Planet Rugby

Rugby Championship: XV of the Week

08th October 2012 14:19

Ma a Nonu try South Africa New Zealand 2012

Mixed it up: Ma'a Nonu

Now that the dust has settled in the southern hemisphere, Planet Rugby looks at the players who stole the show in the Rugby Championship.

15 Mike Harris (Australia): In for the injured Berrick Barnes, Harris played a telling role for the Wallabies. Not even red and green lasers could stop the full-back from slotting seven out of his eight kicks at goal for a personal haul of 20 points.

14 Gonzalo Camacho (Argentina): By far Argentina's best back on show in Rosario, Camacho was full of running and gained a whopping 44m for his team in attack whilst he was also responsible for several turnovers for the Pumas.

13 Conrad Smith (New Zealand): Gave the Springbok tacklers a torrid time as the veteran centre continually sucked in defenders. Led a defensive line that barely faltered, whilst also ran in for New Zealand's bonus-point try. Reliable as ever.

12 Ma'a Nonu (New Zealand): Using his considerable mass to great effect in both defence and attack, Nonu turned the match on its head with his early second-half try that both side's described as the turning point of the Test. Mention too for Pat McCabe who was a demon on defence.

11 Hosea Gear (New Zealand): Needed a big performance and delivered. A constant threat out wide with ball in hand and helped set up Aaron Smith's well-worked try. All Blacks coach Steve Hansen won't be having sleepless nights with the number of destructive wings at his disposal, that's for sure!

10 Dan Carter (New Zealand): It's becoming quite a tricky task finding new descriptions for the All Blacks playmaker after silencing a crowd of 85,000 by piloting the world champions to success at altitude.

9 Nick Phipps (Australia): Tough one this. Aaron Smith hardly put a foot wrong, but neither did Phipps who controlled the wet ball well in slippery conditions and came oh so close to scoring.

8 Kieran Read (New Zealand): A staggering work-rate once again from the number eight. Had Bok defenders frantically back-pedalling whenever he got his safe hands on the pigskin.

7 Michael Hooper (Australia): The Wallabies' young gun was a standout in Rosario - not only did he produce one of the few Test highlights by racing 60 metres downfield after grabbing an opposition line-out throw, but was also Australia's leading defender with 10 tackles.

6 Liam Messam (New Zealand): Has very quickly implanted himself as an important member of this All Blacks team, stepping up his consistency and impact. The loss of Jerome Kaino doesn't look to be a massive train smash after all.

5 Sam Whitelock (New Zealand): An accomplished Test performance from the big man in the second row for NZ. Landed the first uppercut for the All Blacks when he charged in for his team's opening try and was a leading line-out taker.

4 Nathan Sharpe (Australia): Australia's fourth stand-in skipper led from the front superbly, kept his ill-discipline in check and gave as good he received against a strong Pumas pack.

3 Jannie du Plessis (South Africa): His work-rate wasn't overly visible which isn't always a bad thing. But what we did see from Doctor du Plessis in his 50-odd minutes on the field was an injection of power at scrum-time.

2 Andrew Hore (New Zealand): Played with intensity and urgency. Was almost mistaken for a loose forward at times!

1 Tendai Mtawarira (South Africa) Another tough position to fill. It's never easy going head to head against the All Blacks front-row, but the Beast did his reputation little harm.

Comments

jmanngod says...

No McCaw? No idea!

Posted 00:20 09th October 2012

aucknz13 says...

Thank god you don't select any team that counts!

Posted 00:16 09th October 2012

georgesmith says...

M. Hooper has arrived and he deserves it so too. R. McCheat will soon be history. Maybe a museum is the place for him now. I did not see any good work by him against the Sprinbgoks. Maybe tis because he was not allowed to cheat by the referee.

N.Sharpe's selection is so biased. A lock with always hands on the hips. What a farce? S. Timani was doing all the hard work and over-rated N.Sharpe takes all the credit. Shameful and disgraceful.

Posted 23:56 08th October 2012

Polyboy says...

@leebok are we ever going to see s bok fan on this site that loses gracefully.

Posted 23:08 08th October 2012

rugbylover says...

@leebok..........In fact, following on from your comments, all the AB's past victories should be declared null & void - against all opposition in perpetuity.

I think that about covers it. OK?

Posted 22:33 08th October 2012

olepete says...

leebok, thank you for restoring my faith in SA refbashing, I thought you'd all learned to accept your defeats!

Posted 22:22 08th October 2012

olepete says...

leebok, thank you for restoring my faith in SA refbashing, I thought you'd all learned to accept your defeats!

Posted 22:22 08th October 2012

Trinats2 says...

Did Deans select this team ? How could you leave out Higgers after giving him a 9 ???

Also only one Aussie in the pack when they had one of the best packs in the world going backwards !!!

Hooper could take over Pocock as the best No7 in the world.

Posted 21:16 08th October 2012

S_Dog says...

Worst team of the week ever

Posted 20:57 08th October 2012

nzmaoriboy says...

