Planet Rugby

Who's hot...and who's not!

20th June 2012 16:35

hot ot not june 20

No good: Midweek England - Upsetting the odds: Los Pumas

It is time for our weekly wrap up of who has their name in lights at the moment...and who is making the headlines for the wrong reasons.

They're smoooookin'!

Southern Hemisphere heavyweights: Ireland and Wales came agonisingly close Down Under and England gave South Africa a run for their money after mounting a brave fightback, but the best the Home Nations had to offer wasn't enough to prevent all three series being wrapped up prematurely. The northern trio now only have pride left to play for as they bid to avoid a series whitewash.

Ireland: They might have been on the wrong end of the result in Christchurch but the intensity of the Irish response to defeat in the first Test, especially amongst the pack, deserves a raise of the hat. BOD and co were immeasurably better in defence and were unlucky not to at least snatch a draw.

Argentina's depth: Not even France could prevent a southern hemisphere cleansweep after losing to a inexperienced Pumas outfit in Cordoba. It wasn't pretty, but Argentina - fresh from victory over Italy the previous weekend - typically fed off scraps and took their chances, scoring a late try to complete a come-from-behind victory.

Scotland and Italy:There was some reprieve for travelling northern hemisphere teams after Six Nations strugglers Scotland and Italy managed wins over Fiji and Canada. Scotland are unbeaten on tour thanks to a hard-fought victory in Lautoka, while the hot boot of Italy fly-half Kris Burton was instrumental in Canada's downfall.

Samoa: The islanders were crowned Pacific Nations Cup champions for a second time after beating defending champions Japan. Samoa finished the four-team competition with three straight wins, and will head into Saturday's Test against Scotland with their tails up.

Tim Visser:The Dutch-born winger delivered on expectations brilliantly and got his international career off to a perfect start as his two tries helped Scotland to victory, marking out the Edinburgh speedster as an automatic choice for years to come.

Berrick Barnes:It was quite a momentous 24 hours for the Wallabies playmaker who had watched the birth of his baby in Sydney before starring in Australia's win against Wales in Melbourne. Now that's what you call a super dad!

Mike Harris: The Reds centre bounced back from his costly wayward kicking display against Scotland by sending over the match-winning penalty from a wide angle after the final siren in Melbourne. Talk about going from zero to hero!

Dan Carter:If at first you don't succeed, try and try again. And that's exactly what the All Blacks pivot did after failing to land a winning drop-goal on two occasions before striking it third time lucky to break Irish hearts.

JP Pietersen: The long-striding Bok flyer played a vital role in South Africa closing out a tense encounter against England in the City of Gold. At one stage, SA led 22-3 and a series win looked in the bag. But Test rugby doesn't always work that way and when the Boks entered the final 10 minutes leading only 31-27, an upset looked on the cards. However, a try started and finished by Pietersen dismissed the prospect of a truly staggering turnaround and capped off a superb man-of-the-match performance.


Bbbrrrr... Someone turn the heater up!

England's dirt trackers: Despite losing their first two Tests to the Springboks, England's Test team's performances were of a good quality on both occasions. The same cannot, however, be said of their midweek side who have flattered to deceive in their matches against the SA Barbarians' North and South XVs. Although they managed to notch 50 points in both matches, George Robson's men never dominated proceedings against players who are from the lowest rungs of the South African professional scene. This might sound daft but getting close to the century mark in both matches would not have been a surprise to South Africa's rugby public as very few of the Barbarians players have come close to playing at Super Rugby level. The 57 points conceded = not hot.

France: Les Bleus' horrific run in Argentina continues. Saturday's loss to los Pumas means that it's been 14 long years since last year's World Cup runners-up have won a Test on Argentine soil! That's a remarkable statistic and even though they did not field their strongest XV, the visitors were expected to win this one. The tourists did all the playing but against their passionate hosts, who had the support of a fanatical crowd on their side, Phillipe Saint-André's men fumbled and bumbled their way to disappointing defeat. It was a harsh reminder that Argentina is one of the toughest places in the world to tour.

All Blacks: No one expected it but it was bound to happen...New Zealand were run mighty close by Ireland and if nothing else it was all down to complacency by the world champions. After their clinical display in the opening Test of the three-match series most rugby enthusiasts predicted another walkover for the men in black against their counterparts from the Emerald Isle. It was said that unlike 2003 and 2007 world champions England and South Africa, the All Blacks were not suffering from a hangover after last year's World Cup victory. Steve Hansen was, however, nursing a massive headache five minutes before the end and only some late DC heroics saved his blushes.

