It's warmer down south
It is time for our weekly wrap up of who has their name in lights at the moment...and who is making the headlines for the wrong reasons.
They're on fire!
Southern hemisphere: No one seriously expected Ireland to beat the All Blacks but Welsh fans had realistic hopes that the Grand Slam champs might end their drought on Australian soil - that extends from 1969 - against a Wallaby side infected with self-doubt after the Scottish hiccup. The English thought playing at sea level might offer them a chance against a Bok side finding their feet under a new coach. Most expected a near full-strength Italian side to cruise past a second-string Pumas outfit. In the end, the 4-0 whitewash suggests matching the pace and intensity of the southern hemisphere heavyweights remains a work in progress for their challengers from the North.
Toulouse: It wasn't a classic final by any stretch of the imagination but no one will deny that Toulouse deserved their 19th French title. The Big Red and Black Machine dominated that French league, leading the championship for the last 16 rounds before totally outmuscling Toulon at scrum time in Paris. A mention too for Luke McAlister, who landed all six of his shots at goal.
Samoa: Top of the IRB Pacific Nations Cup standings as the only unbeaten side in this year's tournament following wins over Tonga and Fiji, Samoa put themselves in a position to clinch the title next week if they beat Japan.
Julian Savea: The young Hurricane proved, more than adequately, that he could make the step up to the Test arena as he scored three blockbusting tries to herald a new era for the world champions under Steve Hansen.
Bryan Habana: The 2007 World Player of the Year has been in outstanding form for the Stormers this season and in his first Test appearance in 2012 he showed that he can still be an important player for the Boks too. The former Bulls (sorry, we couldn't resist) wing displayed glimpses of the kind of form that once made him the most dangerous player on the planet with his best performance in green and gold for ages.
Will Genia: Australia's number nine was the clinical mastermind who ran the courageous Welsh into despair as the Wallabies tasted Test redemption only four days after a shock loss to Scotland. Genia was back to his dangerous best, inspiring his side to victory after taking control of the match with two pivotal plays in the second half - first, darting over for a try seconds after half-time, and then sending centre Pat McCabe across in the 67th minute to snuff out the Welsh comeback.
Los Pumitas:Argentina's Under 20s have been the sensation of the Junior World Champs, following on from their senior side's upset of Italy to top Pool C in convincing fashion and qualify for the semi-finals. The hosts await.
Pieter de Villiers: It's been a long time since the Bok scrum looked that solid. The former Stade Français and France stalwart has been handed a lot of the credit for his input. Could the real PDV please stand up?
Bbbrrrr... Someone turn up the heater!
Peter de Villiers: He can't find a job, but that hasn't stopped P-Divvy from making news. In his recently released book, the ex-Bok coach says "I think I was the Mandela of rugby." Eh??? We reckon drawing a comparison to a man who spent 27 years in prison only to walk out and shake hands with his oppressors is more than a little rich when you consider that De Villiers has yet to stop bleating on about how he needs an apology from Bryce Lawrence. Talk about delusions of grandeur. A little perspective please!
Zebras: Despite an impressive coaching line-up which includes some of the greats of the Italian game, the Parma-based team that will take part in the PRO12 and Heineken Cup next season could possibly have the worst name in the history of the game! Rugby is a brutal, physical game where the laws of the jungle (pardon the pun) are applied ruthlessly on the field and in the press. The FIR have been at pains to stress that they want a team made up mostly of Italians and not imports from the Highveld. Yet they've chosen a not-so-Italian animal to be their symbol. The funniest part of the whole situation is that Italy's other team, Treviso (who actually win fairly often these days) are known as i Leoni (the Lions). We can see the headlines following Italian derbies already...
Japan: Former Wallabies coach Eddie Jones took over the reins from John Kirwan after the defending Pacific Nations Cup champions' winless showing at last year's World Cup. Jones was seen as the man that man that would fix the 2019 World Cup hosts' problems, especially after he guided Suntory Sungoliath to the Japanese Championship title last year. But the men from the Land of the Rising Sun have little to crow about after suffering consecutive defeats at home to Fiji and Tonga.
