Shane Williams: Milestone try, but it wasn't enough
Related links
Teams
Also see
Wales once again thrilled in a fightback on Friday, but could not find the final flourish, going down 26-20 to France in Cardiff.
20-0 down at the break and having barely threatened the French line, a pasting similar to Wembley's 51-0 horror show in 1999 looked on the cards for the Welsh. They looked bereft of ideas, inspiration and shape at times as the French defence read every move.
But once again, the second half brought out the best in the Welsh. They worked their way back in with forward play that was simply better-executed and which conjured up two penalties from Stephen Jones. They scored a super try through Leigh Halfpenny. They should have equalised when Jamie Roberts made a clean break and inexplicably held on to the ball when the pass to James Hook was both easier and more effective.
In the end, they ran out of steam. France found a modicum of the mojo they had displayed in the first half and managed to close out the game, despite a last-minute try from Shane Williams that brought up his half-century for Wales.
Match commentators sat back after this one, dropped headphones on desks and opined that Welsh home matches should come with a health warning. Whether that should be for the increase in blood pressure over the ineptitude of the first half or the pulse-quickening excitement of the second was not clear, but you're never going to have a dull moment at Welsh matches this year, it seems.
Indeed, the French played party poopers to the Welsh's favourite party trick, when Freddie Michalak managed to find the logical thought that Scotland could not and pumped the restart of the final play of the game straight into touch to end the match. You'd have put your shirt on Wales scoring the game-clinching try had he not.
Yet all that excitement aside, Wales need a serious period of introspection. It's a truism that Lions tourists are often off the boil the following season, but Lee Byrne and Jamie Roberts in particular were culpable for a series of morale-sapping errors which robbed the fightback of its impetus.
The laying of proper blame for the defeat must be laid squarely at whatever it is that makes the Welsh traipse out onto pitches needing forty-odd minutes of beating about for them to wake up. They've won some classic second halves this year, but they've been thrashed like second-tier nations in some first halves.
Out of all this, we should not forget that France are still on course for the Grand Slam everybody is now betting the shirt they did not put on Wales' last play on. We should also not discount the effectiveness of their first half display, with rampant and noticeably well-educated defence picking apart at Wales' weaknesses from the first whistle.
The French showed a knack for knowing where the ball would go next that is a fine advertisement for the preparations made by the coaching team before the game. Both tries came from intercepts, but a more telling pass-mark for the defence was the way the French prevented Wales from even coming close to their tryline.
Italy's current impersonation of an attack ought to be competently dealt with on this form, but it is this sort of intelligence in preparation that will stand the French in good stead when they head back to Paris for what is almost certain to be a Grand Slam-stakes clash with England.
Gatland had spoken all week about the need for a strong opening, yet France were able to cash in with a gift sixth-minute try.
James Hook's speculative pass to his centre partner Jamie Roberts went straight to Palisson, and he sprinted over unopposed from the halfway line for a score that Parra converted.
Hook's missed tackle led directly to an early Scotland score in Cardiff 13 days ago, and once again he was forced to reflect on a painful blunder.
Wales struggled to cope with Les Bleus' physical intensity, illustrated when their star centre Mathieu Bastareaud powered through his opposite number Roberts.
It resulted in Parra kicking his second penalty either side of Wales lock Jones limping off to be replaced by Newport Gwent Dragons forward Luke Charteris.
Wales had a mountain to climb at 13-0 adrift, and it soon became a case of Shane or bust.
Wing wizard Williams represented Wales' best - and seemingly only chance - of breaking down a mighty French defence.
But one from one of his trademark touchline darts, France scored a critical second try as half-time approached.
Williams was tackled, and after he lobbed the ball back to his supporting team-mates, it ricocheted straight into Trinh-Duc's hands and he easily finished off.
Parra's second conversion gave the visitors a 20-point interval lead, leaving Wales to contemplate a damage-limitation exercise before Jones opened their account through a 46th-minute penalty after an impressive counter-attack ended when Charteris spilled possession.
It was much brighter from Wales though, and Jones' second penalty lifted the capacity crowd after they were left stunned by a French first-half masterclass.
Things got even better after 62 minutes when Williams appeared in midfield and rifled a scoring pass to Halfpenny. Jones' wide-angled conversion made it 20-13 and set up a pulsating finish.
Roberts then made a sparkling break to keep Welsh hopes alive, yet he failed to find one of his supporting runners and a golden chance went begging.
In truth, it summed up Wales' night. A case of so near, so far, after once again leaving themselves with too much to do, although Williams provided one late flash of genius.
Man of the match: The match organisers gave it to Julien Bonnaire, but while he, along with Clement Poitrenaud, Francois Trinh-Duc, William Servat and Imanol Harinordoquy all impressed, we could not help but be bowled over by the energy of Nicolas Mas, who gave the Welsh a torrid time in the scrum and still found time to tackle Shane Williams.
Moment of the match: There is always so much to admire in Welsh games this year, but Shane Williams' late try, his 50th for his country, was a grand finale to remember.
Villain of the match: Welsh fans might not forget Lee Byrne's two penalties kicked into touch in-goal that cost his side critical late momentum.
The scorers:
For Wales:
Tries: Halfpenny, S Williams
Cons: S Jones 2
Pen: S Jones 2
For France:
Tries: Palisson, Trinh-Duc
Cons: Parra 2
Pens: Parra 2, Michalak
Wales:15 Lee Byrne, 14 Leigh Halfpenny, 13 James Hook, 12 Jamie Roberts, 11 Shane Williams, 10 Stephen Jones, 9 Richie Rees, 8 Ryan Jones(c), 7 Martyn Williams, 6 Jonathan Thomas, 5 Deiniol Jones, 4 Bradley Davies, 3 Adam Jones, 2 Huw Bennett, 1 Paul James.
