Planet Rugby

The Phil Vickery column

Wooden spoon white logo

The Phil Vickery column

19th June 2012 13:26

Dan Cole with blood from ear

Catching the eye: Dan Cole

In the third installment of a series of exclusive columns for Planet Rugby, former England prop Phil Vickery examines England's chances in PE.

Phil Vickery is an Official Ambassador of Wooden Spoon, the leading Rugby Charity. 'Spoon' is a children's charity founded in 1983, dedicated to helping disadvantaged children and young people across the British Isles live happier, richer lives. 'Spoon' partner with the UK rugby community, and during our first 25 years, over half a million young people benefited form over £18 million of charitable support. WS is proud of its legacy, the work it does, and the ambitious plans for the future. Visit www.woodenspoon.com for further details.

Reflecting on the Second Test at the towering Ellis Park, I have to admit the opening 20 minutes went something like I feared it might. Unless you've personally experienced wave upon wave of strapping Springboks running around the corner towards you at pace, you have no idea just how big a physical challenge this is. Yes, you could claim that South Africa's first try was a nonsense, but in honesty, could you deny that they had earned the points from the manner they played?

However, England rallied well, and were in touching distance at the end, and even 'won' the second half by a narrow margin, but that rally was achieved through grim determination and absolute heart rather than anything more tactical or technical.

South Africa don't enjoy the contact game, they absolutely relish it! Even their backs want to bully their opposite number; they want to hit and they want to hurt. Everything about the Springbok game is BIG- from kicks, to tackles to carries and everything in-between, and it was here the game was won and lost.

Willem Alberts has been a massive thorn in England's side this series, and his direct, no-nonsense approach is something England can learn from. Bismarck du Plessis too, made a lethal impact on the game, and I am sure that all who played in RWC 2011 were delighted this mobile behemoth of a hooker was inexplicably confined to reserve duties during the competition. England's forwards could take a lot from emulating how these guys hit the line and the pass from deep and at pace. When 18 stones (or 120kgs) is moving at you that quickly, it's hard to stop them dead on the gainline.

But there were some very pleasing moments and performances by the men in white too. Dan Cole continues to catch my eye and he's made a big impression on this series, holding up the huge Bok pack early on and then increasing his stranglehold on both the game and his opposite number as the match progressed. His work and work-rate in the ruck is also outstanding, and there are few better props in the world right now. Alex Corbisiero made a strong showing after replacing the mobile Marler; he and Cole work well together in 'pinching' the opposition front row- both England props pointing inwards like an arrow head onto the hooker and trying to disconnect the SA loosehead, so effectively England are scrummaging 3 v 2 in the front row, something they achieved three or four times in the second half. Thomas Waldrom, an unlikely shape for an 8, is a real footballer and added much needed impact. Gritty and intelligent, he understands southern hemisphere rugby and his introduction made a noticeable difference, save for his awful dropped catch.

However, there were some serious concerns in terms of structure and defence, compounded by playing an inexperienced centre partnership with two outside centres. It resulted in a palpable lack of shape in both attack and defence, with England playing a very 'de-constructed' game, something they're not used to and is not really the 'English way'. As an example of this, the last Bok try featured a run from the outstanding JP Pietersen where he waltzed through 7 (yes 7!) would be tacklers. Worrying too, there was a lack of shape and chase to defend the initial kick from Jonathan Joseph that JPP returned. I know Stuart Lancaster will be appalled at this one moment in the game, despite JP Pietersen's outstanding display. There is an old adage in rugby- a kick is made a good kick by a good chase. In this respect, SA are a long way ahead of England right now and they really apply pressure through the chase once they've kicked.

It also concerned me to see the poor execution of pressure relieving tactics. We continually put ourselves in areas of the field where we simply did not want to be; Chris Ashton's inexcusable penalty directly after the first try is a great example of this; just when England needed to play territory, we found ourselves back defending our own red zone. That was a naïve piece of rugby in extremis from the Saints wing.

