Planet Rugby

Ireland

Ireland

Carter drop breaks Irish hearts

16th June 2012 08:17

all blacks v ireland

All Blacks: Deny Irish at the death

Ireland turned up the heat in freezing conditions to push New Zealand all the way, before eventually succumbing to a 22-19 defeat in Christchurch on Saturday.

With the scores level at 19-19 and one minute remaining in the match, All Blacks pivot Dan Carter broke Irish hearts with a last-gasp drop goal to win the game and the series.

It was a valiant effort from the visitors, who led the world champions by one point (9-10) at half-time, but were left playing catch-up following an early try to Aaron Smith two minutes after the break.

But the men in green managed to claw their way back and when All Blacks full-back Israel Dagg was yellow-carded in the 72nd minute, Ireland were presented with a golden opportunity to retake the lead from 49m out.

However, Jonathan Sexton's attempt had the direction but not the distance as the ball fell agonisingly short. From there the hosts put themselves into a position to set up Carter for the match-winning drop.

His first attempt off his right boot, however, clipped an Irish hand and sailed wide. But Carter wouldn't miss the second attempt, and this time - off his left foot - sent the ball between the sticks.

Jubilation for the All Blacks, heartbreak for the brave Irish.

Declan Kidney's troops had promised they would up the intensity after being run off the park a week ago and they were certainly true to their word as the visitors - roared on by dozens of Irish fans - threatened to snaffle their first-ever Test win over the All Blacks in their 26th attempt.

Ireland supporters would have been choking on their Guinness after looking at the scoreboard to see the visitors 10-0 ahead in the opening quarter of the match thanks to an early try from Conor Murray and the boot of Sexton.

Ireland made the most of an early line-out close to New Zealand's line with brilliant effect, mauling the ball superbly before Murray - despite having no blindside support - made a dart to get the ball over for the try. Sexton added the conversion and nine minutes later he added his first penalty.

The All Blacks were able to put their first points on the board through a Carter penalty in the 21st minute. As in the first Test, Ireland went off the boil when the game headed into the second quarter and as New Zealand's intensity grew, the home side forced errors at the breakdown. This allowed Carter to add two more three-pointers that closed the gap even further.

The number ten had a chance to put his team in front on the stroke of half-time, but his fourth penalty attempt didn't have the legs and allowed Ireland to head into the half-time sheds 10-9 ahead.

That lead lasted just two minutes after the resumption before Smith grabbed his first Test try after a burst from Sonny Bill Williams. Williams crashed into the Ireland pack and as the All Blacks piled in, their livewire scrum-half was driven over the line for the try that Carter duly converted.

Any thoughts that the floodgates might open as they did in Auckland seven days ago, were dispelled as Ireland rallied with Sexton adding his second penalty in another strong attacking period that had the All Blacks scrambling to make try-saving tackles.

But with that storm weathered, the momentum again swung the other way and Carter's fourth penalty extended New Zealand's lead to 19-13.

Ireland then came back with two more Sexton penalties levelling the scores to set up a dramatic finale.

Pressure mounted on New Zealand as Adam Thomson joined Kieran Read on the injured list, leaving them only two specialist loose forwards. Dagg's sin-binning for a late charge on Rob Kearney didn't help matters either for the hosts.

But at 19-all and a man down, the All Blacks rallied one last time and fittingly, Carter - a Canterbury local - was there to hold his nerve and seal the outcome.

Man of the match: For New Zealand, Dan Carter was obviously the man of the moment thanks to his match-winning drop-goal. But it's hard to look past the gallant Irish who silenced their critics with a superb effort that came within fractions of the most famous Irish win in history against the world champions. And it's for that reason why we've opted for a collective award to the entire Ireland team.

Moment of the match: With 40 seconds of the match remaining, it has to be Carter's winning drop goal.

Villain of the match: Israel Dagg's brain implosion that so nearly cost his team defeat.

The scorers:

For New Zealand:
Try: A Smith
Con: Carter
Pens: Carter 4
Drop: Carter

For Ireland:
Try: Murray
Con: Sexton
Pens: Sexton 4

Yellow card: Dagg, 72 mins (New Zealand, foul play)

New Zealand: 15 Israel Dagg, 14 Zac Guildford, 13 Conrad Smith, 12 Sonny Bill Williams, 11 Julian Savea, 10 Dan Carter, 9 Aaron Smith, 8 Kieran Read, 7 Richie McCaw (c), 6 Adam Thomson, 5 Sam Whitelock, 4 Brodie Retallick, 3 Owen Franks, 2 Andrew Hore, 1 Tony Woodcock.
Replacements: 16 Hika Elliot, 17 Ben Franks, 18 Ali Williams, 19 Sam Cane, 20 Piri Weepu, 21 Aaron Cruden, 22 Ben Smith.

