ruckingkiwi says...

" There must be a reason why is legality is qustioned by non Kiwis"

Yes Carpelone, I would call that jealousy, being a poor loser or many other such things... you tell me? I would say the dozens of referees who have referreed the guy in his 250+ first class games would know best, wouldn't you?

I would say 99% (+) people bend their knees when they get about in everyday day life, except maybe unless you're the Pistorius guy who they let bounce around with titanium legs.. what is it with SA, last Olympics there was an alledged man running with the girls and this time titanium legs, what next?

Anyway, I think a better example of dirty play would be watching Burger with his finger poking into Fitzgeralds eye. Nice.

Posted 01:30 24th July 2012

Sprogrugby says...

Carpelone, the one thing I would say is I would never say McCaw was 'dirty' in the foul play sense of the word. I saw that Parra knee and did not think it was the cynical act that others did - sure somebody got hurt but that happens when you're between the opposition and the ball. I assume you're fishing when you refer to the reasoning behind his bent right knee - unless you're an expert on biomechanics (which you may very well be) ?

Posted 15:26 23rd July 2012

Sprogrugby says...

I thought McCaw was immense in this game, his work rate and sheer presence at critical times was amazing. I have opinions on his legality and don't want to open that can of worms in this thread (thank you trolls), as I think he is not only superbly skilled but also superb at readings refs and situations. There is no denying that in this game, as in other 'major' games, he steps up. Legend ! (and I'm not a kiwi - married to one who'd divorce me if Richie ever came to town :)

Posted 01:31 23rd July 2012

AWEBLAX says...

Pierre please teach Genia how to lose graciously.......the Sharks gameplan was just as good if not better then the Crusaders and its a shame Genia didn't acknowledge that. Well played Richie..........

Posted 00:13 22nd July 2012