Kurtley Beale and Quade Cooper: Being injured didn't prevent the Wallabies duo from hitting the headlines. Only problem is... they made the front page and not the back page of newspapers in Australia after being asked to leave a Brisbane hotel during the early hours of Friday morning after an "incident" with security guards at the establishment's pub. It is alleged that Beale hit a security guard on the head. The Australian Rugby Union are investigating. Another incident to be swept under the carpet?
Rhys Priestland: The Wales pivot must still be wondering what could have happened if he had managed to hold onto the ball in the 63rd minute in Brisbane. With a massive overlap on his outside and the score at 20-19 Wales were on the attack inside Australia's 22 when Priestland dropped the egg. To be fair, the pass was a difficult one and high above his head but as they say in cricket...catches win matches.
SABC: Another mammoth stuff-up from South Africa's national broadcaster. Instead of showing a delayed broadcast of the first Test between the Springboks and England, as advertised, fans were treated to....an episode of Smallville. It's a sad day when spandex suits, kryptonite and super-powered teenage-angst trump Test rugby.
AWOL Pacific Islanders: It's a sorry reflection of the state of rugby in the Pacific Islands when on a weekend that Samoa, Tonga and Fiji are playing Test matches, no less than twelve internationals were lining up for the BGC APB invitational side against Saracens in Hong Kong. A combination of politics and money meant that Kahn Fotuali'i, Alesana Tuilagi, Henry Tuilagi, Seilala Mapusua, Seru Rabeni, Viliami Ma'asi, Tonga Lea'aetoa, Elvis Seveali'i, Vilimoni Delasau, Mahonri Schwalger, Deacon Manu and Sione Timani were not doing duty for their respective national sides.
Top 14 knock outs: Toulouse forwards coach Yannick Bru said it best after the final: "The Top 14 is totally locked." 240 minutes of rugby and not single try. C'est ennuyeux.
The European ranking system: We've made this point before and it seems that the big clubs in England and France are also sick of the lopsided clashes and pools that have become a trend in the Heineken Cup. English clubs are threatening to pull out off European competition if the qualification and ranking system is not reviewed and it's easy to understand why.
Compiled by Ross Hastie, Dave Morris and Dave Skippers







Comments
blametheref says...
I agree there could be "tweaking" of the Heineken cup qualification etc, but take the soccer European Champions League, the most popular watched sport in the world, SKY have just paid 3 Billion for the rights for the next 3 years...where extemely low ranked League of Ireland teams qualify and get their chance to play the top clubs like Barcelona and Manchester United early in the competition, it's what makes the Champions League special, in that all countries in Europe are given their chance. As regards the HC, yes there could be some tweks but threatning to "walk out" is sheer arrogance. You don't hear Barcelona or Man Utd threatning European soccer with walk outs over League of Ireland teams or Norwegian teams participating etc, it adds to the competition, especially when say Barcelona have to come and beat a tiddler team away and the locals are talking about it for years to come.
One change I do think should be made in the HC is that quarter and semi finals should be Home and Away affairs, mainly because these are the red hot matches and like the Champions League pulls in the most viewers and adds that extra element to proceedings
Posted 08:53 15th June 2012
Willy says...
@ the Editor, on blame the Ref's post.
Connacht are in by the virture of Leinster winning the Heineken cup and as such Ireland's 4 team (in this case connacht) benefit from the extra place in the Heineken cup reserved for the champions. Therefore did not gain automatic qualification as you suggest. Had a team from another nation won the HC then connacht would be in the Amlin.
Now I do agree that the H.C. places should go to the top Rabo teams rather than 3 irish, 3 welsh, 2 scottish and 2 Italian, but then again its the European cup and should by its very name try to encompass as much nations as possible. You don't hear the Spanish, English, Italian & German soccer clubs looking for more Champions league places over teams that would be considered far weaker than the 5 place team in those leagues.
Do the english clubs not remember the last time they walk out of the HC cup and then came back with their tail between their legs.
The editor says.... Willy: I think you have misinterpreted my post. By 'automatic' I meant by virtue and their nationality as opposed to having qualified on merit via their position in the Pro12 standings. So, essentially, we agree.