So onto the 'Windy City', the wonderful Port Elizabeth, with its long beaches and calm demeanour. A visit to Jeffery's Bay is always a highlight for the tourists, where the huge, rolling 'tube' breakers are legendary with surfers around the world. It's often overlooked by visitors for the attractions of Durban and Cape Town, but it's truly a lovely city, with tremendously friendly people who 'braaii' until the early hours on the west end of the beach, and I've enjoyed both playing and socialising there a number of times. Nearby Cape St Francis is also a beautiful place well worth a trip; a holiday village for the rich and trendy, with canals, lagoons and the Indian Ocean all at hand- utterly stunning.

Although England have lost both tests narrowly, I believe Lancaster will make a number of changes for the last test. In the backline, expect a recall for either Barritt or Farrell to captain the defence at 12, with Tuilagi given a roaming role on the wing, where he's played a lot of club rugby, and will look to match the physicality of JPP and Habana. In the pack, Tom Palmer's bulk is sorely needed in the second-row, and in the loose forwards, we will see a re-shuffle, with the probable line up (through injury and change) of Johnson (or Dowson), Haskell and Waldrom. I also expect the looseheads to swap, with Corbisiero starting. I understand the outstanding Ben Youngs is struggling, and therefore Danny Care's welcome return to form will earn him a test start.

It'll be a tough ask for England, but, with the Boks also missing key players through injury, I actually fancy them to sneak this one by a score.

Cheers,

Vicks

Join Phil Vickery on the TNT Great British Bike Ride 2012. This cycle will be staged from Land's End to Twickenham Stadium from Tuesday, August 28 to Saturday, September 1, 2012. The five day ride is designed for all cycling enthusiasts, sportsmen and women who want to take on a real challenge and at the same time raise some much appreciated funds for Wooden Spoon, www.woodenspoon.com the children's charity of rugby. To register your interest please contact Nick Fielding, nfielding@woodenspoon.com and for more details on the event please go to www.greatbritishbikeride.co.uk

Comments

letsgoboks says...

J-bay and Cape St Francis... thanks for making me homesick Phil :D

Posted 10:41 20th June 2012

markpat says...

NHSaints, I'm assuming you mean Dan Ward-Smith as the Wasps #8? He is 34 now though, so even if he were fit, I'd prefer a younger option.

On another topic, please, please, please no James Haskell. For the few positives that he brings, his negatives far outweigh them.

Also, Tuilagi will get exposed for lack of pace on the wing, in my opinion. Although Kahui had a strong world cup on the wing, generally speaking, it is a big change from centre to wing (wing to centre isn't too bad).

Also, no, no, to Barritt in the centre. We'll revert to trying to stifle South Africa, rather than trying to actually build some attacking rugby. How do you expect Tuilagi and Joseph to learn to play together if you move one of them to the wing after just one game? Tuilagi's future isn't on the wing, why play him there?

Posted 09:54 20th June 2012

philipjfry says...

He spelt 'braai' wrong. Only 'one eye' Phil.

Posted 22:53 19th June 2012

ARGNo9 says...

"both England props pointing inwards like an arrow head onto the hooker" isnīt this against the law?

Posted 21:50 19th June 2012

NHsaints says...

Great article...few can Deny cole is a world class tighthead and with some honing and refining the English front Row is a serious force to be reckoned with...especially considering that Marler is the weakest link in the scrum and is only 21. Combine that with a Palmer - Lawes second row or a Lawes - Parling second row and you've got a tough looking tight 5. People looking for England's up coming 8? There were two...Narraway and the Wasps U21 8 (I can't remember his name) but unfortunately Narraway was ignored after injury and the Wasps 8 had to retire due to knee injury. With Kvesic the obvious choice at 7 for England in the coming years I'd move Robshaw to 8 - he can carry, tackle and offload. And then Let croft and wood fight for the 6 jersey. There are no real talents coming through at 8 and if we'd been trying to win the series Easter would have been our starting 8. I really like the Idea of Tuilagi on the wing...we've been exposed out wide before and he'll handle that easily and he's scored most of his best tries from a back 3 position or going down the wing. That'll also allow us to employ Joseph's skill at 13 and Barritt's endless tackling from 12.

Posted 18:47 19th June 2012

APV1 says...

