Planet Rugby

Sorry, this story is unavailable

Comments

melkdave says...

Vuna was lucky really it wasnt a straight red ,you cant run straight though a player in the air ,FULL STOP.It is very dangerous to do so ,and is rightly penalised by the IRB and refereesThe fact its unintentional really shouldnt have any bearing on a referees decision, but alot of referees these days seem scared to make HARD decisions ,and either pass the buck to the TMO for tries ect or citing commissionier,for bad tackles and unsportman like conduct.I really hope that referees start growing a pair soon ,and make decisions .Dosent matter if they are right or wrong ,as long as they are honest decisions.

Posted 20:55 17th June 2012

jontheref says...

It is in the report.

"Vuna faces being banned for the third Test after sin-binned in the 59th minute for taking Halfpenny out in mid-air in contravention of Law 10.4(e) Dangerous Tackling, and 10.4(i) Tackling the jumper in the air. "

Posted 15:45 17th June 2012

anotherfarce says...

@Jonesy2

Are you a total moron?? I am absolutely certain you have never played this game or have any inclination as to the rules that govern it, unless your a site moderator just getting a thread going???

An opposition player may contest the ball in the flight, but he/she must not interfere with the airborne player in any other circumstance!!!

In your (experienced???) opinion did Vuna contest the ball?

This particular rule is one of the most sensible ever to be invoked to the game of rugby union in order to avert head neck & spinal injuries, due to a player not being able to control his/her landing.

Vuna should have without doubt been given a red card, but you somehow state Halfpenny should have been penalised for the knee in the head of Vuna as he charged through Halfpenny in mid air!!

Halfpenny did come down on his head & sholders and was very lucky. You on the other hand need to get a rule book & grow a brain, please do the latter first just in case your not sure!!

Posted 11:25 17th June 2012

Ramage says...

jontheref there you go again with the ambiguous name you give yourself you make a pontifical statement "far worse than any of the tip tackles that have brought red in the last year or so. Well thanks for your great knowledge especially when you are comparing incidents in other games. Of course your experience as a junior referee far outweighs that of the guy refereeing the game. Just a suggestion it would be better to add the words In My Opinion. Had you done so I would not have written this post but I strongly disagree with your comment quoted above. In my opinion to say it was very dangerous and brutal is I believe an over reaction and in sanitizing the game it will soon be illegal to touch an opponent.

Posted 09:27 17th June 2012

tha_mai says...

just trying improve on his stats from first test - made two tackles and missed five; I was surprised he even made the 22 for this test, whether he gets a suspension or not, surely he won't be selected for next week, Robbie?

Posted 08:37 17th June 2012

jonesy2 says...

how can he be cited for a dangerous tackle when he didnt tackle anyone? he run towards the ball and then copped a knee to the head from an airbourne halfpenny who as a result flipped up and landed dangerously.

Posted 06:49 17th June 2012

Tails81 says...

Idiot! Get rid of him for the next game. Beale to fullback and AAC to wing.

Also, replace Alexander on the bench. Our scrum became a shambles once he came on.

Posted 05:38 17th June 2012

startledwombat says...

I'm not optimistic here. Vuna has a track record on this sort of thing. To my uneducated eye they almost always look like mistakes, but after this latest incident I am forced to one of two theories, I don't know which:

- he's a slow learner especially at the faster pace of test level, or

- he's a nasty piece of work cunning enough to camouflage his deliberately foul play.

I lean towards the first explanation, not the second.

Posted 00:35 17th June 2012

jontheref says...

Wales lost because they could not close the game out.

If the tipping had been a red, who knows?

Very few refs will give a red for this, but it was very dangerous and brutal.

Far worse than any of the tip tackles that have brought red in the last year or so.

But that is up to the iRB, bless them, to ajudicate on.

Posted 20:28 16th June 2012

Page 1 of 1

Character Count : 0/1900

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
International Match
Saturday , June 22
New Zealand vs France08:35
Scotland vs Italy14:15
South Africa vs Samoa17:15
Sunday , June 23
Fiji vs Tonga12:10
Japan vs USA14:10
More International Match fixtures
British & Irish Lions
Saturday , June 22
Australia vs British & Irish Lions11:05
Tuesday , June 25
Melbourne Rebels vs British & Irish Lions10:40
More British & Irish Lions fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
International Match
Wednesday, June 19
Fiji 35 - 10 USAFiji vs USA Report
Japan 16 - 13 CanadaJapan vs Canada Report
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Tuesday , June 18
Brumbies 14 - 12 British & Irish LionsBrumbies vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
International Match
Sunday , June 16
Canada 14 - 40 IrelandCanada vs Ireland Report
Saturday , June 15
Japan 23 - 8 WalesJapan vs Wales Report
Samoa 39 - 10 ItalySamoa vs Italy Report
New Zealand 30 - 0 FranceNew Zealand vs France Report
Argentina 26 - 51 EnglandArgentina vs England Report
South Africa 30 - 17 ScotlandSouth Africa vs Scotland Report
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Waratahs 17 - 47 British & Irish LionsWaratahs vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
International Match
Friday , June 14
USA 9 - 18 TongaUSA vs Tonga Report
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Tuesday , June 11
NSW-Queensland Country 0 - 64 British & Irish LionsNSW-Queensland Country vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
International Match
Sunday , June 9
USA 12 - 15 IrelandUSA vs Ireland Report
More International Match results
Super Rugby
Western Force 13 - 28 WaratahsWestern Force vs Waratahs Report
More Super Rugby results
International Match
Saturday , June 8
USA 12 - 15 Ireland
Japan 18 - 22 WalesJapan vs Wales Report
New Zealand 23 - 13 FranceNew Zealand vs France Report
Samoa 27 - 17 Scotland
Canada 36 - 27 Tonga
Argentina 3 - 32 EnglandArgentina vs England Report
South Africa 44 - 10 ItalySouth Africa vs Italy Report
Scotland 17 - 27 SamoaScotland vs Samoa Report
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Reds 12 - 22 British & Irish LionsReds vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
Super Rugby
Friday , June 7
Brumbies 39 - 17 Melbourne RebelsBrumbies vs Melbourne Rebels Report
More Super Rugby results
International Match
Wednesday, June 5
Fiji 18 - 20 Canada
More International Match results