Planet Rugby

Newbies of the Year

27th December 2012 12:31

Brodie Retallick under posts

Growing up fast: Brodie Retallick

Getting your shot in the first-team is part of the ongoing battle for rugby hopefuls, but in 2012 this group of starlets were given their chance.

Their fine efforts have not gone unnoticed by us here at Planet Rugby and we have consequently cobbled together a XV that although is lacking in caps, it makes up for in fearless exuberance.

As always, remember that those included in our recent senior Team of the Year are subsequently ineligible for this selection. Rules are rules.

Newbies of the Year

15 Andrew Horrell (Chiefs) - It was a close call with Brumbies full-back Jesse Mogg who, after a season of rugby league, made such a big impact in Canberra. Mogg has so much potential but in the end there was a number 15 in Waikato making all the right noises, with Horrell's try against the Cheetahs illustrating his running game while his rugby intelligence was apparent all season. The Chiefs have a real gem who is capable of filling in at centre.

14 Alex Cuthbert (Cardiff Blues) - Alex Cuthbert made a significant step up for both Cardiff Blues and Wales after originally coming to Test prominence in December last year. While a certain Ulster finisher, Craig Gilroy, was excellent, he had started to make noise in 2010 so Cuthbert took this jersey hands down. It's a boost that he recently re-signed and we can now expect a strong 2013 from a player who started all of Wales' end-of-year internationals.

13 Paul Jordaan (Sharks) - Leaving North Harbour and Blues youngster Francis Saili in the cold was tough but the form of Jordaan needed recognising. If the JWC star had not missed a spell due to injury, his year could have been even better. Jordaan has big potential.

12 Gael Fickou (Toulouse) - Came into the spotlight in this season's Heineken Cup but will struggle to get regular starts for Toulouse ahead of Florian Fritz et al. There is no question he has the temperament and ability to put pressure on Fritz and maybe Wesley Fofana in the future but for now Fickou knows there is a great deal more improving to be done. Other young centres worthy of applause are Luke Marshall (Ulster) and Tom Casson (Quins).

11 Willie le Roux (Cheetahs) - Simply superb in Bloemfontein this year. The wing or full-back who has past experience playing at 10 gave the Cheetahs so much going forward in Super Rugby. He also backed that up with a strong Currie Cup at Griquas, as his ability to mix creativity with beating a man made him a special player who is expected to shine when the new Super Rugby season rolls around. Mentions for Eli Walker and Johnny McNicholl.

10 Beauden Barrett (Hurricanes) - The 2010 U20 IRB World Championship winner was handed the fly-half reins in Wellington this season and did not disappoint. He scored 197 points for Mark Hammett's side as his running and kicking game entertained the masses, with one of many excellent performances coming against the Blues when he provided the match-winning try for Conrad Smith. Was rewarded with a NZ end-of-year tour squad place.

9 TJ Perenara (Hurricanes) - New Zealand is certainly blessed in the 9 department, with Aaron Smith, Piri Weepu, TJ Perenara and Kerr-Barlow knocking on the door. Smith was ineligible due to PR's full team honours so it was a shoot-out between the Hurricane and Chief, which was eventually won by Perenara after moments such as his inside ball against the Rebels seeing him make it. Can count himself unlucky not to make NZ's touring squad.

8 Billy Vunipola (London Wasps) - At 20, Vunipola has become a hot property in England, with Wasps director of rugby Dai Young already backing his number eight for an England call-up. Rightly so in our eyes as the brother of Saracens loosehead prop Mako has been improving with each game in 2012 and we expect that to continue next year. Two players also set to improve - after a strong ITM Cup and Top 14 - are Ardie Savea and Edwin Maka.

7 Michael Hooper (Brumbies) - If this call was made mid-year, I would have immediately written the name Marcell Coetzee after his outstanding early-season form for the Sharks. His bruising, all-action showings alongside Keegan Daniel and Willem Alberts immediately screamed "future Bok" and that is what he became. But for year-round efforts, Hooper gets in and is a worthy inclusion after consistently exceptional showings throughout 2012.

