Planet Rugby

Sorry, this story is unavailable

Comments

curates_egg says...

@KiwiRooster the cheeky Scotsman was Laidlaw - the outhalf.

In any case, this is bogus - it is de facto not a "team of Round 2", as Round 2 is not over. It is a team of the PR selection of the best players of the 2 games in the 2nd weekend of the 6 nations.

Posted 09:44 16th February 2012

quietbrit says...

Farrell has yet to impress in attack. His defense is solid (and like that of England as a whole over-rated IMO). He was behind Roberts in the 12 stakes.

I would have said that Jones and Cole were the picks for #3 berth.

Lions talk for anyone is premature - that is for next six nations not this one.

Posted 23:01 13th February 2012

curates_egg says...

Sorry to state the obvious but: Round 2 is not over!

Posted 20:44 13th February 2012

edhutson says...

@bruno 74 that looks like such a welshmans selection, for team of the week im supprised palmer and hartley werent in there, both got through alot of work in rome and acted as leaders.

anyway just because i can, my lions 22:

1)Jenkins

2)Best

3)Jones

4)Gray

5)O'Connell (captain if BODs not playing)

6)Ferris

7)Warburton

8)Heaslip

9)Phillips

10)Sexton

11)North

12)Roberts

13)Bod/Tuilangi

14)Ashton

15)Foden

16)Hartley

17)Jacobsen

18)Lawes

19)O'Brien

20)Dickson?? (looked very sharpe last weeked, dont rate murray or the scots atm)

21)Farrell (probably best kicker atm, can play 12)/Priestland (best attacker)

22)Kearney

Posted 20:18 13th February 2012

AlanS says...

If the team is picked on 2 games, then Farrell would never get in given you have a proven kicker in Halfpenny (who can also score tries) and, based on 2 games, Farrell has done little more than kick (very good) goals. Also a little generous putting Robshaw in. I think Rennie is vastly superior over the 2 games so far.

Posted 19:40 13th February 2012

papachinzo says...

Interesting to pick a welsh man in the second-row, considering they have the worst Line-out in the tournament thus far.

Have to say, Ross Rennie(7) and Sean Lamont(12) stood out more for me... I also thought Priestland had a poor game, I'm not 100% sure about him at this level(just my opinion). No mention for Zanni or Masi either, I thought they had good games also.

Posted 18:02 13th February 2012

DBRowan says...

Cittadini go absolutely muched by Corbisiero... just like Castro did before he went off.

Posted 15:54 13th February 2012

Carpelone says...

Robshaw? For tripping Parisse? Fair team otherwise, maybe Adam Jones at 3, however I like when new faces are mentioned.

That try from Benvenuti should have earned him a mention, at least. Ashton was unable to reduce the gap.

Posted 15:18 13th February 2012

Houston_11 says...

Completely agree with Jose_Jones.

Is Chris Robshaw actually picking this team every week? I really can't understand how he's beaten Rennie both times. Even Shingler was better than Robshaw. It will be interesting to see if he retains the captaincy for the next game.

And as for the British Lions XV... I guarantee you that a lot of that will change. Remember that in 2008, the in form back row in the six nations were Scotland's with the infamous Killer B's, even outplaying Ireland's in Dublin. The following year, none of them even made the Lions squad.

Best not to be too premature just because one team has a good showing.

And I'd say if Conor Murray keeps improving at the rate he is, he's most likely the no9 next year in Australia.

Posted 13:09 13th February 2012

JMehrtens says...

@adamk

you don't mind he cost Scotland 7 points?

Posted 13:03 13th February 2012

jose_jones says...

""slaps head in disbelief""

Robshaw ahead of Rennie,.... again!!!!

I don't think so...!!!

Posted 11:33 13th February 2012

adamk says...

I'd swap Priestland for Laidlaw. Priestland wasn't at his best, Laidlaw was. The teams were never even is all. ;)

Also Roberts over Farrell. Roberts was showing some of his oldschool skills in the second half, breaking nearly every tackle. Farrell was anonymous save his kicking.

Posted 11:26 13th February 2012

bruno74 says...

British Lions 1st 15

1. Jenkins

2. Ford

3. Jones

4. Gray

5. O'connel

6. Lydiate

7. Wartburton

8. Falatau

9. Philips

10. Preistland

11. North

12. Roberts

13 Tuilagi

14. Halpenny

15. Foden/Kearney

Posted 11:23 13th February 2012

lawynd says...

I'm not sure about Farrell's inclusion; if all that was required is his kicking from the tee we might as well go back to 10-man rugby. And Robshaw was impressive, but as a blindside; he did very little in the role that a seven is supposed to play. Also, Cittadini? England didn't have it all their own way in the scrum but came out on top overall, over both Castro and Cittadini, and Cole showed more around the park than his opposite number, too.

Posted 11:17 13th February 2012

Page 1 of 1

Character Count : 0/1900

  • RBS Six Nations Fixtures
  • RBS Six Nations Table
RBS Six Nations Table
PosTeamPPts
1Wales58
2England58
3Scotland54
4Italy54
5Ireland53
6France53