Planet Rugby

Letter of the week

24th January 2013 15:36

Share:

Planet Rugby mail

Got an opinion? Mail us!

Planet Rugby readers are never short of an opinion and our mail box is seldom empty. This week, one of our readers questions why so many captains are loose forwards.

Got an opinion? Are you the type who puts it out there or or look to bet on sports online. We'd like to hear it, so why not send us an email HERE.

Loose forward leaders
By Richard Clifton

Is it just me who's noticed that the captain for each of the Six Nations teams is a forward this year? Not only that, but five of the six are back-row forwards. And I'm sure if push came to shove, Pascal Papé would be happy to slide back from second row (which lock wouldn't? - I'm sure all second rows have aspirations of being-back row heroes).

I'm beginning to wonder if this is a trend now in our modern, professional era. Can it be because the loose forward is most likely to be closest to the action and right in the thick of it? I suspect as much. In days gone by, it was usually the fly-half who was the general, directing play from the safety of his position behind the firing line and politely discussing decisions that the referee had made. All jolly nice. Nowadays though, coaches seem to prefer a more pragmatic leader, a grunt, fighting in the trenches. We've even had a few front-row forwards as captain, Phil Kearns & Sean Fitzpatrick to name just two. However, I can't seem to recall any props. Sorry props, please correct me if you can. I suspect the coal-face isn't the place to call the shots from.

It seems obvious to me that the players who are most likely to give penalties away are the forwards. They're in the thick of it and involved in all the set pieces and nearly all of the rucks and mauls. Now, to me, it appears that these places are where most of the penalties are given away. Anyone disagree? If you make a forward your captain, will this influence the decision of the referee and have a bearing on the penalty count?

It's not only the Six Nations sides either who employ a piano-shifter as a captain. Who can ignore New Zealand - captained by the magnificent Richie McCaw! Until his recent sabbatical, the All Blacks have had a breakaway as skipper for ages. But who steps up to the plate to fill his dynamic boots while McCaw takes a timely rest? None other than, fellow loosey and Number 8, Kieren Reed. I don't think anyone can doubt Reed's ability, but is he the natural replacement as captain of the best side in the world? I suspect as much. What better place to see what's going on than from the base of the scrum, head popping up over the trench line, having a peek a what's happening on the battle field.

Jamie Heaslip and Sergio Parisse both command from the 8-slot at the back of the scrum and I seem to recall that Warburton, Robshaw and Brown have all packed down at 8 for club, if not country. So is Number 8 the ideal position to captain a side from? I think it might well be.

Let's look at some more back-row forwards. If Pascal Pape was not skippering Les Blues, then it would be Thierry Dusautoir... hmmm... another flanker. And not to be forgotten, are Ryan Jones and Michael Owen, both versatile, past Welsh captains. I'm sure in Sam Warburton's absence, the skipper's armband would return to Ryan Jones. Anyone else? Lewis Moody - if ever there was a man likely to be the subject of the referee's wrath, it was old Mad Dog himself. But make him your captain and watch the rub of the green change. Dallaglio. He played across all three back-row positions for country and skippered on numerous occasions. But, we have to come back to the great Richie McCaw. Was there ever a man who lived at the firing line, causing referees to pause or re-think their decisions? The man was so on the edge that the offside line seemed to move in his favour most of the time. How many times have referees decided to caution rather than penalise the softly-spoken man? What a man, though! Best of luck with the rehab, mate.

However, we mustn't forget the odd one out. Poor old Pascal Papé. The only second row of our Six Nations mix, stuck in the boiler room. But he shouldn't worry, because there once was another second row forward who captained his country. Who remembers when Martin Johnson was made captain of England? Genius! Pick the biggest, ugliest bloke to tower over the ref saying, "me, Sir?" That's exactly what the Lions management decided back in '97 when Johnson was chosen to skipper the famous touring side, even before being picked to captain his own country. Only then, it was the opposition skipper he was required to tower over (and thus intimidate) at the coin toss before coming out onto the field, not the ref this time (although I'm sure that point was not lost either).

But, enough of those second-row titans, I digress. Picking an open-side wing forward as the team representative is like choosing the naughty boy in the class to talk to teacher. But everyone seems to be at it. Is it because the ref is less likely to penalise the captain? Again, I think it is, and I'm going to stick my neck out again by saying it's the open-side flanker who's most likely to get pinged during a game (I know I usually did). So by choosing a forward to captain your side, is it a positional move, or an attempt to influence the penalty count? And if all sides have a forward as skipper, will that affect the game? I wonder what our better halves have to say.

Come on backs, get involved - your country needs you!

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Super Rugby
Saturday , July 26
Waratahs vs Brumbies19:40
Crusaders vs Sharks19:35
More Super Rugby fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Super Rugby
Saturday , July 19
Brumbies 32 - 30 ChiefsBrumbies vs Chiefs Report
Sharks 31 - 27 HighlandersSharks vs Highlanders Report
Saturday , July 12
Crusaders 34 - 8 HighlandersCrusaders vs Highlanders Report
Reds 3 - 34 WaratahsReds vs Waratahs Report
Lions 60 - 25 CheetahsLions vs Cheetahs Report
Stormers 10 - 34 SharksStormers vs Sharks Report
Friday , July 11
Blues 8 - 11 ChiefsBlues vs Chiefs Report
Brumbies 47 - 25 Western ForceBrumbies vs Western Force Report
Bulls 40 - 7 Melbourne RebelsBulls vs Melbourne Rebels Report
Sunday , July 6
Waratahs 44 - 16 HighlandersWaratahs vs Highlanders Report
Saturday , July 5
Crusaders 21 - 13 BluesCrusaders vs Blues Report
Western Force 30 - 20 RedsWestern Force vs Reds Report
Stormers 16 - 0 BullsStormers vs Bulls Report
Cheetahs 27 - 20 SharksCheetahs vs Sharks Report
Friday , July 4
Chiefs 24 - 16 HurricanesChiefs vs Hurricanes Report
Lions 34 - 17 Melbourne RebelsLions vs Melbourne Rebels Report
More Super Rugby results
International Match
Saturday , June 28
South Africa 55 - 6 ScotlandSouth Africa vs Scotland Report
More International Match results
Super Rugby
Hurricanes 16 - 9 CrusadersHurricanes vs Crusaders Report
Waratahs 39 - 8 BrumbiesWaratahs vs Brumbies Report
Western Force 14 - 40 BluesWestern Force vs Blues Report
Friday , June 27
Highlanders 29 - 25 ChiefsHighlanders vs Chiefs Report
Melbourne Rebels 20 - 36 RedsMelbourne Rebels vs Reds Report
More Super Rugby results
International Match
Saturday , June 21
Australia 39 - 13 FranceAustralia vs France Report
South Africa 31 - 30 WalesSouth Africa vs Wales Report
New Zealand 36 - 13 EnglandNew Zealand vs England Report
More International Match results
Aviva Premiership Table
PosTeamPPts
1Bath00
2Exeter00
3Gloucester00
4Harlequins00
5Leicester Tigers00