6 Iain Henderson (Ulster) - What a year it has been for Henderson. His form in the Junior World Championship in South Africa saw him receive plenty of praise before matches for Ulster in the Heineken Cup - due to the injury absence of Stephen Ferris - meant he was firmly on the Test radar for Ireland. Able to play lock, could he be a bolter for the Lions?

5 Samu Manoa (Northampton) - Manoa has been one of the finds of the year from the Saints due the American's size, power and pace. He arrived at Franklin's Gardens from San Francisco Golden Gate RFC and was an instant hit at the club, earning a fresh three-year contract as his reward. A mention also for Melbourne Rebels lock forward Cadeyrn Neville.

4 Brodie Retallick (Chiefs) - After losing Brad Thorn, the All Blacks needed a new grafting second-row under new coach Steve Hansen. Up stepped a 21-year-old from Rangiora who went on to win a Super Rugby winner's medal, the Rugby Championship and many plaudits along the way. Retallick was a real workhorse and sees off the impressive Joe Launchbury.

3 Ben Tameifuna (Chiefs) - From one new Chief to another, young but sizeable Tameifuna has been excellent for the tournament champions in 2012. Weighing in at 140kg, the 21-year-old formed a strong front-row unit with Sona Taumalolo and Mahonri Schwalger and it was intelligent of All Black selectors to get him involved in some training. Samson Lee has impressed for the Scarlets and is a very good prospect to be eased into the Welsh setup.

2 Tom Youngs (Leicester) - The converted centre edges Toulouse's Christopher Tolofua after taking his chance when the likes of Dylan Hartley and Rob Webber - originally ahead of him the pecking order - fell to injuries. He is still a work in progress but so far so good.

1 Mako Vunipola (Saracens) - Two starts, two man-of-the-matches is good by anyone's standards but for a prop it is quite a way to announce yourself. Vunipola is now a full England international and beats Stormers prop Steven Kitshoff to the final newbie jersey.

By Adam Kyriacou
@PlanetRugbyAK

Comments

JayStarr says...

I just read the 3rd paragraph... and remembered that Retallick did play at 4 for the AB's... But if players included in the senior xv team are not eligible for this team, then it shouldn't be called "Newbies of the year".

Posted 09:46 28th December 2012

new_j4a says...

@munster30, ...my 2c: I don't agree. (I have an interest in both....live here, but primary interest and loyalty is SH)

Posted 09:02 28th December 2012

JayStarr says...

And there I was thinking this was a pretty good list... until I saw you left Eben Etzebeth out - the most successful/impressive "newby" of the year! Absolutely inexcusable...

... Especially since the person picked ahead of him, Brodie Retallick, played at 5, not 4. And the person who filled Brad Thorne's role in the Crusaders/All Black squad was Luke Romano, not Brodie Retallick... I'm dumbfounded at this elementry oversight. Bad PR - go sit on the naughty chair.

The editor says.... JayStarr..... First off, the rules have been the same for three years, which is why Etzebeth didn't get in. Secondly, Retallick DID play at 4 for both the Chiefs and NZ (Sam Whitelock is 5 for ABs). Thirdly, Retallick was the original replacement for Thorn before Luke Romano overtook him later in the season. Retallick's selection was based on Super Rugby & Test form.

Posted 08:31 28th December 2012

TVaddict says...

@editor

Fair enough about Wade, what about my other English bias comments? :)

Although, it must be pretty damn tiring writing 'Read the third paragraph' so much. Could you perhaps post your team from last year to help us less memorable fans out for our comments?

Posted 02:53 28th December 2012

ABasquefan says...

For all those saying that E. Etzebeth was the best newby and he deserves being include in that list, it's true that he was one of the bests newbies but he can't be included for the same reason as Aaron Smith can't be: "Smith was ineligible due to PR's full team honours".

For the 15 spot, Charles Piutau's exhibition in the 2 Super Rugby matches he plyed it's much worthy than Horrell and Mogg's whole season. He's by far the most interesting prospect at fullback.

Who is no more a prospect cuz he got to be first choice nš 10 in the springboks team, is Johan Goosen. He's the more skillfull and complete young fly-half seen in a long time. Though Barret is a very good player, he has to improve his defense.

Posted 01:38 28th December 2012

pr_3 says...

I'll have whatever this writer is smoking...

Julian Savea must be on that list.. He didn't even get a mention!

