sense and robbed the Welsh of a