Planet Rugby

Loose Pass

06th August 2012 11:29

liam messam chiefs

Stellar season: Liam Messam

This week we will mostly be concerning ourselves with Super things, the changing of a guard and a half-time analysis...

All hail the Chiefs! One of the most one-sided Super Rugby finals of all time was capped off by yet another simple and brilliant try from Sonny Bill Williams.

The winners dominated from start to finish, ending up deserved winners. Given that this was the first season many of the franchise - including the coaches - had worked together on a Super Rugby project, it's a terrific achievement. If second-seasonitis can be avoided, it's a franchise with the hallmarks of a major future.

There've been grumblings about the scheduling the Sharks had to endure to get to the final and the travel, but we're not buying it. The Crusaders proved better than anyone last year that mastering the time zones can be done. Nor are we buying the moans about 'off-the-ball' stuff and infringements at line-outs by the Chiefs. 4-0 in tries and 37-6 in points is a pretty convincing stat...

However, legitimate questions about the conference system remain. The Chiefs are all the more worthy winners because of the sheer strength of the New Zealand conference. The Australian conference only managed to produce a play-off qualifier on account of the automatic qualification of a pool winner, while the disparity in internal strengths in South Africa gave the Stormers and Bulls especially a little leg-up the table.

The format works well in many ways, but while you are judging results on an overall table you still have flawed competition integrity if some teams have stronger fixture lists than others.


There wasn't much to see of him in the final, but when our poll went up on Super Rugby player of the tournament last week we'll freely admit in the aftermath our vote was going to JP Pietersen.

Aaron Cruden has been superb, but on the back of a superb team performance. Pietersen has stood out like a beacon for the Sharks, even through their indifferent form early on in the year. Since the Sharks' resurgence, Pietersen has been mesmerising at times. There was a half-step and acceleration in the win over the Reds, followed by a defence-splitting offload, that only a player right at the top of his game can make.

The move to centre in the semi-final and final probably stifled him a little bit - try against the Stormers notwithstanding - but there's little doubt that while Cruden's been a standout player in a standout team, Pietersen's been outstanding in a team which didn't always give him the best platform to shine on, which is why he gets our vote.


Another player who was on our shortlist may not have won our accolade, but he was a close second and is now the deserved winner of an accolade he probably wanted a whole lot more.

Liam Messam has worked tirelessly for this All Black call-up, and now gets it after a stellar season in which he has thrived upon the Chiefs' style and shown his depth of quality in terms of not only work-rate, fitness and skill but also leadership.

Man of the match in the Super Rugby final, among the top try-scorers, co-captain of the Super Rugby-winning side. Messam has done it all this year in his finest season to date. Can he finally cut the All Blacks as well? It would be a deserved reward for what has clearly been a year of immense work.


Meanwhile, back in South Africa.... the meeting is scheduled for August 16, but is there anyone who does not now foresee the Lions disappearing from the Super Rugby landscape and being replaced by the Southern Kings?

All the coaches are gone. John Mitchell may have left under a cloud, but there's little evidence that Carlos Spencer or Wayne Taylor have done much wrong.

This means that the 2011 Currie Cup champions are currently without a coach, assistant coach, conditioning coach or captain - Josh Strauss has stepped down just one week before their first match of the 2012 campaign against Free State Cheetahs in Johannesburg. Since Monday's announcement, there's been little mention of an eventual replacement.

Is this a franchise that looks to you as though it believes it is in the Super Rugby tournament next year? No, neither us...


Finally, with the end of Super Rugby comes the end of an era. From here on in, everything is new.

There are new laws which will change the dynamic of the game irreversibly, particularly the one about the ball being available at the back of a ruck for a max. of five seconds before a scrum-half - or someone - has to do something with it. In the Aviva Premiership, Pro12 and Top 14, that's going to be revolutionary.

The first competition to use it will be New Zealand's ITM Cup starting in two weeks, while also starting in two weeks is the last competition to be played under the old rules: the Rugby Championship.

But that too will be new. Argentina's long wait for international competition will be over when they step onto the field at Newlands on August 18, a new flavour to an old format hopefully keeping Pumas rugby at the top table for years to come.

After the dust has cleared in London, rugby will have a new competition to look forward to as well, as qualification begins for the Olympics in 2016. Sevens rugby is about to become popular like never before and there will be players now seeking achievements in both codes; who wouldn't want an Olympic gold to add to a Super Rugby or Heineken Cup title?

Lots to look forward to in rugby as we wave goodbye to an era...

