Tuilagi v Olivier: Stalemate?
Related links
Teams
Also see
The odds seem stacked against England salvaging a Test win over South Africa in Saturday's tour-ending clash in Port Elizabeth.
It's been 12 years since England claimed victory on South African soil and a win for the Springboks at Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium would make it ten in a row - the longest sequence of wins ever recorded between the teams.
While the results of the first two Tests this June suggest that the tourists came close to ending their long streak, it would be fair to say the hosts never realistically looked like succumbing in either encounter.
The Springboks were always going to have a far larger margin for progression in the three weeks with their new coach compared to a relatively settled England side that had played the Six Nations together. And South Africa's first half-an-hour at Ellis Park was a massive step up from their performance in the opening Test. That early blitz was the best rugby we've seen from a Springbok side in years but Heyneke Meyer firmly believes they can get a lot better.
As Meyer suggested in the immediate aftermath of England's dogged comeback, if the Boks can put together the second half from Durban with the opening 40 minutes from Jo'burg, they will be near unstoppable.
Ominous words for Stuart Lancaster and co. to digest, especially considering that England will take the field in PE without their two best players on tour - skipper Chris Robshaw and scrum-half Ben Youngs.
The Boks are dealing with a few setbacks too - and some selections have caused heated debate amongst the SA public - but the general consensus is that it would be a massive surprise if the home side didn't wrap up a 3-0 series win.
Indeed, there is now an expectation for the Boks to drive home their perceived advantage and win big. But fans of the green and gold should not overlook the significance of their own absentees, especially Willem Alberts and Frans Steyn.
Those betting their mortgage on a home win should be reminded of the third Test against the British and Irish Lions in 2009. Lest we forget that England were level at half-time in Durban and outscored their hosts 17-11 in the second half in Jozi - so they are carrying a fair amount of momentum and self belief.
Much has been made of the physical threat posed by the Springboks but pundits will do well to remember that England are 4kg per man heavier than South Africa up front. The average weight of the England pack is 113kg while the Springbok forwards weigh in at an average of 109kg.
So, the tourists are not at a physical disadvantage. How they use that bulk however will be more important and it will be interesting to note what impact the addition of Thomas Waldrom and James Haskell has on England's ability to compete in the trenches.
Some might even suggest that Lancaster has gone overboard in trying to match the Boks for muscle as the midfield partnership of two specialist 13s that failed to create much at Ellis Park has been retained.
Trying to match the Boks for grunt is one thing but it's a rare sight to see the men in green bullied. If England are to go home with a victory they need to find a way around the wall, not through it. How long before we see a ball player at 12? Does the solution lie in jersey 21 on the England bench?
Players to watch:
For South Africa: The last time the Boks visited the PE, Jacques Potgieter was in the stands and promised a friend he'd be back a year later to watch the game with him, never suspecting that he would be on the field himself. Indeed, the Bulls flank's rise has been nothing sort of meteoric - this time last year Potgieter was playing second division domestic rugby. After a standout Super Rugby season, the 26-year-old has the unenviable task - on debut - of filling the boots of Willem Alberts. He hasn't played for over a month after dislocating his kneecap, which makes his selection all the more surprising. There will be no time for rustiness on Saturday though. Meyer has, however, come in for a fair amount of criticism for favouring the Bulls and it's fair to say that Wynand Olivier probably would not have made the cut had he played for any other team. But Meyer loves stability and Meisiekind's partnership with Morne Steyn is a tried and tested formula. Defence coach John McFarland reckons Olivier was South Africa's best defender when he came on in Johannesburg and he'll have plenty of opportunity to show his tackling ability against the hulk that is Manu Tuilagi.