Posted 15:32 14th June 2012
APV1 says...
With regards to the HC qualification and the England and France disputes, I think you need to draw a comparison to the S15. Many are complaining that, despite not having scored as many points as other teams, the top team in the Aussie conference gets automatically bumped up the table, displacing "better" teams.
I appreciate that there are big differences, but one can see similarities too.
Why should the Zebras get automatic qualification when they would, in all likelihood, get beaten by most AP and T14 teams?
Posted 14:45 14th June 2012
froggy73 says...
@liam2me: you reckon English and French should copycat the Celtic league. Fine. Then Can the French and English have respectively 14 and 12 spots in the HCup then ? Then I promise would would never talk again about relegation.
Posted 13:54 14th June 2012
blametheref says...
Can the Planet Rugby writers please explain how when French and English teams are beaten in the Heineken Cup that is lopsided and unfair?...If they have problems with their own leagues and hold them more important than the Heineken Cup then that's their problem! Both the French and English leagues can adjust their leagues if they want, who is stopping them? Liam2me is dead right, we didn't hear any complaints from the French and English leagues when Toulouse, Leicester and Wasps were dominating Europe...Current European Champions, Leinster, have proved they are in the best in Europe and deserve their accolade as the best team in Europe...are the writers, Hastie, Morris and Skipper above seriously disputing that?
The editor says.... No one disputes that Leinster deserve their title. French and English clubs are protesting the fact the 'small' teams like Zebre and Connacht gain automatic qualification.
Posted 13:37 14th June 2012
Trinats2 says...
melkdave:
Rules have changed since the 70s !! You are allowed to present the ball when you have been tackle, hence why Pocock would have his hands on the ball while on the ground !!!
Posted 12:39 14th June 2012
fattysock says...
@trinats2
"But it would make great news in a "reputable" LOL tabloid paper when the best No.10 in the world is involved !!! "
I don't remember anyone ever mentioning Dan Carter with regards to this incident... ?
Posted 12:35 14th June 2012
new_j4a says...
@melkdave back to rugby! Yes, consider yourself pressed (several times). Please provide the minute and the Law you feel was violated for all of Pocock's "6+" offenses. As you may or may not remember (in your rather endearing decrepit twilight), there are circumstances in which being on the floor with your hands on the ball are, by convention if not explicitly in Law, deemed acceptable i.e. a tackled player who reaches backward, places and then holds the ball in that position is not usually penalized. So review the game and give us the minutes and law contraventions. While you are doing that, here's an interesting question: of the 2 sides, which has players lying about or standing around on the wrong side of the ruck most? I am not claiming that these were material or that they should have been penalized. Unlike jonthewannaberef, I think that decision is best made by the ref on the spot, and not in some Welsh valley deluged by rain and ignorance.
Posted 12:14 14th June 2012
mayhem says...
@ Jaystar, thanks for those, they are priceless!! PDV is a legend, of sorts!
Posted 12:03 14th June 2012
Trinats2 says...
markpat:
maybe Aus feel off the pace because most of them played 2/3 games in 7 days ? Nothing wrong with their pace in first half at 20-3. Or maybe because they were without 3 of the best backs in the world, or their captain to lead them ?
Not an excuse, just pointing out why they could have been off the pace. It was a poor 2nd half by Australian standards, but will take the win after the loss to Scotland.
Posted 11:12 14th June 2012
melkdave says...
@To All
I have one B cap from the 70s , su never the absolute top of rugby,I never clamed to have coached at international leval .just for a at the time a well regarded club ,and never as head coach..ie not a pub team.After injury cut short my playing career
To answer Trinet2 question .Pocock is clearly seen on the floor with his hands on the ball ,in the second half ,and isnt penalised for it..Thats one.id have to rewatch the entire match to get times ect (if they are still available ) ,and if really pressed i will
Now can we all please move on ,and just discuss rugby ,and not my life ,as its fairly ordinary imo,and yes im now an old decreped bugger ,in my twilight for all those wondering
Posted 10:46 14th June 2012
Trinats2 says...
new_j4a:
Pigs ?? Sheep ??? Have I missed something ?? or has it been swept under the carpet !!!
melkdave:
"what about QCs burglary last year" what burglary ??
