Planet Rugby

Argentina

Argentina

November Tests: XV of the Week

26th November 2012 11:35

Jonathan Sexton try Ireland v Argentina

Edging it at 10: Jonathan Sexton

Now that the dust has settled in the northern hemisphere, Planet Rugby looks at the guys who stole the show in week three of the November Tests.

Victories were picked up by France, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Tonga and Ireland in an entertaining round of international action.

So without further ado, here comes our offering - be sure to send in your own 15-1 team line-ups.

15 Andrea Masi (Italy) - One of the Azzurri's finest during their narrow defeat against Australia, the Wasp was a huge attacking threat - making over 100 metres with the ball in hand. Credit to Simon Zebo, who grabbed his first score for Ireland against the Pumas, and also Israel Dagg.

14 Fetu'u Vainikolo (Tonga) - Straight into the side after scoring a try his country will not forget for a long time. The Connacht wing's burst of pace left Tim Visser flat-footed and ultimately played a part in the sacking of coach Andy Robinson.

13 Conrad Smith (New Zealand) - 'Snake' was at his imperious best in Cardiff, his pass leading to flank Liam Messam's try on another dominant Saturday for the world champion All Blacks.

12 Jonathan Davies (Wales) - A positive note amidst the dross - Davies did his Lions chances no harm despite the heavy defeat against New Zealand, beating a handful of defenders. His effort in midfield when Jamie Roberts hobbled off sees him slot in here.

11 Craig Gilroy (Ireland) - The rise continues. Three tries against Fiji last week and now one on his senior Test debut against Argentina, whispers of the Lions are starting to increase.

10 Jonathan Sexton (Ireland) - A narrow race to this spot with Aaron Cruden and Frederic Michalak, but Johnny Sexton against Argentina looked like the Sexton from Leinster we have come to admire. Great distribution and kicking, plus two tries in an impressive shift.

9 Kahn Fotuali'i (Samoa) - Now seen as arguably the world's best scrum-half, Fotuali'i was always prominent, backing up a strong showing in Wales by constantly threatening France.

8 Duane Vermeulen (South Africa) - Was a colossus for the Boks and one feels that Pierre Spies will have a real task displacing the Stormers number eight when he returns from injury. Vermeulen never shies away from the physical and looks to have cemented his spot.

7 Richie McCaw (New Zealand) - Simply outstanding. 21 tackles to go with streetwise work at the breakdown. He anticipates so much before his opponents and was a cut above his rival sevens over the weekend. One more game to go until he can put his feet up for a bit.

6 Taiasina Tuifua (Samoa) - This positional shift is due to a blend of a lack of blindsides shining and the impressive form of the Samoan. He was superb against Wales the week before and backed that up against France as the islanders came mighty close to winning.

5 Luke Romano (New Zealand) - We almost handed our five jersey to the ever-improving Donnacha Ryan after another big effort from him. But Romano was a carrying machine for the All Blacks and finished his try well in Cardiff. Mention for Samoa's Joe Tekori.

4 Eben Etzebeth (South Africa) - Has been on the receiving end of a fair share of criticism of late and was once again in the thick of it against England, notably with scrum-half Ben Youngs. However, the physicality of the young lock was a key reason why the Boks won.

3 Census Johnson (Samoa) - Toulouse's star prop was one of the first names down on our teamsheet this week after an all-action performance that was highlighted by his nice chip kick that set up David Lemi's score. Owen Franks earns a mention as does Dan Cole.

2 Richardt Strauss (Ireland) - It was slim pickings in the hooking department this weekend but Strauss edges his cousin as our number two. Got 74 minutes in a strong team effort.

1 Cian Healy (Ireland) - Alex Corbisiero got the better of Jannie du Plessis at scrum-time while Sona Taumalolo put in another Herculean performance. But in Healy, Ireland and the British & Irish Lions arguably have the number one loosehead in the world game right now.

By Ben Coles and Adam Kyriacou
@bencoles_ and @PlanetRugbyAK

Comments

Tyler_Durden says...

Bloemboy - it's Carter then daylight, champ. 10 years of sustained excellence is not trumped by 3 good games in November.

Posted 06:28 27th November 2012

Tyler_Durden says...

Lenistergoy the inclusion of Sexto is a no-brainer. the best fly-half in the NH for the past 3 and a half years (and fast approaching best in the world)"...

So, better than Carter then? From where i'm sitting he looks great for Leinster and decidedly average at test level, until he can start producing his club form for Ireland he cannot be considered world class, and certainly not the worlds best.

Posted 06:22 27th November 2012

nzmaoriboy says...

Southern hemisphere site rugbyheaven XV is...

15.Dagg 14.Bowe 13.Smith 12.Mermoz 11.Gilroy 10.Cruden 9. Kahn 8.Palu 7.Mccaw 6.Alberts 5.Whitelock 4.Donnacha 3.Census 2.R.Struass 1. Woodcock

Posted 06:18 27th November 2012

Mace says...

