Planet Rugby

Letter of the week

31st January 2013 11:35

Share:

Planet Rugby mail

Got an opinion? Mail us!

Planet Rugby readers are never short of an opinion and our mail box is seldom empty. This week, one of our readers questions the wisdom of Declan Kidney's selection policy.

Got an opinion? We'd like to hear it, so why not send us an email HERE.

Win or bust for Kidney?
By Rory McGimpsey

Ireland coach Declan Kidney has at last revealed his hand for Saturday's Six Nations curtain raiser at the Millennium Stadium.

Bearing in mind Ireland's fairly mediocre record in recent championships, this season's campaign is of cataclysmic significance for Kidney's tenure as coach. Put in stark terms: failure during this season's Six Nations would surely signal the end of Kidney's five-year reign as national supremo. And for those of us who follow Ireland's progress with expectation, the early signs are ominous.

In recent seasons, Kidney has developed a reputation as a conservative and pragmatic coach. The overriding feeling within Irish rugby is that in terms of both team selection and performance, the Cork man has tended to err on the side of caution.

While this ethos was initially successful; delivering two Heineken Cups for Munster and Ireland's first Grand Slam in 60 years, it is equally apparent that Kidney's conservative philosophy is now an intrinsic part of the current malaise.

What makes this state of affairs all the more frustrating is that for the first time in a decade, Ireland have unearthed some genuine young superstars who have the potential to enrich European rugby for years to come. In Luke Marshall, Simon Zebo, Cian Healy, and Craig Gilroy, we can witness an emerging generation who possess not only supreme talent, but also a big-game mentality that epitomises the fearlessness of youth.

In this transition season for Irish rugby, which could herald the international retirement of Brian O'Driscoll, the time was surely right for Kidney to roll the dice and give youth its chance. What did we get instead? More of the same: conservatism galore.

Let's start with the backline. While it is fantastic to see the return of Rob Kearney to international rugby, and the merited selection of young tyros Gilroy and Zebo, it is monumentally depressing to see Gordon D'Arcy togging out again at inside-centre. D'Arcy was arguably never a natural in the role in any case, but given his lacklustre performances in recent years, it is utterly depressing to see him occupy the position.

The injured Luke Marshall represents what a dynamic, modern number 12 should typify, but even the experienced Paddy Wallace would have been a better option for this opening encounter. The predicament is even more galling in the replacements, where Ronan O'Gara again provides fly-half cover. ROG has been a magnificent servant to Irish rugby for many years, but how can young starlets such as Ian Madigan and Paddy Jackson gain the requisite experience when the ancient O'Gara clings onto his place in the squad?

There are some equally bemusing selections in the forwards. How Peter O'Mahony can keep Chris Henry out of the back row is a source of complete bewilderment. O'Mahony is a promising prospect, but Henry has been an open-side sensation in Europe this season.

Against a poacher as accomplished as Sam Warburton, the expedient route would have been to select Henry alongside Sean O'Brien. Although it is heartening to see Declan FitzPatrick occupy the reserve tighthead spot, I fail to see how Dave Kilcoyne can be chosen ahead of Tom Court.

Court has been one of the most destructive loose-heads in Europe this season, annihilating virtually every prop he has some into contact with. His regal form should, at the very least, have been rewarded with a place on the bench. I would also love to have seen young Iain Henderson or Devin Toner preferred to veteran second-row, Donnacha O'Callaghan among the reserves.

Balancing the twin objectives of Six Nations' competitiveness and building for the World Cup is never an easy task, but it is hard to resist the conclusion that Kidney has got the chemistry wrong.

With his position openly being called into question, the moment was rife for Kidney to experiment. Give youth a chance; is all we are saying. Regain the equilibrium, and Ireland could be embarking on a new era driven by its talented youngsters. Get it wrong, however, and it will definitely be adios for Mr Kidney.

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Heineken Cup
Saturday , April 26
Saracens vs Clermont Auvergne15:40
Sunday , April 27
Toulon vs Munster15:30
More Heineken Cup fixtures
RaboDirect PRO12
Saturday , April 26
Glasgow vs EdinburghGlasgow vs Edinburgh Preview
More RaboDirect PRO12 fixtures
Amlin Challenge Cup
Friday , April 25
Northampton vs HarlequinsNorthampton vs Harlequins Preview
Sunday , April 27
Wasps vs Bath13:00
More Amlin Challenge Cup fixtures
Super Rugby
Friday , April 25
Blues vs WaratahsBlues vs Waratahs Preview
Brumbies vs ChiefsBrumbies vs Chiefs Preview
Sharks vs HighlandersSharks vs Highlanders Preview
Saturday , April 26
Hurricanes vs Reds19:35
Western Force vs Bulls17:40
Cheetahs vs Stormers17:05
More Super Rugby fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Aviva Premiership
Sunday , April 20
Northampton 36 - 21 London IrishNorthampton vs London Irish Report
Newcastle 18 - 23 SaracensNewcastle vs Saracens Report
More Aviva Premiership results
RaboDirect PRO12
Cardiff Blues 17 - 13 ScarletsCardiff Blues vs Scarlets Report
Newport Gwent D'gons 10 - 20 Ospreys
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
Aviva Premiership
Saturday , April 19
Bath 32 - 20 WorcesterBath vs Worcester Report
Exeter 12 - 55 SaleExeter vs Sale Report
Wasps 38 - 30 GloucesterWasps vs Gloucester Report
More Aviva Premiership results
RaboDirect PRO12
Zebre 26 - 13 EdinburghZebre vs Edinburgh Report
Connacht 23 - 32 MunsterConnacht vs Munster Report
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
Top 14
Oyonnax 19 - 19 ToulouseOyonnax vs Toulouse Report
Biarritz 19 - 13 Brive
Perpignan 31 - 46 ToulonPerpignan vs Toulon Report
Racing Metro Paris 22 - 6 Clermont AuvergneRacing Metro Paris vs Clermont Auvergne Report
Stade Francais 37 - 23 Bordeaux-Begles
Grenoble 21 - 21 Bayonne
More Top 14 results
Super Rugby
Chiefs 17 - 18 CrusadersChiefs vs Crusaders Report
Sharks 19 - 8 CheetahsSharks vs Cheetahs Report
Waratahs 19 - 12 BullsWaratahs vs Bulls Report
Stormers 18 - 3 LionsStormers vs Lions Report
More Super Rugby results
Aviva Premiership
Friday , April 18
Harlequins 24 - 20 LeicesterHarlequins vs Leicester Report
More Aviva Premiership results
RaboDirect PRO12
Leinster 62 - 7 Benetton TrevisoLeinster vs Benetton Treviso Report
Glasgow 27 - 9 UlsterGlasgow vs Ulster Report
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
Top 14
Castres 22 - 15 MontpellierCastres vs Montpellier Report
More Top 14 results
Super Rugby
Hurricanes 39 - 20 BluesHurricanes vs Blues Report
Melbourne Rebels 22 - 16 Western Force
More Super Rugby results
Aviva Premiership Table
PosTeamPPts
1Saracens2080
2Northampton2071
3Bath2064
4Leicester Tigers2064
5Harlequins2058