@ astrospange - you might not want PV commentating if you'd heard him during the RWC! That said, I'd gladly replace Barnes with white noise, such is his ability to annoy everyone. He's neither partisan nor objective. He swaps allegiances more often than the ball changes posession during a match and we all just wish he would shut up!

@ objetive - what an awful post. To suggest that we're that bad and are delusional is plain wrong. To suggest that a win against SA is meaningless is also daft. It's no more meaningless than the last two wins by SA against an inexperienced and developing team, by an experienced and gelled SA.

Anyone who claims that SA are not experienced and gelled is just wrong. The FR is an obvious place to start and let's consider how inexperienced and un-gelled they are! Of course there are some new caps and less experienced players, but the SA team is overwhelmingly more experienced and test-hardened than the English one. And for this English team to come to SA and perform as they have done is commendable. And to belittle that achievement, or that of the winner on Saturday, shows a small-minded and one-eyed bias that's quite ugly. Most Saffas are good humoured and great hosts, with a good grasp of rugby. It's a shame that there are those who let themselves down, with ill thought through comments.

Posted 17:36 19th June 2012

heathy says...

For me this particular tour has not been about winning. Granted, to record a win (or even two or three) would have been fantastic but in reality this was never ever going to happen. For me it was all about the performance, blooding young and inexperienced players and improving. There is nothing better than to have a tour against the Boks in their back yard as experience. Add to this they were able to compete and this will do the world of good going forward (I hope). Don't get me wrong, England are still a long way off. Even if we do win this next match (IF?) then it will not be the same as winning any of the first two. It is, as they say, a dead rubber. However, England should go all hell for leather and try to win it. Take something from the tour and learn. They have got SH teams in November and then a Six Nations competition after that. If we can keep progressing then this side is looking good for the future. After a few more games against SH oposition we need to look at taking a few scalps. We are a good three years behind Wales and for me, the next Six Nations is going to be interesting as I think Wales have gone backwards. In contrast, their tour was a disappointment for them. Ireland for me haven't really moved. They can be great one day and awful the next. Unfortunately, the Boks and the All Blacks are looking very good not only now but for the future.

Posted 15:33 19th June 2012

rugby_rockstar says...

Wish you were there in SA Phil!

Posted 15:30 19th June 2012

bloemboy says...

Nice article, offering praise where it is due. In my opinion though, Waldrom was no better than average and only stood out because he was in white. If he had been wearing a green or black shirt, he would have been totally inconspicuous. His carries etc. are a minimum expectation for a Bok or All Black loose. If you compare his 20 minutes worth to the play of Alberts, McCaw, Burger, Pocock, Reid etc, he simply isnt even in the same hemisphere....

Surely England can unearth another Dallalio from somewhere.

I completely agree on Dan Cole. Excellent player and technician

Posted 15:21 19th June 2012

APV1 says...

Nailed it again, Bull!

Posted 15:04 19th June 2012

objetive says...

Never enjoy dead rubbers as the team that has lost the series is always more motivated to win. Inevitably, the winning team also rests players not really injured (having done the business the week before). A consolation victory is then used as a basis to argue any number of "if only" scenarios in the first two tests and to convince oneself that one actually "deserved" (hate that word in a sporting context) to have won the series. Then DVD's are released about England's famous series "win" (because they deserved to win the 1st and/or 2nd test too). England, my message to you is to not speak a bunch of nonsense if you squeeze a win on Sat. Just accept it was a bit meaningless and that you have a lot to learn before you can win when it really matters. Having said all that, it has been great having you over and well done on competing in patches. Both you and the Boks will get a lot better. EngvSA final in the next RWC? Quite possible.

Posted 14:51 19th June 2012

astrospange says...

Vickery to replace Barnes as commentator on Sky! Sense, insight, positivity and lack of bitterness are qualities Barnes sadly does not have.

Posted 14:39 19th June 2012

melkdave says...