Springboks front-row replacements: The Boks' first-half performance in the second Test against England was one of their most dominant displays in recent years. Most of it was down to the perfect platform laid by the forwards for their backs, but all that good work almost came unstuck when coach Heyneke Meyer decided to do some tampering with his front-row. Off went the Du Plessis brothers and on came Adriaan Strauss and Werner Kruger. There seemed to be little cohesion up front and the highly-rated Bok pack got pushed around on more than one occasion in the scrums. Will Meyer learn his lesson and avoid the fate of his predecessor, Peter de Villiers, who was regularly in the firing line for continuously making substitutions en masse?

Rhys Priestland: The Welsh fly-half makes his second appearance in this section in as many weeks. After dropping the ball with a huge overlap at a crucial stage of the first Test against Australia in Brisbane last week things could only get better for the Scarlets pivot. However, he incurred the wrath of his team-mates when, with Wales leading 23-22, he kicked the ball into touch in the dying minutes of the second Test in Melbourne. The Wallabies went on the drive at the resulting line-out, Wales were penalised for collapsing the maul and Mike Harris made them pay.

The Top 14 calendar: France started their June tour a week later than every one else because their season ended a fortnight after those across the Channel, and the French would have been shaking their heads in disbelief at the sight of their clubs starting pre-season training just nine days after Toulouse raised the Bouclier de Brennus. Yip, the Top 14 kicks off again on August 18!

Argentina U20s: Last week we were singing their praises, but Los Pumitas' wheels came off sensationally in their semi-final defeat to the Baby Boks at Newlands on Sunday. Despite reaching the final four without losing a match, Argentina's youngsters seemed out of their depth and didn't come close to matching the exploits of their previous matches. With the game lost it was not a pleasant sight as several of their players spent the latter stages of the second half playing the man and not the ball. This performance took off plenty of the shine from their stunning start to the competition.

Compiled by Dave Morris and Dave Skippers

Comments

new_j4a says...

@curates_egg, please post links to article and NO's tweet

Posted 20:30 21st June 2012

NZcrusade says...

@pog_mahone:

I mean't no disrespect to Ireland's effort last weekend, it was an epic showing and a complete turn around from the previous week and certainly showed that Ireland have the potential to be at the top, providing they can play like that consistently. It was Irish pressure and commitment bringing about a below par(imo) NZ performance. Perhaps my point came across poorly in that manner, in which case apologies. All I was implying was, that it is far to early to start assuming NZ are going to be performing like SA or England post WC wins, especially when they've started with a series win.

Posted 19:50 21st June 2012

pog_mahone says...

NZ crusade - so when New Zealand win they played well, and when they lose they played poorly. There's no half way when you've only one eye, is there? No hint at all that Ireland upped their game last week, 1 through 22 - and if Ireland can maintain the same performance this week the result will also be close. No argument whatsoever that NZ is the better team and with far more depth - but give just a little credit where credit is due.

Posted 16:47 21st June 2012

kybone says...

jonesy2- You're welcome to your opinions, but can you actually back them up? My guess is no. Of course the NH are getting closer to the SH. You only have to look at the results to see that. Wales lost by 2 points to Oz in Oz and they were disappointed with that! Scotland, the 6N worst team, beat Oz in Oz. Ireland only got beaten by 3 to NZ in Christchurch, and England by 9 against SA at altitude. Thats a combined losing margin of 14 points and we were all away from home! Australia have been beaten by a NH team for the last 3 World Cups in a row!

For me, NZ are still the best team in the world but below them theres very little to choose between the next 6 or 7 teams. And even the ones below that are starting to get wins against big teams every now and then i.e. Samoa v Australia, Scotland v Australia, Italy v France, Tonga v France, Scotland v SA etc.

Posted 16:40 21st June 2012

Jivinjeff says...

Maybe the Springbok forwards are "highly-rated" in general, but their scrum hasn't been for years. Other than half a game against the BI Lions they rarely get a push on. "Usually stable" is probably a closer compliment to the truth.

Still, with Smit out of the side they can only get better. And the All Blacks shouldn't challenge them too much this year in that department with BBBT out of the engine room.

Posted 16:09 21st June 2012

BokkeJ says...

@Trinats, why is it that people feel so compelled to always try and knock SA's 2 world cup wins? Lets just look at pure and simple facts. If all games ever played are taken into account the AB's have a comfortable winning ratio over every other nation on earth (although their ratio over SA is not so comfortable - 55%)... so lets call them the best. SA have a comfortable winning ratio over every nation on earth (yes including Aus) except the AB's ... so lets say we're the second best. Why do our 2x World Champ wins bother everyone so much!?! Surely the second strongest team, statistically, of all time deserves at least 2 world cup wins?

Posted 15:36 21st June 2012

jonesy2 says...