For England: After attracting plenty of headlines for his off-field indiscretions earlier this year, Danny Care has earned a recall - ahead of Lee Dickson - thanks to an excellent showing for the midweek team. It will be the Harlequins scrum-half's first England appearance since August. Care will be charged with generating much-needed go-forward ball and sparking some life into an England attack that has failed to fire on all cylinders. Highlanders flank James Haskell has been called in to fill the hole left by Robshaw but will be expected to bring a more aggressive game than the injured skipper as England try to cope with the Boks' full-frontal assault. England fly-half Toby flood will win his 50th cap. The 26-year-old needs ten more points to break the 250 Test point barrier.
Head-to-head: With these teams playing similar styles of rugby, the battle of the number eights should make for entertaining viewing. While Pierre Spies will be winning his 50th Test cap, Thomas Waldrom will be making his first start for England after coming off the bench last week. Spies' ball-carrying ability and speed have been well documented but his critics - and there are many - claim he goes missing when the going gets tough. The label of "flat track bully" has become a favourite. But the rampaging Bull had one of his best games for ages last week and will be keen to build on that performance. Waldrom is far less appealing to the eye as a pure physical specimen, but 'Thomas the Tank Engine' is an awfully hard man to stop. If it rains on Saturday, which is likely, his grunt in the tight stuff could prove invaluable - especially if it means Spies is denied opportunities to go galloping. Both teams will also be lining up their third full-back of the series. Proficient kicker and the deceptively fast Alex Goode makes his debut. But like his opposite number Gio Aplon, Goode's first instinct is to counter-attack. The danger for both players is to overdo it as they aim to grab a rare opportunity to impress. Errors at Test level will be severely punished.
Previous results:
2012: South Africa won 36-27 in Johannesburg
2012: South Africa won 22-17 in Durban
2010: South Africa won 21-11 in London
2008: South Africa won 42-6 in London
2007: South Africa won 15-6 in Paris
2007: South Africa won 36-0 in Paris
2007: South Africa won 55-22 in Pretoria
2007: South Africa won 58-10 in Bloemfontein
2006: South Africa won 25-14 in London
2006: England won 23-21 in London
2004: England won 32-16 in London
2003: England won 25-6 in Perth
2002: England won 53-3 in London
Prediction: South Africa's last loss at home to a northern hemisphere side was a 36-26 defeat to France in 2006 - ironically the year England last beat South Africa (23-21 at Twickenham). Saturday's clash is the 35th match between the two sides and SA won 21 times with just one draw (3-3, 1906). All the indicators suggest the hosts will make it 22 this weekend. South Africa by eight.
The teams:
South Africa: 15 Gio Aplon, 14 JP Pietersen, 13 Jean de Villiers (c), 12 Wynand Olivier, 11 Bryan Habana, 10 Morne Steyn, 9 Francois Hougaard, 8 Pierre Spies, 7 Jacques Potgieter, 6 Marcell Coetzee, 5 Juandre Kruger, 4 Eben Etzebeth, 3 Jannie du Plessis, 2 Bismarck du Plessis, 1 Tendai Mtawarira
Replacements: 16 Adriaan Strauss, 17 Werner Kruger, 18 Flip van der Merwe, 19 Ryan Kankowski, 20 Ruan Pienaar, 21 Elton Jantjies, 22 Bjorn Basson.
England: 15 Alex Goode, 14 Chris Ashton, 13 Jonathan Joseph, 12 Manusamoa Tuilagi, 11 Ben Foden, 10 Toby Flood, 9 Danny Care, 8 Thomas Waldrom, 7 James Haskell, 6 Tom Johnson, 5 Geoff Parling, 4 Tom Palmer, 3 Dan Cole, 2 Dylan Hartley (c), 1 Joe Marler.
Replacements: 16 Lee Mears, 17 Paul Doran Jones, 18 Mouritz Botha, 19 Phil Dowson, 20 Lee Dickson, 21 Owen Farrell, 22 Brad Barritt.
Date: Saturday, June 23
Venue: Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium, Port Elizabeth
Kick-off: 17:00 (16:00 BST, 15:00 GMT)
Weather: 21°C. Sunny with cloudy periods with showers likely. Chance of a thunderstorm. Windy at times.