Annother concise and well written article,,and yes the J.P.Pitersen try was a soft try ,as he should have been nailed by the 1st up tackler.but still a great run.I to expect there to be changes ,much as Vicks has stated.B.Morgon has been a bit of a disappiontment imo ,given his ability and size ,but has shown enough in flashes as to his potential,he can only improve imho,and overall Eglands attack is still lacking .The support just isnt there at vital moments ,but again its showing improvment in flahes,consistancy in that regard will come (i hope) as the team developes.Overall its been a good tour so far from England ,lets not forget its a very experianced and powerfull SA team,picked purely to win against England ,as stated by HM himself.For it to be an outstanding tour England have to win a test ,and they arnt to far off doing that imho,They just need to cope with the SA power game ,which i know is easier said than done ,and keep the scores close thoughout the entire match,if they can stay within 3-5 ponts they have a good chance imho,Not going to be easy ,but then nothing worth doing is easy ,and what a morale boost it could be for a young developing squad /team.To have an away win against a major SH nation

Posted 14:30 19th June 2012

redcoat2806 says...

Good article and nice to see Dan Cole getting the praise he deserves. Really has been one of the most consistent performers over the past two years. I feel he really benefits from sharing his position at Leicester each week as he isn't over-used. He has only missed 1 of the last 31 England tests according the the RFU website which rather supports my point.

Posted 14:20 19th June 2012

Page 1 of 1

Character Count : 0/1900

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
International Match
Sunday , May 26
England vs BarbariansEngland vs Barbarians Preview
More International Match fixtures
Super Rugby
Friday , May 31
Crusaders vs Waratahs08:35
Brumbies vs Hurricanes10:40
More Super Rugby fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Aviva Premiership
Saturday , May 25
Leicester 37 - 17 NorthamptonLeicester vs Northampton Report
More Aviva Premiership results
RaboDirect PRO12
Ulster 18 - 24 LeinsterUlster vs Leinster Report
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
Top 14
Clermont Auvergne 9 - 25 CastresClermont Auvergne vs Castres Report
More Top 14 results
Super Rugby
Blues 13 - 20 BrumbiesBlues vs Brumbies Report
Western Force 19 - 18 HighlandersWestern Force vs Highlanders Report
Stormers 20 - 15 RedsStormers vs Reds Report
Sharks 16 - 18 BullsSharks vs Bulls Report
Southern Kings 22 - 34 CheetahsSouthern Kings vs Cheetahs Report
More Super Rugby results
Top 14
Friday , May 24
Toulon 24 - 9 ToulouseToulon vs Toulouse Report
More Top 14 results
Super Rugby
Chiefs 28 - 19 CrusadersChiefs vs Crusaders Report
Melbourne Rebels 24 - 22 WaratahsMelbourne Rebels vs Waratahs Report
More Super Rugby results
Heineken Cup
Saturday , May 18
Clermont Auvergne 15 - 16 ToulonClermont Auvergne vs Toulon Report
More Heineken Cup results
Super Rugby
Crusaders 23 - 3 BluesCrusaders vs Blues Report
Waratahs 28 - 22 BrumbiesWaratahs vs Brumbies Report
Cheetahs 27 - 13 RedsCheetahs vs Reds Report
Bulls 35 - 18 HighlandersBulls vs Highlanders Report
More Super Rugby results
Amlin Challenge Cup
Friday , May 17
Stade Francais 13 - 34 LeinsterStade Francais vs Leinster Report
More Amlin Challenge Cup results
Super Rugby
Hurricanes 12 - 17 ChiefsHurricanes vs Chiefs Report
Western Force 13 - 23 SharksWestern Force vs Sharks Report
Melbourne Rebels 30 - 21 StormersMelbourne Rebels vs Stormers Report
More Super Rugby results
Aviva Premiership
Sunday , May 12
Saracens 13 - 27 NorthamptonSaracens vs Northampton Report
Saturday , May 11
Leicester 33 - 16 HarlequinsLeicester vs Harlequins Report
More Aviva Premiership results
RaboDirect PRO12
Leinster 17 - 15 GlasgowLeinster vs Glasgow Report
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
Top 14
Castres 25 - 12 MontpellierCastres vs Montpellier Report
More Top 14 results
Super Rugby
Blues 36 - 32 Melbourne RebelsBlues vs Melbourne Rebels Report
More Super Rugby results