Ireland: 15 Rob Kearney, 14 Fergus McFadden, 13 Brian O'Driscoll (c), 12 Gordon D'Arcy, 11 Andrew Trimble, 10 Jonathan Sexton, 9 Conor Murray, 8 Jamie Heaslip. 7 Sean O'Brien, 6 Kevin McLaughlin, 5 Donnacha Ryan, 4 Dan Tuohy, 3 Mike Ross, 2 Rory Best, 1 Cian Healy.
Replacements: 16 Sean Cronin, 17 Declan Fitzpatrick, 18 Donncha O'Callaghan, 19 Peter O'Mahony, 20 Eoin Reddan, 21 Ronan O'Gara, 22 Simon Zebo.

Referee: Nigel Owens (Wales)

By Dave Morris

Comments

bigb6969 says...

Just re-watched the game from Saturday - yes the IRB certainly give McCaw special treatment, because he was eye gouged in 2nd half maul. His was just just raked once, but four times in one incident - all was obvious attacking of the face, but one was a definite scrap as the fingers catch in his eyes. Mark of the man (will I say stupidity) he did not say anything. If I can get around to it I will post that on the net.

PS: I see some mention of Trinats not liking Joubert. I know I heard that NZ had won every test under Joubert, and of them was versus Australia. However that is not true, I was watching an old test (I have recorded every AB tests for the last 7 years) and my son pointed out - isn't that Joubert, and it was. NZ lost that test in 19-34 in Sydney

Posted 07:17 20th June 2012

new_j4a says...

@Trinats, refs are like wives: you think they're an impediment to progress until you try to live without them. In a perfect world you'd have a German mechanic, a French chef. and English policeman and a Saffa Ref (and wife)

Posted 16:24 19th June 2012

Trinats2 says...

KiwiLad:

LOL, been there, it's more like hell !!!

Posted 14:36 19th June 2012

Trader2 says...

@KiwiLad that was very funny cos Trinats just loves Eden Park, especially with a Saffa ref. Can't wait until Aug 25.

Posted 14:25 19th June 2012

KiwiLad says...

Ironicaly Trinats, when in heaven, watching the game they play there, You will be at the garden of EDEN Park.

Posted 10:55 19th June 2012

Trinats2 says...

Trader2:

While in Heaven, watching the game they play there, I promise to send a post card down south (at least you'll be warm for a change !!).

Posted 10:38 19th June 2012

makemehappy says...

@trelawney - UK and I know they did - just wrongly.

Posted 20:31 18th June 2012

Golden_statenba says...

Respect to Irland and all that but I don't understand all the praise they lost the game and the series?? You can loose by 20 or loose by 2 but in the end you loose?

You don't get consistancy by accepting mediocrity.

Posted 16:55 18th June 2012

Trader2 says...

Hi @Trinats thought you had died and gone to heaven, you have been a bit quiet. Whatsamatter no QC in the team yet, Horwill out for the year (seriously on this real bad luck for JH and hope all goes well and he is back soon, the Wannabies will miss him), Beale in strife, the Reds going down to the Canes, the Baby Wannabie U20's are going to finish last or next to it, or is it just that the Big Boy Wannabies don't look that great against a pretty ordinary Welsh outfit. Oh and by the way RM never praises the opposition it's called "never give a sucker an even break" he must have had the same coach at Otago Boys High as I did.

Posted 15:21 18th June 2012

lacroix says...

i think the dagg yellow card was harsh...debateable and not 'clear cut' by any definition. i think Irish fans would have exploded if that had been the other way round.

all the same i agree that the all blacks got a few breaks from Owens but they still deserved to win...just. a brave effort in sporadic bursts by Ireland, helped by some desperately bad individual perfomances from all blacks- Mccaw was awful all game, and disgracefully bad mannered in the post match. but he has previous in that respect- he's a bad sport on and off the field , and a very unfortunate reflection on the otherwise generally wonderful rugby culture of NZ. a great shame and an embarassment for the hosts.

on the other hand i think some of the hyperbole about the irish performance is a bit silly. they weren't all that good. they have a massive problem with their front row- woodcocks poor game gave them a respite this time, but they're vulnerable- and the whole team look bereft of ideas a lot of the time. when their opponents put them under sustained pressure they crack- they were just fortunate that every time the ABs started to build pressure Mccaw knocked on.

Posted 14:47 18th June 2012

lacroix says...

mccaw really is a disgrace

Posted 14:40 18th June 2012

crunchfit says...