The editor says.... Read the third paragraph.

Posted 00:42 28th December 2012

runnrugby says...

Beauden Barrett also made the test series against Ireland when he dummied O'Driscoll and put Adam Thompson in for his try. Him, Retallick and Tameifuna made the ABs before the end of year tour before completing their super rugby seasons. Id say Perenara is NZs best halfback and was unlucky with his injury coming during the test series break between super rugby.

Posted 23:36 27th December 2012

ben7 says...

Eben Etzebeth? Player of the year in my opinion and didnt even make the list.... Also where is Johan Goosen? Id choose him over Barrett any day. Same with Mogg over Horrell. Hooper over Coetzee? HA!! And Launchbury not there!?!?

The editor says.... See the third paragraph. Goosen was a newbie last year.

Posted 21:44 27th December 2012

Terry_English says...

I think Sam Cane was unlucky not to get a mention. His performances for the ABs were outstanding and every bit as good as Hoopers, except he had fewer opportunities.

Posted 19:31 27th December 2012

makemehappy says...

Though I only saw him in the NPC, I thought Charles Piutau looked comfortably the most exciting fullback appearing on the scene.

Posted 17:56 27th December 2012

banter_claus says...

horrall over mogg is controversial, and to leave out eben etzebeth is just plain scandalous

The editor says.... Read the third paragraph.

Posted 17:29 27th December 2012

munster30 says...

can we start separating these articles into Northern and Southern Hemisphere teams please? I am a huge rugby fan but to be honest my knowledge of Southern Hemisphere club rugby is limited. Mostly due to the fact that I have no interest in it.

Would be interested to know if other PR readers agree?

Posted 16:05 27th December 2012

jacquesdw says...

Can`t believe Etsebeth isn`t in this team. He would have been the first name I would`ve put down. Unbelievable opening season.

The editor says.... Read the third paragraph.

Posted 15:25 27th December 2012

TVaddict says...

A decent selection. Though at 27, and having announced himself for about two years ago, I wouldn't have defined Manu Samoa as a newbie, and so would have instead of had Launchbury at 5.

Now for my English bias. I'm guessing Tuilagi was counted as new last year but Farrell deserved the 10 slot for his 6 nations performance and game against the All Blacks. I know you guys don't like him but he's slightly younger than Beauden Barrett and he's already performing at international level. Possibly Ben Morgan deserves the mention above Vunipola as he's already on the international scene, though I agree that Vunipola is a fantastic prospect for England. Also Wade is a real prospect for England who probably deserves a mention under Cuthbert.

The editor says.... Wade made the team last year.

Posted 14:00 27th December 2012

jonesy2 says...

even as a chiefs fan im confused at seeing horrall over mogg. what are the criteria? first year players i guess? joe tomane is another obvious choice.

Posted 13:44 27th December 2012

Page 2 of 2

Character Count : 0/1900

  • RaboDirect PRO12 Fixtures
Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
RaboDirect PRO12
Saturday , May 25
Ulster vs Leinster16:45
More RaboDirect PRO12 fixtures
  • RaboDirect PRO12 Results
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
RaboDirect PRO12
Saturday , May 11
Leinster 17 - 15 GlasgowLeinster vs Glasgow Report
Friday , May 10
Ulster 28 - 17 ScarletsUlster vs Scarlets Report
Friday , May 3
Connacht 3 - 20 GlasgowConnacht vs Glasgow Report
Ulster 37 - 13 Cardiff BluesUlster vs Cardiff Blues Report
Zebre 25 - 27 MunsterZebre vs Munster Report
Scarlets 17 - 41 Benetton TrevisoScarlets vs Benetton Treviso Report
Leinster 37 - 19 OspreysLeinster vs Ospreys Report
Edinburgh 31 - 24 Newport Gwent D'gonsEdinburgh vs Newport Gwent D
Friday , April 26
Benetton Treviso 23 - 23 ConnachtBenetton Treviso vs Connacht Report
Sunday , April 21
Zebre 22 - 41 Leinster
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
  • RaboDirect PRO12 Table
RaboDirect PRO12 Table
PosTeamPPts
1Ulster2281
2Leinster2278
3Glasgow Warriors2276
4Scarlets2266
5Ospreys2262