Pretty even team! may have picked Louw for messam..and woodcock instead of beast!

Posted 20:36 08th October 2012

leebok says...

McCaw left out because playing the ball on the ground or being offside counts against you. Also, Read should have been carded and pen try awarded after he deliberately brought a rolling maul down 3m out, buf ref ignored it.

Posted 18:17 08th October 2012

Kiwikev says...

Rubbish is the word that you are alluding to AVP1...

Posted 18:04 08th October 2012

rugbylover says...

Did you use a pin..............or a coin?

Posted 17:55 08th October 2012

KeaJHB says...

Peculiar selections given the team ratings that appeared on this very website after the weekend's matches.

Harris (7) preferred over Dagg (8)

Nonu (7) preferred over McCabe (8)

Sharpe (6) in even though the "lock replacement" Scott Higgin-botham was rated a 9

Both Spingbok props selected even though they were both ranked the lowest at 4 apiece (both the Puma and All Black props were rated 6).

Rather strange...

Posted 16:06 08th October 2012

melkdave says...

Well a bit of a mixed bag this week ,dont realy think any wallabies deserve to be in the XV myself,yes Harris/Sharpe and Hooper did well ,but any good play in that match would stand out like a sore thumb same with Camacho.Mtself i would have had Dagg,Habana and F/Louw/ Ramano instead but its all subjective anyway,and doesnt really matter.

Posted 15:44 08th October 2012

Terry_English says...

How can you leave out McCaw. Do you guys ever look at the stats? In every game he plays he is more involved than any other player.

Posted 15:05 08th October 2012

APV1 says...

One word...

Posted 14:54 08th October 2012

Page 2 of 2

Character Count : 0/1900

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
International Match
Sunday , May 26
England vs BarbariansEngland vs Barbarians Preview
More International Match fixtures
Super Rugby
Friday , May 31
Crusaders vs Waratahs08:35
Brumbies vs Hurricanes10:40
Saturday , June 1
Highlanders vs Blues08:35
Reds vs Melbourne Rebels10:40
Stormers vs Southern Kings16:05
Cheetahs vs Bulls18:10
More Super Rugby fixtures
British & Irish Lions
Saturday , June 1
Barbarians vs British & Irish Lions12:30
More British & Irish Lions fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Aviva Premiership
Saturday , May 25
Leicester 37 - 17 NorthamptonLeicester vs Northampton Report
More Aviva Premiership results
RaboDirect PRO12
Ulster 18 - 24 LeinsterUlster vs Leinster Report
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
Top 14
Clermont Auvergne 9 - 25 CastresClermont Auvergne vs Castres Report
More Top 14 results
Super Rugby
Blues 13 - 20 BrumbiesBlues vs Brumbies Report
Western Force 19 - 18 HighlandersWestern Force vs Highlanders Report
Stormers 20 - 15 RedsStormers vs Reds Report
Sharks 16 - 18 BullsSharks vs Bulls Report
Southern Kings 22 - 34 CheetahsSouthern Kings vs Cheetahs Report
More Super Rugby results
Top 14
Friday , May 24
Toulon 24 - 9 ToulouseToulon vs Toulouse Report
More Top 14 results
Super Rugby
Chiefs 28 - 19 CrusadersChiefs vs Crusaders Report
Melbourne Rebels 24 - 22 WaratahsMelbourne Rebels vs Waratahs Report
More Super Rugby results
Heineken Cup
Saturday , May 18
Clermont Auvergne 15 - 16 ToulonClermont Auvergne vs Toulon Report
More Heineken Cup results
Super Rugby
Crusaders 23 - 3 BluesCrusaders vs Blues Report
Waratahs 28 - 22 BrumbiesWaratahs vs Brumbies Report
Cheetahs 27 - 13 RedsCheetahs vs Reds Report
Bulls 35 - 18 HighlandersBulls vs Highlanders Report
More Super Rugby results
Amlin Challenge Cup
Friday , May 17
Stade Francais 13 - 34 LeinsterStade Francais vs Leinster Report
More Amlin Challenge Cup results
Super Rugby
Hurricanes 12 - 17 ChiefsHurricanes vs Chiefs Report
Western Force 13 - 23 SharksWestern Force vs Sharks Report
Melbourne Rebels 30 - 21 StormersMelbourne Rebels vs Stormers Report
More Super Rugby results
Aviva Premiership
Sunday , May 12
Saracens 13 - 27 NorthamptonSaracens vs Northampton Report
Saturday , May 11
Leicester 33 - 16 HarlequinsLeicester vs Harlequins Report
More Aviva Premiership results
RaboDirect PRO12
Leinster 17 - 15 GlasgowLeinster vs Glasgow Report
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
Top 14
Castres 25 - 12 MontpellierCastres vs Montpellier Report
More Top 14 results
Super Rugby
Blues 36 - 32 Melbourne RebelsBlues vs Melbourne Rebels Report
More Super Rugby results