There was an incident when Cooper was asked by a younder reds member to get back a laptop that was not paid for by two students he had sold to, police were called and the laptop was returned to the owner (those two students were charged and NOT Cooper, the young Reds member dropped charges as the two students were from overseas and may have been deported)
But it would make great news in a "reputable" LOL tabloid paper when the best No.10 in the world is involved !!!
Maybe the ARU should have read the tabloid and not the facts and Cooper would have been banned !
Posted 10:12 14th June 2012
markpat says...
Personally, I'm not convinced of the claim "In the end, the 4-0 whitewash suggests matching the pace and intensity of the southern hemisphere heavyweights remains a work in progress for their challengers from the North." either. Yes, SH won 4-0, but neither Aus or SA won because their pace and intensity was more than a match for their northen hemisphere challengers.
If anything, Aus were desperately hanging on because of the pace and intensity of the Welsh attack.
NZ yes. Didn't see the Argentina game to be able to comment.
Posted 09:59 14th June 2012
safehands says...
Have to agree with APV1 and NHSaints with regard to the Bok scrum. Neither team was dominant until the replacements came on. The prop for England, Dory Jones I think is his name, looks smaller than my 5 year old daughter....there was only one way that was going to turn out for England's forward pack once he came on.
Posted 07:38 14th June 2012
RugbyLeRoux says...
Nah english scrum is rubbish and it'll be funnier still to see Morgan being subbed after 15 mins when he's breathing out his arsehole at altitude!
Posted 06:58 14th June 2012
jonesy2 says...
pommy lads getting upset because their scrum is sh*te? dont worry maybe england will start scoring lots of dazzling tries (haha)
Posted 05:53 14th June 2012
hobo says...
the other incident is Quade Cooper and the laptop
Posted 04:53 14th June 2012
JayStarr says...
HAHAHAHAHAHA...!!! Did PdV really say that!? That's his best quote EVER... The Madiba of rugby! LOL! Can somebody please just do regular interviews with him or something... Can Supersport hire him as one of their "experts"... We MUST keep this man infront of a mic somehow...!!
When is someone going to bring out a book of PdVisms? There were some worth their weight in gold... Here are some of my favourites:
"There is little difference between winning and losing except you feel better after winning.''
"If I am the weakest link then we are bloody strong. I am a God-given talent.''
"I don't care if people don't understand me. It's not my duty to say directly to your face that you're ugly, I say you aren't pretty and if you can't read between the lines then it's not my problem. There's no pill for stupid" haha ha!
On the Boks' group at the RWC:
"In our group we are expecting tough games from Tonga and Fiji." - Tonga were not in the Boks' group!
Following Schalk Burger¿s banning during the Lions series:
"If we want to eye-gouge any Lions we will go down to the bushveld like we do and eye- gouge them there." LOL! WTF!?
Hahaha... There are actually tears running down my face right now - I forgot how insane this guy was! I miss him.
Here's a link to some more quotes: http://www.ougrote.com/snorisms/
Posted 03:24 14th June 2012
liam2me says...
The English and French should get their own houses in order before throwing the toys out of the pram. There was none of this bleating in the early 00s when the English sides dominated, now that they can't hack it they're crying foul. The relegation argument is just a pathetic excuse considering what's happening with London Welsh. If relegation is such a problem then get rid of it, it's obvious that the Celtic league set up is better so copy it instead of trying ti drag it down to the lower level of the AP
Posted 01:57 14th June 2012
new_j4a says...
@melkdave (deep respect please everybody...Dave has played at an international level and coached similar...he claims) melkdave, Sir, you seem to have forgotten to answer Trinats2 on the other thread. Since I am sure that this is an oversight due to the pressures one endures what with writing one's memoirs and fielding questions and requests for advice from other former internationals and coaches, I will reprint it here:
Trinats2 says...
melkdave:
Can you point out (in your opinion) just ONE of the "6 illegal plays by Pocock" Or were they the 6 he was penalised for ??
The world awaits, Sir, for you to cast "artificial pearls before real swine."
Posted 22:17 13th June 2012