Just two defeats: Stormers
The Stormers' season may not be too pleasing on the eye, but if it translates into a title, one shouldn't begrudge them a savouring trophy kiss.
For too long the Cape Town outfit have left their passionate supporters frustrated with a barren cabinet, either in the guise of their Super Rugby franchise or provincial side Western Province.
The legendary blue and white hooped-side broke an eleven-year trophy drought with their first-ever Vodacom Cup success two months back.
Prior to that, Province last lifted silverware in 2001 when former captain Corné Krige led his men to Currie Cup victory over the Natal Sharks.
Last season's home semi-final disappointment to the Crusaders saw the Stormers falter at the knockout stage, having gone down to bitter rivals, the Bulls, in the 2010 showpiece in Soweto.
Having also previously stumbled at the last-four round in 1999 and 2004, the Newlands team have yet to savour cup glory since the inception of the SANZAR competition in 1996.
So, as Jean de Villiers' troops head into the final round of the round-robin fixtures this coming weekend against the Melbourne Rebels just one point from finishing top of the overall table, why all the hating?
The Stormers have won 13 out of 15 games this season, but it's been their failure - or willingness some might say - to score a four-try bonus point that has many grumbling at their unattractive results.
Super Rugby has the reputation of being a free-flowing, high-tempo tournament that produces a plethora of five-pointers week in, and week out.
Unlike New Zealand's Chiefs, who top the overall standings courtesy of several bonus-point victories, however, the Stormers have adopted a defence-oriented approach over a more attacking blueprint.
The critics, as well as ardent Cape fans, argue that with the likes of Springbok finishers De Villiers, Gio Aplon and Bryan Habana at their disposal, as well as the Cape's history of running rugby, the Stormers should be crossing the whitewash with far more regularity.
These same observers highlight the crowd pleasing feats of Antipodean foes such as the 'Saders and the Reds as the benchmark for sides capable of winning matches without sacrificing anything going forward.
The Cantabrians, the most decorated team in Super Rugby history, are a side accustomed to winning and have forged their style of play over several successful seasons.
For the Queenslanders, last year's tournament triumph over the 'Saders was built largely on the mesmerising exploits of Australia stars Quade Cooper, Will Genia, Radike Samo and Digby Ioane.
As we've seen in 2012, Ewen McKenzie's Reds have had a far tougher going of it without mercurial Wallaby pivot 'King Quade' spearheading their attack.
Without looking to make excuses for the Stormers, coach Allister Coetzee has been bereft of his skipper and Bok tyro Schalk Burger since Round Two due to injury, along with a host of front-line and back-up players throughout the campaign.
One would be hard pressed to question the effect these squad-crippling setbacks have had on the cohesion of Coetzee's preferred starting XV, and subsequently, his game-plans.
Hampered by injuries, coupled with no title-winning pedigree to speak of for more than a decade, it's little wonder the former Bok backline mentor has snapped back at the cynics who have questioned his side's current brand of rugby.
"Recently I read how the Stormers play unexciting, boring, dour rugby," Coetzee has been quoted in South Africa's media.
"Winning the conference is tougher than (winning) the Currie Cup, because this is where your national players play.
"The pre-season goal was to get into the play-offs. I have to give the team credit by again being the top team in the conference.
"Last year, we played it down a bit, but in a competition as unremitting as this, when you lose top players but still win at Loftus and at the Free State Stadium, you have to give credit.
"What people tend to forget is that it is the final score that matters. That is what we understand.
"We play winning rugby."
Technically-brilliant but not the most flamboyant player to grace the world-stage, Roger Federer has won a record 17 major tennis titles in his illustrious career.
Seven-time Formula One World Champion Michael Schumacher's resilience made him "statistically the greatest driver the sport has ever seen", but not necessarily the most well-loved.
Italy is the second most successful national football team in the history of the World Cup, yet it's the Azzurri's defence rather than their offence which has been at the back-bone of their prosperity.
And let's not forget, it took world rugby's trailblazers, the All Blacks, 24 years to replicate their first World Cup winning achievement - having ground out an 8-7 win over France in Auckland less than 12 months ago.
So, why not cut the Stormers a bit of slack, huh? Because who knows, maybe with a little less pressure to become touchdown kings, they might just be crowned champions.
By Devin Hermanus







Comments
Carpelone says...
A more balanced rugby would be better. All the arguments I am hearing here look like the ones in favour of PdV style of rugby imposed to the Boks. If your opponents know that you can't score tries, they will wait for you in the middle.
Posted 23:11 10th July 2012
olepete says...
Early in the season the Stormers were my second-favorite team (to the Crusaders) but allegiance has been transferred to the Sharks who will be dangerous to anyone in the playoffs. And remember that 'squad-crippling setbacks' in the form of injury are pretty common nowadays.
Posted 15:41 10th July 2012
pikes says...
