Planet Rugby

Letter of the Week

10th April 2014 10:56

Share:

Planet Rugby mail

Got an opinion? Mail us!

Planet Rugby readers are never short of an opinion and our mailbox is seldom empty. This week a reader suggests that red cards are overused. What do you think?

Got an opinion? We'd like to hear it, so why not send us an email HERE.

Is it time to give the red card a red card?
By Andrew Bladon

In the past few weeks we have seen red cards brandished in some crucial games. Particularly Hogg in Cardiff and Payne in Belfast.

In almost every instant a red card has been used, the non-infringing side goes on to win, effectively handing victory to the opponent.

This ruins the game for the defending team, the people who offered good money to watch the match live and the thousands paying an interest at home.

I was in Cardiff when tens of thousands of Scots descended on the city to watch their team's last game of the Six Nations, which realistically ended after just 22 minutes.

Before the halftime whistle was blown most Scots were in the bars and the stadium was half empty. That struck me as waste of an £80+ ticket, and whatever costs associated with the humiliating journey to Wales.

This year's Heineken Cup is over for Ulster fans, as was the 2011 World Cup for the Welsh, all due to the brandishing of a red card.

In the majority of cases (with the exception of gouging, or deliberately targeting an individual player) a red card is given out for a moment of sheer stupidity, rather than a calculated or malicious attack.

In these cases would it not make more sense to punish the player after the match, rather than spoiling the game for everyone involved based on one players foolishness.

For example, penalise the player with a 10 minute sin bin (a good side should capitalise by ten points here alone) and then throw the book at them after the match.

With citing commissioners, ever-improving video angles and super slow motion cameras it is a much easier task to punish a player after a match than it was ten years ago.

By doing so we can keep crucial games competitive for 80 minutes, as well as forcing teams to show strength in depth in major tournaments by bringing out reserve players to cover the inevitable bans.

A hefty fine and increased suspension, potentially losing your place in the team, could arguably have a more punishing effect for modern professional players than sitting on the sidelines for 60 minutes.

Of course, this argument is redundant in amateur rugby where post match bans and fines are more difficult to administer, but certainly for the benefit of a great spectator sport red cards should only be handed out in the most extreme circumstances.

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Super Rugby
Saturday , July 26
Waratahs vs Brumbies19:40
Crusaders vs Sharks19:35
More Super Rugby fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Super Rugby
Saturday , July 19
Brumbies 32 - 30 ChiefsBrumbies vs Chiefs Report
Sharks 31 - 27 HighlandersSharks vs Highlanders Report
Saturday , July 12
Crusaders 34 - 8 HighlandersCrusaders vs Highlanders Report
Reds 3 - 34 WaratahsReds vs Waratahs Report
Lions 60 - 25 CheetahsLions vs Cheetahs Report
Stormers 10 - 34 SharksStormers vs Sharks Report
Friday , July 11
Blues 8 - 11 ChiefsBlues vs Chiefs Report
Brumbies 47 - 25 Western ForceBrumbies vs Western Force Report
Bulls 40 - 7 Melbourne RebelsBulls vs Melbourne Rebels Report
Sunday , July 6
Waratahs 44 - 16 HighlandersWaratahs vs Highlanders Report
Saturday , July 5
Crusaders 21 - 13 BluesCrusaders vs Blues Report
Western Force 30 - 20 RedsWestern Force vs Reds Report
Stormers 16 - 0 BullsStormers vs Bulls Report
Cheetahs 27 - 20 SharksCheetahs vs Sharks Report
Friday , July 4
Chiefs 24 - 16 HurricanesChiefs vs Hurricanes Report
Lions 34 - 17 Melbourne RebelsLions vs Melbourne Rebels Report
More Super Rugby results
International Match
Saturday , June 28
South Africa 55 - 6 ScotlandSouth Africa vs Scotland Report
More International Match results
Super Rugby
Hurricanes 16 - 9 CrusadersHurricanes vs Crusaders Report
Waratahs 39 - 8 BrumbiesWaratahs vs Brumbies Report
Western Force 14 - 40 BluesWestern Force vs Blues Report
Friday , June 27
Highlanders 29 - 25 ChiefsHighlanders vs Chiefs Report
Melbourne Rebels 20 - 36 RedsMelbourne Rebels vs Reds Report
More Super Rugby results
International Match
Saturday , June 21
Australia 39 - 13 FranceAustralia vs France Report
South Africa 31 - 30 WalesSouth Africa vs Wales Report
New Zealand 36 - 13 EnglandNew Zealand vs England Report
More International Match results
Aviva Premiership Table
PosTeamPPts
1Bath00
2Exeter00
3Gloucester00
4Harlequins00
5Leicester Tigers00