Loose Pass compiled by Richard Anderson

Comments

Dingbat32 says...

SA need to manage their sides better to get a more equitable spread of talent. At the moment Cheetahs and Lions are treated as feeder clubs, and the results show the effect. Perhaps that is what SARFU are trying to achieve with the new team (leaving Lions and Cheetahs to combine).

As for 3N, this has been meaningless and boring for several years now. The winners have never won the world cup in the same year. And yes, SA chronically underperform in this tournament, with away games seeming to be particularly difficult.

Will the inclusion of Argentina make things better? Hope so, but probably not.

Posted 13:35 13th August 2012

Trinats2 says...

ruggaluva:

I agree, and same for the tri nations. Because SA are always bottom of the table. (Lions this year in S15) and springboks picking up the wooden spoon yet again.

At least you'd have a chance in the Euro cup !

Posted 15:42 12th August 2012

ruggaluva says...

This comp is starting to wear very thin for me.... i would prefer the top 3 sides from each country playing each other home and away and the winner is the one standing at the top of the log at the end of the day.

All credit to go to the Chiefs BUT there was NO WAY the Sharks had a chance after their last 5 weeks - traveling to Hamilton was pointless really.

As much as i enjoy having the Kiwi and Aussie sides to watch it doesnt make sense for SA teams to play in the Antipodes... they should play their own comp maybe with a strong pacific combo team thrown in and we should tag onto the Euro crowd.

Posted 11:20 10th August 2012

APV1 says...

@ sandal - how very dare you suggest that Bath's very own (RWC Winning) Mr S Donald wasn't NZ's first choice?! (And I still chuckle at the sight of him trying, but failing, to squeeze his paunch into that ill-fitting jersey.)

;-)

Posted 09:34 10th August 2012

tha_mai says...

And now for something completely different.

NZ province Taranaki intends to host a tournament in February 2013 - "Ring of Fire" - featuring eight Pacific Island teams including Tahiti, Guam and Hawaii, and a Pasifika Barbarians side. Guam! who knew they had a rugby team?

Posted 01:32 10th August 2012

sandal says...

@cuw3100

Hear! Hear! Yes, please let's go back to Super 12. The season is too full, and it should be Super Rugby that gives, not international rugby. As for this business with the conferences, I am more interested in seeing those mysterious foreigners from Australia and South Africa come to my ground than another NZ team that I am already familiar with. I have never lost the thrill of seeing the great players from overseas playing Super Rugby here in NZ.

@Trinats

If the Reds were so great, then losing Cooper shouldn't have been such a handicap. Hell, the All Blacks just won a world cup without Dan Carter, and with his best substitute (Evans) unavailable, his actual substitute injured, and his substitute's substitute injured. So take ruckingkiwi's advice and suck it up.

@JayStarr

I think you're splitting hairs. Last year's Crusaders have my admiration for what they did all season. This year's Sharks have it for what they did in the playoffs. Perhaps the finest hour for both teams was in Cape Town.

I think the Reds got the home quarterfinal as part of the TV deal that funds Super Rugby. Every country had to get a home match to televise. Not very sporting, I agree, but it pays the bills.

@Sharkyzulu

Respect, my friend.

@startledwombat

lol

Posted 14:41 08th August 2012

ruckingkiwi says...

Trinats, what does last year have to do with it? This is 2012.

The Reds finished 6th, got lucky with the conference set-up to get a home semi and lost. End of story.

Jaystarr, ultimately I agree, the flawed conference system robbed the Sharks of any chance but that's the way it is. Next year it'll be another team who suffers, but a very similar scenario I imagine.

Posted 12:14 08th August 2012

Jmanngod says...

@Trinuts: Reds were found out this year. Plain and simple.

Posted 20:14 07th August 2012

cuw3100 says...

@ Trinats2 : Now that you mentioned Mr. Quade Cooper, is Miss Stephanie Rice (Australian Olympic swimmer) his girl friend??

Posted 17:50 07th August 2012

JayStarr says...

@ ruckingkiwi & sandal: The Crusaders still played their home games in NZ... except for when they decided to go play at Twickenham (which the Sharks had to do too). To still finish in the final was an incredible achievement though and I'm not taking anything away from them. I'm arguing with Richard Anderson who was trying to say the Crusaders proved it could be done, so therefore the Sharks don't have any excuses... Which is nonsense, because the Sharks did exactly what the Crusaders have done - but the Crusaders haven't done what the Sharks couldn't do (which is fly over the Indian Ocean and Australia 3 times and still win). So his argument is poppycock.