@Jaystarr 13 out of 15 ! I think that's enough for me! If it was 4 out 15 and if we scored more tries I wouldn't have been satisfied! I've enjoyed every match so far! If your a rugby player and a true Stormer supporter you would have known the Stormer have always been known for their attractive rugby and flair.. And its seems that the past 10 years it hasn't been succesfull for them... They've changed there methods to WIN! This is a promise they will win the Super 15 this year mark my words!
Posted 15:25 10th July 2012
spliffed says...
To be fair to the Chiefs had SBW not developed white line fever or blindness in the dying seconds the Chiefs could have been out of touch at the top. Only way the Stormers stand a chance is a home final.. if they make it past the semi's. I cant see the Stormers travelling to Kiwiland and beating the Chiefs.. Stranger things have happened I guess. But dont rule out the Crusaders and a Sharks team who on their day could be a suprise package. Brumbies are too limited.. Reds wont make the play offs and the Bulls without Matfield and Botha are too limited.
Posted 14:32 10th July 2012
JayStarr says...
@ bokking: That's really nice to hear - thanks! Not a lot of fans from other SA teams would say something like that.
@ spliffed: Same here! Grew up on the stands of Newlands... so to see Province boys play such one-dimensional rugby, completely incapable of creating space for their outside backs and scoring tries, is aboslutely mind-numbing. And you're completely right - this is the 2nd year in a row! Last year I called for Robbie Fleck's head because of it... and this year I still think the blame should still be laid at his door...
It's absolutely disgraceful - he has some of the best attacking players at his disposal, who are playing behind a pack who dominated for most of the season, in a winning team - yet they have the worst attacking record in the competition! Even the Rebels have scored more tries!
I am not having myself told that this is the only kind of "winning rugby". The Chiefs, until last weekend, also lost only 2 games - but look at how they're playing!
We've got an amazing defense and a good pack when everyone is fit - but the next step must be to sort out our attack. And unless Robbie Fleck gets on the field, he is not the one to do it.
Posted 12:17 10th July 2012
bokking says...
I am a cheetah supporter and I say well done Stormers.
You won the games and deserve the conference. I hope you do well in the knockout games.
Posted 08:54 10th July 2012
spliffed says...
Jaystarr i couldnt gree with you more. My insomnia has been cured by the Stormers. i'm a life long fan (for more years than i care to remember) of Province and later years the Stormers. This season has almost been a replay of last season. 2 Bonus points all season and both for losing? The only suprise here is that Coetzee seems to be suprised that people are bored watching the Stormers. Right now as much as it pains me to say it, the only SA team I can see who have a hope in hell of winning this are the Sharks. But my money is on the Chiefs.. Unless they fail to get a bonus point next week and the Stormers wake up against the Rebels and get 5.
Posted 08:43 10th July 2012
new_j4a says...
@JayStar, "then what are we going to do?" They could bring in the coach you rated as exactly the right guy for the Boks in RWC2011......PDV?
I think that you would be far better off next season as chief fan for the Super Kings....Cheeky Watson could make you his media consultant. You could do that and keep your janitor job.
Posted 08:27 10th July 2012
georgesmith says...
Stormers are good. this is justified by their top of the table stand. they ken olso win. but to do that they need to be on top of their game all the time. at the moment, i think crusaders can stormers if they meet tomorow. chiefs wil olso push em to the wire.
Posted 23:58 09th July 2012
philipjfry says...
The answer is simple; they play too flat and don't create enough opportunities for the wide players to run at tight forwards. They play a short pick-and-drive game that sucks in opposition forwards and leaves the opposition backs free to defend. The pack never really dominates and with a very average scrum-half in Duvenage there is very little else they can do but keep possession (the Cheetahs match is the obvious exception), defend and wait for Burger's return.
Posted 19:29 09th July 2012
JayStarr says...
Good argument... Thanks for that.
But as a Stormers fan I have to admit I stood up and walked away from the tele on Saturday - I couldn't bare to watch another minute of that pathetic nonsense they were dishing up. I am not having the weather be used as an excuse - I watch the NZ sides play in cold wet weather way too much to believe that this is the only way to play in such weather...
Before the break the Stormers were winning ugly, but still looked good... But now they're winning ugly - and looking bad. And the Lions, Cheetahs and Rebels are hardly the ideal preparation (or reality checks) you need before playing a Super Rugby semi-final against one of the top teams. What if they have to play the Crusaders in the SF again? How big a step up would that be from the Rebels and another week off!?
No, I am decidedly less optimistic about our chances now. We've clearly taken a step back. On Saturday we played Currie Cup rugby, not Super Rugby. I would go as far as saying that our only hope of making the finals now would be if we met either the Brumbies, or the Bulls or Sharks flying back from Australasia a week after they flew there. If we meet the Crusaders we can forget about it... Our scrum is already disintegrating - and we haven't even played them yet. And even if we make the finals, I can't see us beating the Chiefs in Hamilton with our one-dimensional game... The Chiefs WILL score tries - then what are we going to do?
Posted 18:38 09th July 2012