@Euskadi

Maybe that's what you're saying now. That's not what you said before and I can only respond to what you actually write, not what you thought you meant / mean now.

Intent doesn't matter with regards to could play. Self-preservation, natural-inclination or otherwise. Anyway, you could see Dagg looking at Kearney and he didn't try to move his forearm out of the way of Kearney's jaw. That couldn't have been much easier to do but he still hits Kearney.

You seem to be basing the fact that Dagg doesn't deserve a yellow on the fact that he didn't mean to do what he did, which is irrelevant (and I think you're wrong anyway). Read the rules.

At least 3 fouls were committed [1) late charge 2) led with shoulder 3) struck Kearney with his forearm / elbow] and each can warrant a yellow on its own.

Easy decision. The referee's decision was not retarded. Your issue should be with Dagg.

Posted 14:26 18th June 2012

crunchfit says...

@Euskadi

It was a 50 / 50 call without the shoulder and elbow, but he lead with the shoulder and struck Kearney with his elbow / forearm in the face. You could argue that he may not have been able to pull out, but he could easily have avoided striking Kearney too.

Posted 14:12 18th June 2012

crunchfit says...

@blametheref / kinsman

I think he said it happened in 1991. I wouldn't use an experience of meeting some idiots over two decades ago to judge the general quality of Irish fans in 2012.

It seems strange that you say it was rugby supporters who you met. Of all of Ireland at that time, they'd be the most aware of the flag. I doubt it was rugby supporters who you met.

It's disappointing to see an individual to completely withdraw his support of the Ireland team (and hope that others win against them) based on idiocy by some ignorant Irish people and it's a shame to hold the same views for all Irish fans more than twenty years later. I don't think it's a particularly fair or rational view of us either. We are not like that.

Posted 14:11 18th June 2012

Ramage says...

Seems I spoke too soon as up pops a real good Irish troll named foxrock, so sad sigh!. Once again a myopic attack on good referees.What a sad person. Oh by the way would he please provide other readers and myself with either a quote from Hansen or a clip from some website where he acknowledged NZ won because of a wrong call from the referee.

Posted 14:08 18th June 2012

Norm says...

Hi Goy

Your not butting in mate, it is a discussion board. But you are wrong on one thing, I am not trying to have any moral high ground, just embarrassed by the tone of debate that is sometimes set. I am no angel and do like to challenge or bait a debater who I feel is either flawed or a fraud.

However whatever chicanery I have enered into with you in the past (and sorry if it offended it was funny though) I hope that it has been secondary to a discussion about rugby. While you still hold some outlandish ideas and conspiarcy theories, the Cork/ Kerry dark overlords etc etc generally you have a view on some rugby too. That I think in both our cases is the distinction from being in a discussion and being a troll.

Anyway go check out the team of the week, Norm flying the Sexyboy flag whatever next!

Posted 13:22 18th June 2012

Trinats2 says...

foxrock:

Have to agree (not about the ref) I also picked up McCaw in his post match interview never mentioned the Irish or gave them credit, can't recall if he even thanked the crowd ?.

While in Briso last year in the super 15 final McCaw walked his team off as Reds captain was making his winning speech, very rude.

Posted 13:06 18th June 2012

new_j4a says...

@Rosbif digital palingenesis necessitated by a breach of PR's digital fortress or a simple human error which wiped out part of the community....nevertheless, in this incarnation the rugby has been superb and the claret tastes just as good even though attempts to ascend to a higher intellectual plane have been only moderately successful....so far. Your comment on rugby strategy, I think shows the way forward.

Posted 10:39 18th June 2012

foxrock says...

The game was won for NZ by the ref - a fact that even NZ Coach Hansen acknowledged - but of course McCheat was as gracious as ever, which is to say not at all, in his post match comments. As with his comments after the world cup final - won by the ref for NZ - he's shows himself to be a myopic poor sport. It's a shame, because it would provide a much better example, that NZ aren't captained by the peerless and sporting and gracious Carter.

Posted 10:01 18th June 2012

blametheref says...

...and I have to add that President de Valera signed Hitler's book of condolences notwithstanding that thousands of Irish joined the British army voluntarily and gave their lives fighting Hitler

Posted 09:40 18th June 2012

Page 2 of 11

Character Count : 0/1900

  • Ireland Fixtures
Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
International Match
Saturday , June 8
USA vs IrelandTBC
Saturday , June 15
Canada vs IrelandTBC
More International Match fixtures
  • Table
RBS Six Nations Table
PosTeamPPts
1Wales58
2England58
3Scotland54
4Italy54
5Ireland53
6France53