As for having another week off before the final: as a Stormers fan, I'm not so sure! A break was the LAST thing they needed after the June Internationals completely robbed them of their momentum. They needed MORE rugby, not less...

Besides, the Sharks should never have had to travel to play the Reds in the first place. Why the hell did the Reds have a home game? They didn't deserve it. If not for this stupid system, the Sharks would not have had to travel so much... But more importantly, if the worst team was actually placed 6th (as they should have been), they would not have had the ability to travel over the ocean twice and beat better teams at home, so we wouldn't have seen such a situation...

If the Sharks played the Bulls at Loftus in their QF and the Crusaders the Reds in Christchurch - as it should have been - the Sharks would have then gone on to play the Stormers (much fresher) and the Crusaders the Chiefs, so the Sharks would have then only had to travel to go play the Chiefs in NZ. But no, Australia must have a play-off game and everyone else must bend over backwards to accommodate them...

Posted 17:45 07th August 2012

startledwombat says...

I have done an in-depth analysis of the S15 Final and I conclude:

- there were, regrettably, no Australian teams in it.

- the score was not a misprint.

- in terms of Who's Hot and Who's Not, Channel 9 here in Melbourne did not broadcast the semifinals nor the final, neither in full nor even as a highlights package. Apparently there is some other sporting event on. Also, in regard to the final, there were, regrettably, no Australians in it.

- current sport on Australian TV consists of swimming, adverts for large corporations, swimming, complaints about only getting silver, swimming, more complaints.

- Conference rankings for S15 in 2012: NZ gold, SA silver, Aus bronze, Channel 9 a turd.

Posted 12:20 07th August 2012

Trinats2 says...

ruckingkiwi:

Reds finished top of the log last year, backed it up by winning the finals. Stormers finished top of the log this year.

This year Reds lost their games without Cooper, won most (can't recall if he was playing when Reds trashed the Chiefs ??) when Cooper came back. he was only one of the"Missing"Wallabies for the Reds. So yes as a die hard Reds fan, IF only they had players (even from suspension) they would have been in the final !!!! IMHO !!!

Posted 12:12 07th August 2012

tha_mai says...

ruckingkiwi suggests: 'suck it up and come back stronger next time, that's what most Aussies I know would do.'

Not following the Olympics then? "Australian Hockeyroos' star player was physically ill after her team's opening 1-0 loss to New Zealand and confirmed that she and other team-mates had to seek counselling to cope with the defeat,"

This is the new, sensitive, Australia!

Posted 12:05 07th August 2012

powerplay says...

Sharkyzulu..lol@pass

Posted 10:39 07th August 2012

Sharkyzulu says...

Firstly, the Chiefs were deserving winners - as a Sharks fan, I have no issues admitting that. Lets stop with the travel/jet-lag stories already - the margin was clear and a few 50-50 calls were not the difference. I bet the Sharks players themselves have already moved on.

I don't get why Cruden couldn't be player of the S15 just because he was in the winning team? Maybe the Chiefs won because he played so well? Heavens forbid...no that couldn't possibly be it, PR? That would be too logical... But Messam is worthy of mention because he played well but somehow being in the Chiefs didn't contribute to him looking so good/playing so well?

This week's "Loose pass" would be more aptly titled "Loose thinking"...or maybe just "Pass". Lol

Posted 09:34 07th August 2012

cuw3100 says...

What is the possibility of going back to a SUPER 12?

If something's proved statistically this year, is that the 15 team conference system is too long and tedious , with no disrespect to the winners.

Too many players suffered injuries, many matches with sparse crowds, many dull matches and many complaints about travelling. Add to that the length of the tournament with International matches squeezed in between!

Many have cast doubts on suitability of at least 2 of the teams being "up there" to challenge the others. Many have stated easy matches that enabled some teams to get into final stage. Many wondered why one team gets a distinct home advcantage or travel advantage.

Posted 09:30 07th August 2012

dangerous says...

Referees are going to get pretty good at counting to 5 in rugby games. What's the average amount of rucks in 80 minutes? When do they start counting? is it when the ball is on the floor at hind most feet? "aw ref that wasn't 5 seconds"? I like what they're trying to do but... Well we will see.

Posted 09:29 07th August 2012

jonesy2 says...

pieterson player of the tournament? hahahahahaa not even in the top 10 or 20. not even the top south african

Posted 09:17 07th August 2012

ruckingkiwi says...

