Planet Rugby

Sorry, this story is unavailable

Comments

homergriffin says...

BozOnline - I'm an Irishman and I agree with you on most (if not all of the points). Most interestingly, your point about the lack of variation and changing of the game plan is exactly what the Irish pundits mentioned. I think De Villiers is a very good coach but he needs to focus more on options and not just kicking the ball. We have Rob Kearney (the best at fielding kicks in the world) and yet Steyn and Pienaar kept giving us our best attacking platform.

Having said that, the SA will bounce back.

Posted 13:36 29th November 2009

BozOnline says...

Yes, the Boks were poor yesterday, and the Irish were better. There's no doubt about that. But instead of dwelling on recriminations, let's look for lessons learned from the November tests:

1 - You cannot carry a player who is not up to it. This goes for Smit at prop as much as it goes for Jacobs at centre, or Kankowski at 8. I say this even though the Sharks are my team. If you don't pick THE best players in EVERY position, you WILL lose test matches, and you will do so consistently. Yes, you need to test combinations and blood new players, but that's what the mid-week matches are for. Smit is NOT a prop, and if this test series didn't show that, nothing will. He's a hooker or he's gone. Don't move him to prop just so that Chiliboy can hobble onto the bench.

2 - We don't have much depth across the park. There were a couple of finds this season, including De Jongh, Brussouw, Potgieter and Deysel, but at scrumhalf, fullback, wing, front row, and second row, we need to look more carefully. This means keeping players we already have, or find a way of selecting players who don't stay in SA (F Steyn, De Villiers, BJ Botha, James, etc).

3 - Pieter de Villiers is a good coach, but he needs to take the next step. Thinking that he could use the same game plan through a whole season is just stupid. Once the plan is known, it would take a knowledgeable ten-year old to figure out how to combat it. A comfort zone is as bad for a coach as for a player, and never has there been a coach further back in his comfort zone than De Villiers.

4 - We need on-field leaders. Smit is a great leader, but when the game plan fails, it's up to him to change things on the fly, and he doesn't seem able to do that. Maybe that's because he's tied up in the front row; picking a backline leader could help.

These are not difficult things to fix. We have the talent; we just need to use it.

Posted 10:29 29th November 2009

Andhesaid says...

Smit - The Boks performance was shocking to say the least. Dont talk about fatigue being factor Nz and Aus played more or less the same amount of games yet look how well they finished the year.We played the same old style that we played all year, kick and chase and then try smash and run over everyone. Why can't our team see that kicking is not working and change tactics - why??...Guess what!! Ireland and France have watched and studied the videos of our game plan weeks ago and were ready for us.The Irish are good high ball catchers as they play Gaelic football from a young age, so are not afraid of the high balls. The Irish No15+14 even showed us a bit in the Lions tour that they were solid under the high ball...That kick and chase tactic is over used now, it worked for us during the tri nations but its effectiveness as our main attacking point is over. We need our backs to be more creative and run the ball more. You know it makes me think that if Carter was in the NZ team this year would we have beaten them? The Boks need to start using their brains as strength alone is not the answer. We have the players to do the job they just need to be shown how to do it.

Posted 02:49 29th November 2009

Page 1 of 1

Character Count : 0/1900

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
RBS Six Nations
Saturday , February 11
Italy vs England16:00
France vs Ireland20:00
Sunday , February 12
Wales vs Scotland15:00
More RBS Six Nations fixtures
Aviva Premiership
Friday , February 10
Sale vs Worcester20:00
Saturday , February 11
Harlequins vs London Irish14:00
Gloucester vs Northampton14:15
Bath vs Newcastle14:15
Exeter vs Leicester18:00
Sunday , February 12
Wasps vs Saracens13:15
More Aviva Premiership fixtures
RaboDirect PRO12
Thursday , February 9
Leinster vs Benetton Treviso19:05
Glasgow vs Scarlets19:05
Friday , February 10
Ulster vs Newport-Gwent D'gons19:05
Cardiff Blues vs Connacht19:30
Edinburgh vs Ospreys19:35
Saturday , February 11
Edinburgh vs OspreysTBC
Cardiff Blues vs ConnachtTBC
Ulster vs Newport-Gwent D'gonsTBC
Aironi Rugby vs MunsterTBC
Glasgow vs ScarletsTBC
Leinster vs Benetton TrevisoTBC
Sunday , February 12
Aironi Rugby vs Munster14:00
More RaboDirect PRO12 fixtures
Top 14
Friday , February 10
Bayonne vs Stade Francais15:00
Toulon vs Bordeaux-Begles15:00
Clermont Auvergne vs Racing Metro Paris15:00
Lyon vs Brive15:00
More Top 14 fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
RBS Six Nations
Sunday , February 5
Ireland 21 - 23 WalesIreland vs Wales Report
More RBS Six Nations results
LV= Cup
Cardiff Blues 45 - 40 HarlequinsCardiff Blues vs Harlequins Report
Exeter 3 - 31 Bath
More LV= Cup results
RBS Six Nations
Saturday , February 4
France 30 - 12 ItalyFrance vs Italy Report
Scotland 6 - 13 EnglandScotland vs England Report
More RBS Six Nations results
LV= Cup
Northampton 57 - 10 WaspsNorthampton vs Wasps Report
London Irish 23 - 15 Gloucester
Sale 19 - 14 Scarlets
Worcester 24 - 14 Ospreys
Leicester 24 - 13 Newcastle
More LV= Cup results
Top 14
Friday , February 3
Bordeaux-Begles 31 - 10 Lyon
More Top 14 results
LV= Cup
Sunday , January 29
Saracens 41 - 14 WorcesterSaracens vs Worcester Report
Newcastle 37 - 7 Sale
Saturday , January 28
Bath 46 - 14 NorthamptonBath vs Northampton Report
Harlequins 9 - 19 Leicester
Scarlets 27 - 19 London Irish
Wasps 16 - 30 Exeter
Gloucester 40 - 3 Cardiff Blues
More LV= Cup results
Top 14
Castres 29 - 23 Biarritz
Racing Metro Paris 13 - 19 Toulouse
Bordeaux-Begles 10 - 17 Clermont Auvergne
Toulon 50 - 10 BayonneToulon vs Bayonne Report
Lyon 19 - 11 Agen
Brive 17 - 9 Perpignan
More Top 14 results
LV= Cup
Friday , January 27
Ospreys 26 - 21 Newport-Gwent D'gonsOspreys vs Newport-Gwent D
More LV= Cup results
RBS Six Nations Table
PosTeamPPts
1France12
2England12
3Wales12
4Ireland10
5Scotland10
6Italy10