Referee: Steve Walsh (Australia)
Assistant referees: Nigel Owens (Wales), John Lacey (Ireland)
By Ross Hastie







Comments
anotherfarce says...
Zambokke,
Your kidding aren't you!! England 2 down & not much to gain, boks will throw the ball around everywhere in this one, I hope that england show up with last weeks attitude cause they will need it.
On a positive england seem to be building a very good side for the next 6N & RWC.
I cant wait to see the shoot-out between SA & NZ in the upcoming 4N, lots of fireworks there!!!
Posted 15:30 23rd June 2012
Headhunter99 says...
@heathy - Good post, lets face it only 8 months ago we would not have given England any chance of playing well in the match warm up let alone against South Africa at home. SL and his youngsters have given us some glimmer of a future, long way to go but you only get better by playing the best teams.
@ABlack - Are you sure your reading the right British papers ? The tabloids are talking about the English soccer backs !!! The better papers are not going overbard at all, but then they use joined up composition not just pictures and every other word ending in ie like loosie, footie et al... only kidding you get the picture.
Posted 09:11 23rd June 2012
astrospange says...
@ABlack. We know our backs are crap but they have got heart which ain't going to win us didely squat. Get rid of Young's and put in Dickson just to get the ball away from the breakdown.
Posted 07:20 23rd June 2012
ABlack says...
England forwards should be better with Haskell, Waldrom starting to take on the Bok forwards. Also without Alberts playing things should even up a bit in the forwards. England backs are crap and once again so over rated ( by themselves and their media). SA backs are looking better than last season.
SA by 6
Posted 02:12 23rd June 2012
BokRocker says...
Wynand is a hell of a nice guy, sometimes a bit selfish on the field but a chap with a big heart. I had the oppertunity to meet him seeing that he lives a few houses down from my uncle and really a great and humble guy. No doubt he has great potential and with the right mentoring will be a truelly great centre, tackles like one.! The Bulls style of rugby has helped him develop but has also hurt his game. Watched him when he was playing in the junior ranks and he stood out as a play maker but dulled down due to the tactics and training used by the bulls, my opinion of course but I believe he will pleasantly surprise us all this season.
Posted 23:25 22nd June 2012
Jediboy says...
I pretty much agree with heathy's post.
But I'd add that after what I've seen so far on this tour, England are behind are I thought they were. We don't seem to have moved on from the 6N, which is disappointing.
Ashton/Strettle/Foden may as well not have been there the amount of ball they have had. And that's a real problem - we lack guile in attack did its a bit one dimensional. That said, the team does show promise but there is loads of work to do.
Posted 18:17 22nd June 2012
Zambokke says...
A much better chance for England due to our changes. Now I'm worried. Also it is a dead rubber just like the 1997 and 2009 last SA v Lions games. The thing that gets me most worried though is that the English bench has lots of class compared to ours- their bench could swing a game; I'm not sure outs could do the same, in fact it could lose us the game. Good news that Bekker etc will be back for the S15 and the Chamionship.
Posted 18:12 22nd June 2012
jehosophat says...
As with the last two I am just hoping SA don't win big.
SA and England play a more similar game than their supporters would like to admit - smash the other team up front, sap the opponent's strength with physicality and a strong set piece, and kick the points when the other side breaks the laws. Later on individually talented but not exactly over-used backs do the job when the pressure tells. That is why whichever of the two sides is strongest at that moment tends to consistently win the matches between the two, with long runs of results to England up to 2005 then SA since.
Great that SL has spotted that England lack physicality to really compete with the best sides, but this is not going to be cured overnight. I fully support a more open game plan but the lack of real power and precision up front has cost England big in recent years... It needs sorting out.