NZcrusade they didnt say they had a WC hangover they said they were complacent, subconsciously or not.

Jazz-- also, the argies will soon be the 4th or 5th best in the world after a few RC

Posted 15:15 21st June 2012

jonesy2 says...

you have some nerve to call mike harris' kicking against scotland "wayward".

NHsaints- yes they do, the allblacks were pretty much a disgrace and let down the christchurch fans hugely. but to put them is the not section is funny because only a truely ridiculously dominant sporting team can slip out of a pickle with such seemingly nonchalant ease

Jazz-- sorry mate the NH are the opposite of getting closer, they are getting further and further apart.

Posted 15:11 21st June 2012

Stellenbosched2 says...

Hi Trinats2

Emotive language there boet. 'Given' the RWC 2007 and 'dodgy' 95 campaign. Every winner of the RWC avoids one or two top teams, it's the nature of the tournament. And every winner has the odd close call (Ireland 18-Ozz 19).In Ozz's case, in 91 you 'avoided' (your word) France and SA. In 99 you 'avoided' New Zealand and England. The difference between the average Ozz supporter and the average SA supporter is that you are not constantly reminded of these facts. But don't worry, I have moved on, I really have. Enjoy all the money that SA invests in Ozz rugby every year through the SANZAR split.

Posted 12:58 21st June 2012

latehit says...

You should be looking at a number of the U20s teams currently in SA for the Junior world cup. Rumor and strife abound. Why are England and Australia with the talent they have, playing off for 7th and 8th. All night parties, nightclub fights, booze benders, no respect for coaches. Bu then again when you have rugby role models like Q.Cooper and K.Beale who can get away with anything and get not punishment, what do you expect from a bunch of impressionable kids. Well Done to the finalists. Top Quality Rugby. Shame on the pre tournament favorites (not SA or NZ) for letting your country down with shameless behavior.

Posted 12:38 21st June 2012

Jazz says...

The NH getting ever closer. Once the game became professional it was always gonna happen with so many top players leaving for Europe to build there pension funds. Not so much the fact that it strengthens their domestic game, but rather losing out on a wealth of knowledge and experience that should have been passed on locally. Just wondering - are there any stats available on how many AU, NZ and SA pros are currently signed by European clubs? (And yeah, I know... I should deal with it.)

Posted 12:21 21st June 2012

markpat says...

How are the southern hemispehere heavyweights hot, but NZ are not hot?

Dan Carter is hot because he got a 50% strike rate on drop goals right in front of the posts after one of his quieter games?

How is Mike Harris hot for kicking one goal in a game?

How are Italy hot? They were appalling against Canada. Similar query about Tim Visser - yes he scored 2 tries, but his defence was appalling.

I'm guessing no-one actually watched either of these games, or expectations are exceptionally low this week!

Posted 11:37 21st June 2012

Stellenbosched2 says...

Hi NZcrusade,

You are right about the nonsense of 'building towards the next RWC'. I am convinced it is used as an excuse by coaching staff to hang on to their jobs and the perks a bit longer.

Hi AWEBLAX,

You have mentioned something that I find interesting in two fundamental differences in approach between the AB's and SA:

- The AB's seem to play every test as if they have to win by at least 20 points (which they often do) whereas the Boks as a rule are content with a win. The size of the points difference is not critical.

- NZ as a nation seem more passionate about being ranked number one. I have to say that it is the only country that can handle the stress of always being aimed at. Personally it was agony when the Boks were number one after 2007. Just way too much riding on every test. I think most SA fans are happy to be number two officially, but win every test (ja, ja, I know it is contradictory).

Hi StunTheMullet

You have a point. Welcome to our(Bok fans) world. I have figured it out that the two nations fans most consistently called whingers are NZ and SA. The reason is obvious. Both EXPECT to win every match. Perhaps some of the best rugby fans are those who support a side that has no chance of winning a RWC in the near future yet remain loyal.

Posted 11:17 21st June 2012

Trinats2 says...

Stellenbosched2:

You are right, SA did avoid the best teams to be given the 2007 WC after finishing bottom of tri nations yet again, and throw in there their dodgy Home 95 campagin, but that's the draw so move on.

with regards to NZ, no one picks on the poor performance from NZ due to the protection they received from ...a saffa ref ! and everyone focused on the poor ref rather than the poor performance (or great French performance) Hence no reaction to the low score.

As a neutral and self confessed arm chair critic !!! SA do kick too much for my liking and always have (strange when you have such a dominate pack) NZ get away with too much, because the rest of the world has bought into the AB marketing campaign, including the Barbour jacket wearing crowd that is IRB.

I hear people on her refer to soccer and all I ever heard in the UK is how Man U got away with so much. Granted NZ and man U were the consistently best around but the is no doubt some of their results were handed to them because of a preconceived reputation.

