Planet Rugby

Sorry, this story is unavailable

Comments

DrDeath says...

@makemehappy

missed my point AGAIN!

Simple example so you can keep up:

Mike Phillips scores try vs Ireland after illegally taken quick throw (different ball used).

Jonathan Kaplan awards try incorrectly.

Was Mr Kaplan:

1. Biased?

2.In error?

Please answer as this simple exercise will confirm that you have finally understood the nature of my complaint then we can move on!

Posted 10:55 30th January 2013

makemehappy says...

@DrDeath - come on - be fair - you made a mistake!

Re-read the first sentence of your initial post and then simply acknowledge I've refuted it.

The rest of your comments are now supprting a claim of bias. Sadly you have no foundation. I have asked you to analyse the game and you haven't so you have no argument.

I do think he was biased with the yellow card decisions and to an extent that he behaved in an idiotic manner.

I have already stated that I don't think it impacted on the result so time for you to move on.

Posted 17:16 29th January 2013

DrDeath says...

@makemehappy

missed/ignored it again!

My point is not about the referee at all (although you still think it is obviously).

My point is you cannot constantly go round saying people have sanity issues and are DELIBERATELY favouring another team over the Welsh heroes!

Clearly cuts to the reputation, integrity and private life of the individual in question! Your comments are not about rugby!

I really can't explain it to you any clearer than that!

Posted 15:21 29th January 2013

makemehappy says...

@DrDeath - I didn't miss your point, you simply just didn't state it well. Look at the yellow cards issued and compare with those that should have been issued to Sale. You'll have little doubt then.

As for libellous - I don't think so on any grounds.

Posted 12:53 29th January 2013

DrDeath says...

@makemehappy

as usual you missed my point!

saying the that the referee was inconsistent and to the detriment of the Scarlets is a perfectly reasonable statement.

To call him a "biased lunatic" smacks of slightly crazed conspiracy theories and is frankly possibly libellous!

Referees may be inconsistent, you may disagree with their decisions but to keep playing this "bias" card is a bit pathetic!-mate

Posted 08:37 29th January 2013

makemehappy says...

@DrDeath - yes of course they have. Bit of a daft comment by you really to think that anyone would state otherwise. I'm sure if you saw the game you would acknowledge that the refereeing was far from consistent and to the detriment of the Scarlets. I still think they would have lost however. Think you need to look for a new record to try and break - hey mate!

Posted 18:12 28th January 2013

DrDeath says...

@makemehappy

Has a welsh team EVER lost a game where the referee was not criminally culpable?

It's becoming a bit of a broken record mate!

Posted 14:53 28th January 2013

APV1 says...

@ ArmchairGeneral - if he continues as he is and Claassens does move on, we might be able to keep him. he's only in as injusy cover at the moment, but neither Cook nor McMillan are really that good yet.

Posted 10:13 28th January 2013

makemehappy says...

Nice to see the ref in the Sale v Scarlets game being a completely biased lunatic in favour of the home team. Absolutely disgraceful refereeing! Hope we never see him again.

Posted 21:11 27th January 2013

ArmchairGeneral says...

How long will Stringer play for?... How longs a piece of string... er?

Posted 19:12 27th January 2013

PatrickH says...

Well done Strings! Prob the best passer in the game, fierce easy to take the ball off him though.

Posted 00:07 27th January 2013

ArmchairGeneral says...

Quinns! What depth. Noon of the top players in there even on bench, and still a good win. Saints! Should have rested Pisi and perhaps some others in there too. Same old Mallinder. Not surprised re Exeter vs Bath as their game previously vs Leinster was huge and they really must have exhausted themselves with that.

Posted 23:22 26th January 2013

MunsterRedArmy says...

Strings the man! If only Penney would use him instead of Duncan Williams...

Posted 19:54 26th January 2013

Qkram79 says...

Get in Strings

Posted 17:30 26th January 2013

paddy91317 says...

delighted for him... great player on his day

Posted 16:47 26th January 2013

Page 1 of 1

Character Count : 0/1900

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
International Match
Wednesday, June 19
Fiji vs USA17:10
Japan vs Canada19:10
Saturday , June 22
New Zealand vs France08:35
Scotland vs Italy14:15
South Africa vs Samoa17:15
Sunday , June 23
Fiji vs Tonga12:10
Japan vs USA14:10
More International Match fixtures
British & Irish Lions
Saturday , June 22
Australia vs British & Irish Lions11:05
More British & Irish Lions fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
British & Irish Lions
Tuesday , June 18
Brumbies 14 - 12 British & Irish LionsBrumbies vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
International Match
Sunday , June 16
Canada 14 - 40 IrelandCanada vs Ireland Report
Saturday , June 15
Japan 23 - 8 WalesJapan vs Wales Report
Samoa 39 - 10 ItalySamoa vs Italy Report
New Zealand 30 - 0 FranceNew Zealand vs France Report
Argentina 26 - 51 EnglandArgentina vs England Report
South Africa 30 - 17 ScotlandSouth Africa vs Scotland Report
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Waratahs 17 - 47 British & Irish LionsWaratahs vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
International Match
Friday , June 14
USA 9 - 18 TongaUSA vs Tonga Report
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Tuesday , June 11
NSW-Queensland Country 0 - 64 British & Irish LionsNSW-Queensland Country vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
International Match
Sunday , June 9
USA 12 - 15 IrelandUSA vs Ireland Report
More International Match results
Super Rugby
Western Force 13 - 28 WaratahsWestern Force vs Waratahs Report
More Super Rugby results
International Match
Saturday , June 8
USA 12 - 15 Ireland
Japan 18 - 22 WalesJapan vs Wales Report
New Zealand 23 - 13 FranceNew Zealand vs France Report
Samoa 27 - 17 Scotland
Canada 36 - 27 Tonga
Argentina 3 - 32 EnglandArgentina vs England Report
South Africa 44 - 10 ItalySouth Africa vs Italy Report
Scotland 17 - 27 SamoaScotland vs Samoa Report
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Reds 12 - 22 British & Irish LionsReds vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
Super Rugby
Friday , June 7
Brumbies 39 - 17 Melbourne RebelsBrumbies vs Melbourne Rebels Report
More Super Rugby results
International Match
Wednesday, June 5
Fiji 18 - 20 Canada
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Western Force 17 - 69 British & Irish LionsWestern Force vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
International Match
Saturday , June 1
Fiji 22 - 8 Japan
More International Match results