Come on PR what about Andrew Hore? That shot alone should be his inclusion hahaha.

Posted 06:06 27th November 2012

ferdie says...

Isograford - think you'll find Kahn Fotuali'i made it known early on - before 2010 - he wanted to represent Samoa rather than NZ, and as such made himself unavailable for All Black selection. His choice, and his right, he meets the Samoan ancestry elegibility requirements.

Posted 02:06 27th November 2012

missionary says...

@ Gleek - Woodcock by a considerable stretch. Gimme a break.

@sonsofsamoa - on Kahn. Great player but A. Smith is right there too. Always thought Kahn should have been more patient. When he left, he was the best HB in NZ.

Posted 23:57 26th November 2012

Andrewinkorea says...

Where can I find your picks for the previous 2 rounds? PR always goes out of its way to defend English selections by saying the writers are not English. But I am absolutely sure the first week was laced with Englishmen after their facile victory over Fiji. It seems when other teams do the same, their players are overlooked.

Posted 23:53 26th November 2012

ben7 says...

@Leinster_goy

"the inclusion of Sexto is a no-brainer. the best fly-half in the NH for the past 3 and a half years (and fast approaching best in the world)".... Now that bit about him soon being the best in the world is one of the funniest things i have heard in a long time hahahaha. He is behind carter, cruden, lambie, goosen, beale, barnes, michalak, hernandez, pisi and maybe even morne steyn....

Posted 23:50 26th November 2012

ben7 says...

Cian Healy the worlds best loosehead?? Are you mad?? Ireland have one of the worst scrums in world rugby and he is partly to blame. I would choose mtawarira, woodcock, corbisiero and steenkamp over him any day!

Posted 23:40 26th November 2012

joonyk1 says...

@jmanngod- Why on earth does Hore deserve to be anywhere near this list? He knocked out an opposing player with a sucker punch. Hardly worthy of being player of the week.

I think there is a lot of bias in the comments section here. I would also say that it appears half the people commenting didn't even watch the matches. I personally think PR were have done a good job with these choices.

Posted 22:37 26th November 2012

georgesmith says...

Where is grandpa N.Sharpe? Coach of the November series should be R. 'Hopeless' Deans.

Posted 22:29 26th November 2012

kennyisgay says...

I still don't understand how a team with so called the best loose head in the world, the best fly half in the NH who is apparently fast becoming the best in the world, could allow there ass to be spanked 60 nil. Or is there a different world north of the equator. Kahn is without doubt the best 9 in the world right now.

Posted 22:08 26th November 2012

yuri29 says...

@leinster_goy says..."the inclusion of Sexto is a no-brainer. the best fly-half in the NH for the past 3 and a half years (and fast approaching best in the world) "

Except Michalak is better.

Sexton has yet to produce big performance against the top international teams contrary to Michalak.

But well, i guess it's useless to try to convince you considering you're a leinster fan.

Posted 22:07 26th November 2012

lacroix says...

cian healy the best LH in the world?

he's not even in the top 5.

sexton at 10 is a bit silly.

i agree with toulousain- far too many french players in this team :)

Posted 21:21 26th November 2012

BokAvenger says...

Gilroy ahead of JP Pietersen. HA, HA, HA, HA, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha!

Posted 20:58 26th November 2012

froggy73 says...

@leinster-goy: all you can talk about is Leinster or Leinster players. Even when on international games, you manage to only talk about Leinster. How boring. I guess the wall of your bedroom must be entirely covered with posters of Sexton, O'Driscoll and co. Have a life mate. Watch some real rugby for a change.

Posted 20:18 26th November 2012

johnniegordon says...

With these selections it is easy to understand why Northern Hemisphere teams don't win many games.

LOL

Posted 19:52 26th November 2012

JayStarr says...

I'm losing my mind... I meant to say JP Pietersen was by far the best 14. He didn't score a try, but he was all over the place and was simply brilliant.

Posted 19:36 26th November 2012

pog_mahone says...

I am an admirer of Dagg and normally regard him as the best in his position in the world (he outshone Kearney 3-0 in June) but I thought he had a poor game on Sat.

Posted 18:51 26th November 2012

Ripzy007 says...

Is there a better half back at the moment? Genia is out and Smith is playing great rugby but 'arguably' Kahn is playing better than any during these Northern tours, IMHO.

Posted 18:46 26th November 2012

Page 2 of 4

Character Count : 0/1900

  • Argentina Fixtures
Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
International Match
Saturday , June 8
Argentina vs England20:10
Saturday , June 15
Argentina vs England20:10
More International Match fixtures
Rugby Championship
Saturday , August 17
South Africa vs ArgentinaTBC
More Rugby Championship fixtures
  • Table
League
Rugby Championship Table
PosTeamPPts
1New Zealand626
2Australia612
3South Africa612
4Argentina64