Replacements:16 Ken Owens, 17 Rhys Gill, 18 Luke Charteris, 19 Sam Warburton, 20 Mike Phillips, 21 Andrew Bishop, 22 Tom Shanklin.
France:15 Clement Poitrenaud, 14 Julien Malzieu, 13 Mathieu Bastareaud, 12 Yannick Jauzion, 11 Alexis Palisson, 10 François Trinh-Duc, 9 Morgan Parra, 8 Imanol Harinordoquy, 7 Julien Bonnaire, 6 Thierry Dusautoir (c), 5 Julien Pierre, 4 Lionel Nallet, 3 Nicolas Mas, 2 William Servat, 1 Thomas Domingo.
Replacements:16 Dimitri Szarzewski, 17 Jean-Baptiste Poux, 18 Alexandre Lapandry, 19 Sébastien Chabal, 20 Frederic Michalak, 21 David Marty, 22 Marc Andreu.
Referee: Jonathan Kaplan (South Africa)
Assistant referees: Alan Lewis (Ireland), Simon McDowell (Ireland)
Television match official: Jim Yuille (Scotland)
Assessor: Steve Hilditch (Ireland)
Comments
JeanLucJoinel says...
to say France showed nothing, or were on the ropes is nonsense.
They had a great game plan- and had watched the tapes. Wales will concede interception tries. Pallisson was looking for that pass- thats no lucky try, just excellent defence , excellent preparation.
They were better than wales for 65 minutes of the game and outscored them when down to 14 men . It was not a brilliant french performance but in some senses a refreshingly professional one. credit to wales for bravery , but lets not pretend that this was some bizarre turn of events and wales were so unlucky'- they were beaten by a better team
Posted 23:09 28th February 2010
Sinolated says...
@choky: I think France deserved to win it. They had a scare in the 2nd half and Wales have deservedly won the 2nd half but in the 1st half Wales were pathetic. Bereft of ideas and no plan B to crack a flawless French defence. The reason France didn't play any rugby in the 1st half because they simply did not need to; Wales were making all the mistakes and France capitalised on it: that's what a good team does. They read their weaknesses and exploited them. You can't score intercept tries if you're not reading the gameplay and understanding your opponent. Even Lievremont knows that his team is not a finished article yet - but they will get there. You can't every single match convincingly... in any sport! Let alone rugby.
The bottom line remains that Wales never crossed the French 22 line until they scored their try by the 62nd minute. To keep Wales in the Millennium Stadium at arms length for over 3 quarters of the game is impressive. In my opinion, I don't think France needed to go into 2nd gear in the 1st half. There's a concern about their performance in the 2nd half; the table was turned and Wales kicked their way above the French defence line. Then all seemed to happen at once: Parra sin bin, Halfpenny try, the French briefly panicked. When Michalak entered the fray and landed that penalty, followed by Parra's return to the pitch and landing his penalty the sting was taken out of Wales.
You can't play away from home to a top team like Wales and not expect to conceed; they're spirited, brave, powerful, and love running-rugby which is always refreshing to see. France have done well in my opinion except for that 10 minutes (60-70th minute) were they seemed to have gone suicidal, but then snapped out of it.
@kije: France didn't contest Welsh ruck yesterday to provide numbers to keep Welsh centres and wings tied down. Worked like a charm (for 1st half anway..lol.)
Posted 12:54 27th February 2010
choky says...
the welsh deserved to win and if they had not made some stupid mistakes in second half they would have won - very poor rugby frm france - very disappointing - not a great team for sure
Posted 09:29 27th February 2010
isabelle713 says...
France had this in the bag the whole time in my opinion just very very disappoinetd in the second half they let Wales get back into the game. They could have easily won by so much more but the finish was horrible. I don't know if they wanted to reserve their energy or what not but it wasn't good to watch. The Williams try was ridiculous (from the Frenc point of view), Wales did nothing in the first half and France did just about nothing in the second half, confusing game by both sides but overall THREE OUT OF THREE for France so I'm happy for that reason alone.
Posted 02:11 27th February 2010
kije says...
Kiwifester, what match were you watching?
Posted 23:18 26th February 2010
kije says...
I live in France and like to see them do well, I like what Livremont is doing, they have the ability to be world beaters and often show it and that's the problem, often but not consistently, they are fatally inconsistent. If England hit their notes they will beat this team. England will hit the midfield they will suck in the French defence which was good this evening, but against England they will have to commit more men to the ruck or England will tear through them. Could be a good decider if England can only get past Ireland....
Posted 23:14 26th February 2010
Iyhel says...
Damn, now I've just missed this one ! Can never get used to the fact 6N matches can be played on friday nights...
Posted 22:33 26th February 2010
choky says...
i am french - i have often coomplained about french loosing games they should have won because reefering was partial and against them and they were loosing game despite they were playing better rugby but this time thats not the case - the welsh should have won - they are the only team which tried to create and except 2 lucky tries the french showed NOTHING at all except a good pack - so not thrilled at all y this french victory
Posted 22:28 26th February 2010
kiwifester says...
A comeback??? your kidding me ..Wales were never in the game ..possibly for 10 minutes after the usual french inconsitency...but never a comeback..another stupid idiotic mistake by the French at end not kicking ball out resulted in Williams who is nowhere near world class anymore a try..a side issue..why are basic skills so poor in rugby globally now..its a crime and becoming painful to watch
Posted 22:11 26th February 2010