SA to win again unless they get very, very cocky but England should have a great chance against all the SH sides bar NZ in the home internationals in the autumn, IF they continue to progress rather than plateau. The 6N went better than expected but I don't feel there is a settled side or gameplan yet, just some decent players and a sensible ethic.
Posted 17:42 22nd June 2012
darthbok says...
hard to believe that the rugger press talk about the bok`s physicality and they are playing a bigger side -- SA had better watch out in the scrum -- could concede alot of penalties -- and waldrom will be a serious handful -` looks like homer simpson, plays like bart simpson`--
Posted 15:03 22nd June 2012
Carpelone says...
When I see Olivier playing, I wonder why my dad persuaded me to study Engineering and Management.
With Frans Steyn out, JdV / De Jongh is the better center pairing. Good to see Aplon in the mix, sorry that Lambie can't have a go. Lambie can run Boks' backline much better than M. Steyn. Potgieter was in fine form during the S15, let's see if he can cope with Test Rugby. Still work in progress, a 3-0 is a must to build on these performances nicely.
Posted 13:43 22nd June 2012
objetive says...
Heathy, well done on your accurate post. Us "southerners" like it when teams and supporters keep their feet on the ground and do the talking on the field. Respect to you. If the English rugby team adopt your approach (and I believe Lancaster is the man to do it), they will rise through the rankings.
Posted 13:42 22nd June 2012
bokbevok says...
England may be heavier in the forwards but if they go in trying to be to physical then they are in for a long hard day at the office. The physical aspect of boks game is not thuggery it is just the way the game is played at home. England should be best served just going out forgetting that it is the boks and try force their style of play in the game instead of trying to be better than the boks at he boks game, not gonna happen.
Boks win again, love it.
Posted 13:30 22nd June 2012
jonesy2 says...
SAcanuck-- good call but i dont think it will matter anyhow.
i find it amusing how PR have singled out spies as being a "flat track bully" whatever the hell that is, only because some bokke fans on here have said he "looks like tarzan but plays like jane". looks for yourselves PR, next you will be saying pocock and mccaw cheat and odriscoll is the best centre ever.
Posted 13:30 22nd June 2012
makemehappy says...
Very little evidence to suggest that SA won't win by more than 10!
Posted 13:07 22nd June 2012
heathy says...
Will the English win this one? Gosh, I hope they do as then they can take something away from this tour. I already think they have learned quite a lot if only that they are blinking miles away from where they need to be. BUT, it will come and this side do have the potential. If they do win it will be because the Boks are just not mentally as focussed. Let's be honest here, as much as England have huffed and puffed and done well to give the Boks a couple of good tests, you always felt that if England got too close, they would just say "okay boys, you've had your fun, now we are going to step up into third gear and blow you away". Thank the lord they stepped off the pedal in the second half of last week eh? If we do win (IF!!??) then I really do hope the media don't start going off on one about how close we were etc. We weren't. AT ALL!! We competed and that is as good as we could have hoped at this stage. England have the potential to grow and to be a decent team. South Africa, Australia and New Zealand already are (when were they not?). Go on Boks, let's have this one. We can pay.
Posted 12:45 22nd June 2012
undecided says...
@rugby_lord...means little girl
Posted 11:48 22nd June 2012
SACanuck says...
Don't know if Olivier is there to make Steyn look good or Steyn to make Olivier look good. Hope the plan works. If Boks play for 81 minutes they will win by 10
Posted 11:46 22nd June 2012
rugbylover says...
triprats
Posted 10:57 22nd June 2012
rugby_lord says...
What does Meisiekind mean???
Posted 10:51 22nd June 2012
Sharkyzulu says...
Oh dear, Meisiekind in at centre... Bok bench looking extremely weak, with Ruan Pienaar the only player of genuine international class. England's best chance of winning as the Bok team is the weakest of the series, however, the starting XV should hopefully have enough in the tank to build an insurmountable lead before the reckless subbing starts at 60 minutes.
Posted 09:03 22nd June 2012