Trinats, we'll never know what would have happened had the Reds played a return match in Hamilton and Dunedin, there is no point speculating. The Reds had injuries as did every team, some teams handled them well (as I thought the Reds did) while others, like the Blues, fell apart. There is no point making ifs and buts as to what shoulda, coulda, woulda been, the only thing that counts is that the Chiefs won from the hardest conference in the competition, suck it up and come back stronger next time, that's what most Aussies I know would do.

Posted 09:15 07th August 2012

Trinats2 says...

hybrid187:

Reds beat the Chiefs and Highlanders (without half their team). Also beat the Crusaders but Bryce Lawtohimself had other plans !!!

Posted 05:14 07th August 2012

Page 1 of 2

Character Count : 0/1900

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
International Match
Sunday , May 26
England vs BarbariansEngland vs Barbarians Preview
More International Match fixtures
Aviva Premiership
Saturday , May 25
Leicester vs NorthamptonLeicester vs Northampton Preview
More Aviva Premiership fixtures
RaboDirect PRO12
Saturday , May 25
Ulster vs LeinsterUlster vs Leinster Preview
More RaboDirect PRO12 fixtures
Top 14
Friday , May 24
Toulon vs ToulouseToulon vs Toulouse Preview
Saturday , May 25
Clermont Auvergne vs CastresClermont Auvergne vs Castres Preview
More Top 14 fixtures
Super Rugby
Saturday , May 25
Blues vs BrumbiesBlues vs Brumbies Preview
Western Force vs HighlandersWestern Force vs Highlanders Preview
Southern Kings vs CheetahsSouthern Kings vs Cheetahs Preview
Stormers vs RedsStormers vs Reds Preview
Sharks vs BullsSharks vs Bulls Preview
Friday , May 31
Crusaders vs Waratahs08:35
Brumbies vs Hurricanes10:40
More Super Rugby fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Super Rugby
Friday , May 24
Chiefs 28 - 19 CrusadersChiefs vs Crusaders Report
Melbourne Rebels 24 - 22 WaratahsMelbourne Rebels vs Waratahs Report
More Super Rugby results
Heineken Cup
Saturday , May 18
Clermont Auvergne 15 - 16 ToulonClermont Auvergne vs Toulon Report
More Heineken Cup results
Super Rugby
Crusaders 23 - 3 BluesCrusaders vs Blues Report
Bulls 35 - 18 HighlandersBulls vs Highlanders Report
Waratahs 28 - 22 BrumbiesWaratahs vs Brumbies Report
Cheetahs 27 - 13 RedsCheetahs vs Reds Report
More Super Rugby results
Amlin Challenge Cup
Friday , May 17
Stade Francais 13 - 34 LeinsterStade Francais vs Leinster Report
More Amlin Challenge Cup results
Super Rugby
Hurricanes 12 - 17 ChiefsHurricanes vs Chiefs Report
Melbourne Rebels 30 - 21 StormersMelbourne Rebels vs Stormers Report
Western Force 13 - 23 SharksWestern Force vs Sharks Report
More Super Rugby results
Aviva Premiership
Sunday , May 12
Saracens 13 - 27 NorthamptonSaracens vs Northampton Report
Saturday , May 11
Leicester 33 - 16 HarlequinsLeicester vs Harlequins Report
More Aviva Premiership results
RaboDirect PRO12
Leinster 17 - 15 GlasgowLeinster vs Glasgow Report
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
Top 14
Castres 25 - 12 MontpellierCastres vs Montpellier Report
More Top 14 results
Super Rugby
Blues 36 - 32 Melbourne RebelsBlues vs Melbourne Rebels Report
Southern Kings 34 - 27 HighlandersSouthern Kings vs Highlanders Report
Waratahs 21 - 15 StormersWaratahs vs Stormers Report
More Super Rugby results
RaboDirect PRO12
Friday , May 10
Ulster 28 - 17 ScarletsUlster vs Scarlets Report
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
Top 14
Stade Francais 19 - 16 Racing Metro Paris
Toulouse 33 - 19 Racing Metro ParisToulouse vs Racing Metro Paris Report
More Top 14 results
Super Rugby
Chiefs 22 - 21 Western ForceChiefs vs Western Force Report
Reds 32 - 17 SharksReds vs Sharks Report
Cheetahs 34 - 39 HurricanesCheetahs vs Hurricanes Report
Sunday , May 5
Brumbies 23 - 30 CrusadersBrumbies vs Crusaders Report
More Super Rugby results