Posted 10:46 21st June 2012

kenttaff says...

good piece PR, agree with both front row comments about wales and south africa. cant for the life of me think why the bok brothers were subbed off as they were an absolute handful against england. how bismarck was overlooked for smit for the previous 2 years is nothing short of a crime

Posted 10:43 21st June 2012

letsgoboks says...

2EyedKiwi - agree with you :D

Posted 10:25 21st June 2012

curates_egg says...

No mention for Nigel Owens? As if making a dubious game-changing decision wasn't enough; he completely undermined the institution of refereeing with his tweeted responses to an article dissecting his inconsistent refereeing in the match. Referees should be above that type of thing. Spellcheck would have made it slightly less cringeworthy.

Posted 10:23 21st June 2012

kybone says...

So NZ are 'Not Hot' but the team beaten by NZ are 'Hot'??? So basically NZ have to win by at least 20 points every time to even be considered for the 'Hot' list. How come the Pumitas are bottom of the 'Not Hot' list but their Welsh counterparts aren't on the list at all when they collapsed in a very similar fashion? Im surprised that the RFU aren't in the 'Not Hot' list given their decision to drag out the London Welsh appeal thing for ANOTHER week. 28th June the hearing is now set for! LW and Newcastle might find out what league they're in by the start of pre season training, if they're lucky!

Posted 10:18 21st June 2012

StunTheMullet says...

@ Stellenbosched2 - Meanwhile when the All Blacks win the RWC we hear that it was only because of the referee, only because played in NZ, they choked, second best team on the park, deliberate foul play (despite clear eye gouging from the opposition which was never cited), cheaters, rigged RWC yadda yadda.

Now its world cup hangover when haven't lost a game yet.

Seens the anti All Black brigade are finding the bitter horse tablets are proving hard to get past the epiglottis.

Posted 10:11 21st June 2012

sandal says...

@hayj05

lol. good man!

Posted 09:50 21st June 2012

Page 1 of 2

Character Count : 0/1900

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
International Match
Wednesday, June 19
Fiji vs USA17:10
Japan vs Canada19:10
Saturday , June 22
New Zealand vs France08:35
Italy vs Scotland14:15
South Africa vs Samoa17:15
Sunday , June 23
Fiji vs Tonga12:10
Japan vs USA14:10
More International Match fixtures
British & Irish Lions
Tuesday , June 18
Brumbies vs British & Irish LionsBrumbies vs British & Irish Lions Preview
Saturday , June 22
Australia vs British & Irish Lions11:05
More British & Irish Lions fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
International Match
Sunday , June 16
Canada 14 - 40 IrelandCanada vs Ireland Report
Saturday , June 15
Japan 23 - 8 WalesJapan vs Wales Report
New Zealand 30 - 0 FranceNew Zealand vs France Report
South Africa 30 - 17 ScotlandSouth Africa vs Scotland Report
Samoa 39 - 10 ItalySamoa vs Italy Report
Argentina 26 - 51 EnglandArgentina vs England Report
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Waratahs 17 - 47 British & Irish LionsWaratahs vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
International Match
Friday , June 14
USA 9 - 18 TongaUSA vs Tonga Report
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Tuesday , June 11
NSW-Queensland Country 0 - 64 British & Irish LionsNSW-Queensland Country vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
International Match
Sunday , June 9
USA 12 - 15 IrelandUSA vs Ireland Report
More International Match results
Super Rugby
Western Force 13 - 28 WaratahsWestern Force vs Waratahs Report
More Super Rugby results
International Match
Saturday , June 8
USA 12 - 15 Ireland
Scotland 17 - 27 SamoaScotland vs Samoa Report
Samoa 27 - 17 Scotland
New Zealand 23 - 13 FranceNew Zealand vs France Report
Japan 18 - 22 WalesJapan vs Wales Report
Canada 36 - 27 Tonga
Argentina 3 - 32 EnglandArgentina vs England Report
South Africa 44 - 10 ItalySouth Africa vs Italy Report
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Reds 12 - 22 British & Irish LionsReds vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
Super Rugby
Friday , June 7
Brumbies 39 - 17 Melbourne RebelsBrumbies vs Melbourne Rebels Report
More Super Rugby results
International Match
Wednesday, June 5
Fiji 18 - 20 Canada
More International Match results
British & Irish Lions
Western Force 17 - 69 British & Irish LionsWestern Force vs British & Irish Lions Report
More British & Irish Lions results
International Match
Saturday , June 1
Fiji 22 - 8 Japan
More International Match results
Top 14
Toulon 14 - 19 CastresToulon vs Castres Report
More Top 14 results