Planet Rugby

Edinburgh

Edinburgh

Sorry, this story is unavailable

Comments

porridge_time says...

curates_egg...

Are you not grasping what the 'players player' is all about?

Posted 23:56 08th May 2012

darthbok says...

should have gone to southafrica -with a name like visser he would be playing for the Boks and no-one would have noticed!

Posted 18:07 08th May 2012

curates_egg says...

Jeez lads, you have serious chips on your shoulders (thistle_dave _ I would go and see a doctor about yours).

Visser may well be the best player in the league, however until the league is over, you cannot judge that. If one of the players in the four play-off teams has an outstanding couple of games, that is far more relevant to a season - in terms of individual player contribution.

Regardless of chooses the awards, try-scoring alone is not a sufficient criterion to judge a "player of the season" in a game where a multi-faceted skillset is required, like rugby.

Posted 14:03 08th May 2012

crunchfit says...

@thistle_dave

You may want to save the "Leinster entitlement talk" until someone from Leinster shows a sense of entitlement. I can't see a word which indicates anything like that, just the opinion that that Visser may not be curates_egg's first choice, which I would agree with. There are players in the pro12, Irish and non-Irish, who I feel have done more for their team and themselves, than Visser. Nothing do do with entitlement.

Posted 12:19 08th May 2012

porridge_time says...

curates_egg...

Visser was named Players' Player of the year. That means he was voted for by his peers and by all accounts it's well deserved. He has scored alot of tries in a team that have struggled in the league.

Posted 07:38 08th May 2012

thistle_dave says...

curates - since the PLAYER awards are clearly intended to recognise individual player attributes and performances, their overall team performance surely isn't relevant. The regular season has ended and so this would seem to be the appropriate time for such a recognition. I assume you hail from Dublin - your comments bear the sense of entitlement that seems to come with Leinster territory.

Posted 21:05 07th May 2012

melkdave says...

@atg77

Got to agree with you there lol,and yes i feel Scott and Ansbro / Grove could well be good centers for Scotland

Posted 16:22 07th May 2012

atg77 says...

The sooner we get Visser into a Scotland shirt the better. A back three of hogg, Visser and Jones (or Evans) is a very enticing prospect indeed. All Scotland needs now are centres who can pass the ball... Scott and Ansbro perhaps.

Posted 15:17 07th May 2012

curates_egg says...

Hmm. A number of problems with this, not least: the season is not over yet. Rather, the most important games are yet to come! How can you choose a player of the season at that stage. Surely the final games are the key ones.

Also, Visser may have scored lots of tries but Edinburgh are second from bottom.

In short, this is not serious.

Posted 12:42 07th May 2012

Page 1 of 1

Character Count : 0/1900

  • Edinburgh Fixtures
  • Edinburgh Results
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
RaboDirect PRO12
Friday , May 3
Edinburgh 31 - 24 Newport Gwent D'gonsEdinburgh vs Newport Gwent D
Friday , April 19
Benetton Treviso 30 - 10 Edinburgh
Friday , April 12
Edinburgh 24 - 32 Connacht
More RaboDirect PRO12 results
  • Table
Pool 1
Heineken Cup Table
PosTeamPPts
1Saracens623
2Munster620
3Racing Metro Paris612
4Edinburgh60